• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Comment Policy
    • Disclosures & Disclaimers
  • Resources
    • Links, Essays & Articles
    • Fandomology!
    • CLAMP Directory
    • BlogRoll
  • Features & Columns
    • 3 Things Thursday
    • Adventures in the Key of Shoujo
    • Bit & Blips (game reviews)
    • BL BOOKRACK
    • Bookshelf Briefs
    • Bringing the Drama
    • Comic Conversion
    • Fanservice Friday
    • Going Digital
    • It Came From the Sinosphere
    • License This!
    • Magazine no Mori
    • My Week in Manga
    • OFF THE SHELF
    • Not By Manga Alone
    • PICK OF THE WEEK
    • Subtitles & Sensibility
    • Weekly Shonen Jump Recaps
  • Manga Moveable Feast
    • MMF Full Archive
    • Yun Kouga
    • CLAMP
    • Shojo Beat
    • Osamu Tezuka
    • Sailor Moon
    • Fruits Basket
    • Takehiko Inoue
    • Wild Adapter
    • One Piece
    • After School Nightmare
    • Karakuri Odette
    • Paradise Kiss
    • The Color Trilogy
    • To Terra…
    • Sexy Voice & Robo
  • Browse by Author
    • Sean Gaffney
    • Anna Neatrour
    • Michelle Smith
    • Katherine Dacey
    • MJ
    • Brigid Alverson
    • Travis Anderson
    • Phillip Anthony
    • Derek Bown
    • Jaci Dahlvang
    • Angela Eastman
    • Erica Friedman
    • Sara K.
    • Megan Purdy
    • Emily Snodgrass
    • Nancy Thistlethwaite
    • Eva Volin
    • David Welsh
  • MB Blogs
    • A Case Suitable For Treatment
    • Experiments in Manga
    • MangaBlog
    • The Manga Critic
    • Manga Report
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • Manga Curmudgeon (archive)

Manga Bookshelf

Discussion, Resources, Roundtables, & Reviews

Blog

Dorohedoro, Vol. 18

April 20, 2016 by Sean Gaffney

By Q Hayashida. Released in Japan by Shogakukan, serialization ongoing in the magazine Hibana. Released in North America by Viz.

Well, I said last time that I thought Dorohedoro might get a little more gory in the next volume, and I was not wrong. Dorohedoro is something of a horror-fantasy-comedy, and frequently the horror elements take precedence, as they do in this volume big time. It mostly plays out with the fates of Shin and Noi. Noi’s love for Shin has seemed a bit one-sided at times, but we no know that he does want to protect her, even if it means slicing her brain open and inserting Sho’s ‘thingy’ into her head. (I’m sure the sexual implications are intentional.) Of course, he should maybe think about protecting himself, as somehow (as always, it can be difficult to follow chains of events without a reread) Shim ends up in a corpse factory, and seemingly killed and turned into a murderous zombie. Whoops.

dorohedoro18

Not that things are any better with the other groups. Fujita’s invisibility has worn off, and he’s forced to make an uneasy peace with the cross-eyed guy, though we hear both of them ;planning to double cross each other later. (Fujita is good at being idealistic and self-sacrificing, less good at scheming.) Of course, given they run into zombie Shin, neither plan is really going to come off. Noi, once she recovers from Shin’s lobotomy, ends up finding a trail of body parts, Hansel-and-Gretel style. And Nikaido’s group is torn up as well, as the department store is going to hell – possibly literally – and Risu and Asu both end up getting taken out over the course of the volume. This may not, admittedly, matter much to Nikaido, who is getting more like a Devil than ever, and spends most of the volume with a giant :D expression on her face.

In between all this gore, there is still something of a plot, most of it taking place with Kasukabe, who through a wacky set of circumstances ends up inside his wife Haru’s devil body, as the devils attempt to figure out what the hell is going on with Ai. Your guess is as good as mine, but we do see that Ai and company apparently have a revolving set of heads, although some are already dead. Whatever it is, it leads to a cliffhanger that I wasn’t expecting, as Nikaido discovers Caiman – with his lizard head, and seemingly with his regular old gyoza-lovin’ memories. The reunion will have to wait for next time, though. Oh yes, as an added bonus, we see what’s happening with En in hell, and it’s not pretty, though it is pretty funny.

I’ve often said Dorohedoro is not for the squeamish, and this volume proves that more than ever. But if you don’t mind blood, gore and dismemberment in graphic detail, it’s hard to think of a title out there with more style than this one. Which, as anyone will tell you, is far more important than pesky things like a coherent plot.

Filed Under: REVIEWS

Bookshelf Briefs 4/18/16

April 18, 2016 by Sean Gaffney and Michelle Smith Leave a Comment

Brace yourself for a briefy onslaught!

akuma3Akuma no Riddle, Vol. 3 | By Yun Kouga and Sunao Minakata | Seven Seas – Sadly, this series is proving to have diminishing returns, and I wonder if it’s being written for a set number of volumes, as I feel it’s not really taking the time to develop each assassin before we get their tragic backstory and they’re summarily removed from the story. As I predicted, the Takarazuka pair are one of the main focuses here, and turn out to be somewhat star-crossed themselves, so it’s appropriate that they kill each other. (Or do they? There’s some “recovering in hospital” talk here.) As for Azuma, I think she’s realized that there’s something deeper going on with Haru, but doesn’t really seem to care. I’m still following this, but do wonder what it will do when it runs out of girls .– Sean Gaffney

magus4The Ancient Magus’ Bride, Vol. 4 | By Kore Yamazaki | Seven Seas – Given how this series is trying to develop Chise as a bride, and Elias is very much a paternal mentor character, at some point the author was going to have to, if not walk things back, at least even things out a bit. On Chise’s end, this comes by letting her grow into more power, as she gets a staff of her own, and now finds she can recall happy memories of her past in Japan, not just nightmares. For Elias, it shows us that in many ways he is just as innocent as she, and that much of what we assumed was a guiding hand was simply his total inability to ‘get’ human emotions. Now that Chise understands this as well, will they get closer? I don’t really care, so long as we get more pretty fantasy, to be honest. – Sean Gaffney

centaur8A Centaur’s Life, Vol. 8 | By Kei Murayama | Seven Seas – I begged for more focus last time, and unfortunately that’s not what I get. I suppose that’s one of the selling points of the series, you never know what you’ll get in any chapter. At its best, you get discussion on the true nature of modern art and discussion on how siblings can be very different even if they’re from the same family. At its worst, you get that cover, and a fantasy sequence where half the cast are menaced by sentient clothing-dissolving goo. And at its most problematic, we see this series’ fantasy version of Nazi Germany, which tries to show that racism is something we should overcome, while at the same time noting that it’s ubiquitous in human nature no matter if the species aren’t human. I can’t decide who would enjoy this. – Sean Gaffney

food11Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma, Vol. 11 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | Viz Media – As I expected, the villain who specializes in imitation finds that he’s weak to last-minute improvisation on Soma’s part. Also as expected, he has a somewhat sad backstory, though honestly it’s only average compared to some folks here. The best part was Soma convincing him not to leave the school but keep striving to do better as a chef. Meanwhile, Ryo and Akira prove to be almost equally matched—in fact, so equally matched that it ends up being a tie, meaning that the next volume will have a three-way final. I expect Soma will lose, as it’s far too early in a Shonen Jump series to have him win a competition like this. The joy will be in seeing how he responds to that adversity. Good stuff. – Sean Gaffney

Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma, Vol. 11 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | VIZ Media – Man, there were a lot of fanservice-y reaction shots in this volume! I guess that’s to be expected, given that we’re in the semi-final round of the Fall Classic, but it does still bug me that in one moment, female chefs are lauded as “culinary monsters” and in the next, everything is all about their boobs. Sigh. Anyway, the actual cooking in this volume is pretty great, especially the beef stew battle between Soma and copycat Mimasaka. Also, as a Southerner, I was amused by the crowd’s reaction to the foreign notion of mesquite. I was less captivated by the matchup between the other two semifinalists (eel and prunes?! UGH!) but am looking forward to the finals! – Michelle Smith

mls8My Love Story!!, Vol. 8 | By Kazune Kawahara and Aruko | Viz Media – This is perhaps the first volume of My Love Story!! that I wasn’t 100% happy with. Oh, don’t get me wrong; there’s still lots of wonderfulness here, particularly between our main couple. But if you are going to have a guy forcibly kiss someone, and then have Takeo whack him and tell him that this was the wrong thing to do, don’t then reward him anyway 20 or so pages later. It sends the wrong message. I’m also not too pleased with the guy introduced towards the end, though we don’t get to see too much of him. Most of the obstacles to Takeo and Yamato have been subtly handled, but this looks like it may be as subtle as a brick. That said, despite these faults, this remains essential reading. – Sean Gaffney

shuriken1Shuriken and Pleats, Vol. 1 | By Matsuri Hino | VIZ Media – I suppose the good news is that I ended up liking Shuriken and Pleats more than I expected to. Mikage has been raised as a ninja, and while that imbues her with admirable characteristics like level-headedness and competence, it also means that she hasn’t been encouraged to feel emotion or consider her future goals. After her master is killed, she attempts to heed his wishes for her happiness by moving to Japan and becoming a regular schoolgirl, but gets embroiled in more trouble. Honestly, all the stuff about rival ninjas and seeds and poisons and antidotes is incredibly boring, but I liked Mikage’s journey towards becoming a regular girl in mourning for someone she loved very much. I’ll definitely read the second and final volume! – Michelle Smith

toriko33Toriko, Vol. 33 | By Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro | Viz Media – Well, I only have myself to blame. After ending my last review worried that Komatsu was going to be kidnapped or killed off, we get a bit of both, as he’s now in a coma with a void where his heart should be. As a result, Toriko and friends have to head to a kingdom of giant plant life, ruled by a monkey king that we don’t see much of but I suspect will prove to be difficult. We also get some disturbing post-fight images, as several monkeys that face off against Toriko are later shown to have killed themselves in order to make amends. Toriko, thankfully, finds one who hasn’t yet and explains why it’s the wrong thing to do. Still not as much food love here, but there’s typical Jump battles to make up for it. – Sean Gaffney

yamada7Yamada-kun and the Seven Witches, Vol. 7 | By Miki Yoshikawa | Kodansha Comics – We actually get a lot of new information here. First of all, witches can have their powers removed—which comes as a relief to Maria, whose future-vision is a pain in the ass. The guy who can do it turns out to also be running for student council president. We meet Miyamura’s sister, who was close to finding the seventh witch before something completely broke her. But perhaps most importantly, Yamada has finally realized that his feelings for Shiraishi are love. Naturally, this leads to more problems, but I am pleased with how things are progressing, and at this rate I suspect the series should be done in four or five more volumes. (Looks at current volume count.) Oh. – Sean Gaffney

Filed Under: Bookshelf Briefs

My Week in Manga: April 11-April 17, 2016

April 18, 2016 by Ash Brown

My News and Reviews

As I alluded to a few months ago, I’ve been in the process of trying to purchase a house. Well, I finally made it happen! I signed all of the papers on Friday, so for the foreseeable I’m going to be a little preoccupied getting things ready and moving over to the new place. It’s all sorts of exciting, but it does mean I’ll have significantly less time to devote to other things for a while. And so, I’m back to a reduced posting schedule at Experiments in Manga for the time being. Expect to continue to regularly see My Week in Manga, but there will probably only be one other review or feature most weeks. That all being said, last week I reviewed the recently released Midnight Stranger, Volume 1, a supernatural boys’ love manga with a sense of humor (as well as some pretty great monster designs) by Bohra Naono. I haven’t seen a lot of manga news over the last week, although I’m sure there has been some, but I did want to mention that Viz Media has licensed Kohske and Syuhei Kamo’s Gangsta: Cursed, a prequel series to Gangsta (a manga of which I’m particularly fond.)

Quick Takes

Itazura na Kiss, Volume 7Itazura na Kiss, Volumes 7-8 by Kaoru Tada. It’s been a little while since I’ve read any of Itazura na Kiss, but it’s a pretty easy series to put down and pick up again since nothing of major importance really ever seems to change all that much. I have been enjoying the series, but I’m starting to long for a little more forward momentum and the characters are beginning to wear me down a little. At the same time, while the overall pacing is fairly slow, Tada is expert in changing and moving the story along just enough to keep things interesting. Kotoko and Naoki are now newlyweds, but otherwise their relationship is pretty par for the course. Kotoko is utterly infatuated with Naoki, and Naoki continues to be fairly cold towards her. Thankfully, Kotoko is (slowly) beginning to mature and determine for herself what it is she really wants to do with her life. It can be difficult to tell at times, but Naoki really does love Kotoko and cares for her well-being, he just tends to be a total ass about it which can be tiresome. Granted, it does make it particularly satisfying when he ends up being thrown out of his comfort zone.

The JudgedThe Judged by Akira Honma. Having greatly enjoyed the first two volumes of Honma’s Rabbit Man, Tiger Man boys’ love series, and considering the fact that the third and final volume is unlikely to ever be released in English, I decided to seek out the creator’s other works in translation. I didn’t realize it until I finished reading manga, but The Judged was actually Honma’s first volume to be released as a professional mangaka. The titular story is about a prosecuting investigator and member of the Diet who are navigating a political scandal, while their shared past makes things even more complicated. The Judged also includes Honma’s debut manga “Like a White Phantom” about an initially antagonistic relationship between two young doctors. For the most part, the focus of The Judged is more on the drama and less on the romance. The manga tends to be fairly serious and the relationships aren’t necessarily the most healthy. They’re not always particularly happy relationships, either. Many of the characters have some pretty heavy personal issues do deal with, including physical and emotional abuse.

Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth, Side: P3, Volume 1Persona Q: Shadow of the Labyrinth, Side: P3, Volume 1 by So Tobita. The Persona series is perhaps the most popular subset of the larger Shin Megami Tensei video game franchise. Persona Q is a relatively recent spinoff from 2014 made for the Nintendo 3DS which combines characters from Persona 3 and Persona 4—a player can choose to experience the game from either perspective. Likewise, a reader can choose from either the Side: P3 or Side: P4 manga adaptation which present two different sides of the same story. When it comes to manga adaptations of video games, there seem to be two major types, those that are accessible to anyone and those that are intended to be appreciated by fans of the original. So far, the Side P3 manga would seem to be one of the latter, requiring some prior knowledge of the franchise to fully enjoy the series. Very little is explained about the world or the characters in the manga itself. But for those who are familiar with Persona, the Side: P3 manga can be a fun way to quickly experience or re-experience the story and game of Persona Q, though I’m not sure that it really adds anything new.

Filed Under: FEATURES, My Week in Manga Tagged With: Akira Honma, itazura na kiss, Kaoru Tada, manga, Persona, Shin Megami Tensei, So Tobita

Pick of the Week: Gods and Rosaries

April 18, 2016 by Sean Gaffney Leave a Comment

godslieMICHELLE: I will undoubtedly procure and adore volume thirteen of Say I Love You., but I am most eager to read The Gods Lie, particularly after Ash pointed out it’s by the mangaka behind Immortal Rain, which I loved!

SEAN: I tend to be the light novel fan of Manga Bookshelf, and my attention is torn between two titles this month, one famous, one infamous. Best to err on the famous side, I think, so I’ll pick the 7th volume of Sword Art Online, Mother’s Rosary, which gives Asuna the focus she’s so richly needed.

ASH: It’s undoubtedly The Gods Lie for me! I’m very happy to see more manga by Kaori Ozaki available in translation (I was a big fan of Immortal Rain). This volume may very well be one of my most anticipated releases of the year!

ANNA: I have to go with The Gods Lie too. It wasn’t on my radar before I realized who the author was, but now I’m very very interested in checking out this title.

MJ: I am certainly interested in the latest Sword Art Online novel, but I’m afraid I must join this week’s landslide towards The Gods Lie. Somehow this was entirely off my radar, but what a great surprise!

Filed Under: PICK OF THE WEEK

My Hero Academia Vol 1

April 17, 2016 by Anna N

My Hero Academia Volume 1 by Hohei Horikoshi

So Viz has one hilarious send-up of the superhero genre in One-Punch Man. I was curious to see how the more mainstream and shonen take on the superhero genre would read. My Hero Academia seems to be gunning more for traditional western superhero genre, with the issue numbering rectangle on the top left of the cover just as you would expect from an American comic.

The set-up for My Hero Academia also reminded me of Tiger & Bunny a bit, in the way that super villains and superheroes are treated like an extension of celebrity culture. Over 80 percent of the world’s population has unusual abilities, or “quirks”. Like most shonen heroes, Izuku Midoriya is nothing special. He’s unusual in his ordinariness, as he is one of the few kids in his class at school who has no abilities. He’s picked on and bullied by the other kids in his class, but he’s determined to get into the hero training program somehow. Izuku has a fateful encounter with the superhero All Might, who looks like a slightly better proportioned Rob Liefeld character.

mh1

It turns out that after All Might uses his power, his muscles deflate and he becomes a skeletal creature who suffers from a variety of physical problems. He can only sustain his power for three hours a day before he reverts into his normal form. All Might decides that it is time to pass along his power to a new person, and he picks Izuku, after witnessing Izuku take on a super villain with nothing but the determination to save someone else. Izuku is a pretty typical shonen hero in his determination to become a hero, but his immediate reaction when he sees someone in danger is to sacrifice himself. Although Izuku might have All Might’s power as a legacy, he has no idea how to control it.

Ikuzu winds up going to hero training school along with his school bully, and meets some other kids who are also determined to be heroes. Izuku’s lack of control of his new powers causes him to perform heroic acts with just his fingertip, because the power is too much for him. There’s a lot of set-up and story packed into this first volume, so I’m actually interested to see what happens next once all the characters and background are established. Horikoshi switches between different styles of characture with ease, and the contrast between All Might’s heroic and ordinary form is funny. Ikuzu spends most of this volume looking either incredibly hopeful and enthusiastic or absolutely terrified. The action scenes were for the most part easy to follow, but some of the paneling was a bit cluttered at times, and I think occasionally the art suffered a bit from being shrunk down from the original magazine format it was serialized in. My Hero Academia was quirky enough to appeal to me, and I’m generally picky about shonen series. I’ll see if the next few volumes continue to hold up well.

Filed Under: REVIEWS Tagged With: My Hero Academia, Shonen, viz media

Kindred Spirits on the Roof

April 17, 2016 by Sean Gaffney

By Liar Soft. Released in Japan as “Okujou no Yurirei-san”. Released in North America by Mangagamer, also available on the Steam app.

In general I don’t review visual novels on this site, but I’d heard a lot about this one. First of all, it was hyped as being “uncensored” on Steam’s site, as if it was supposed to have a ton of porn in it. (Spoilers: there’s not much here TO censor.) Secondly, it was hyped as being a ‘yuri’ game that wasn’t marketed to the male otaku market – indeed, it reads a lot of the time as if it’s meant for female readers. But most importantly, it has strong plot and character development, is amusing and as realistic as you can get for a game starring two ghosts, and you just like it a lot.

Kindred_Spirits_on_the_Roof_Logo

The premise is that our heroine, Yuna, spends much of her time on the roof avoiding socialization due to a trauma from her past. While on the roof, though, she finds who ghosts (only she can see them), who are able to convince her through a mixture of politely asking and being excited about the whole thing (as well as a few veiled threats) to help the two of them hook up various female couples at the school. The goal is that when they hook up, they’ll get it on in the school itself. Since the ghosts can’t leave the campus, this is the only way they can really see how girls “do it”.

After typing that out, I realize that those who read me talking about a realistic, well-developed game are pointing and laughing by now. But it actually does a good job. Most of the cast get backstories that help make sense of their character and show why they have their various personality quirks. Two of the girls are already a couple before the series begins, and two of the girls, against all odds, don’t hook up with anyone. (It’s a very linear visual novel – you can’t make choices that really influence the game). As for the couples themselves, they’re not all the same types.

While the word ‘lesbian’ is not explicitly used, it’s made clear throughout that these are meant to be real relationships that last beyond high school. Some of the girls are thinking about their future plans as a couple, or how to explain things to their parents. One even explicitly says that she’s always been attracted to women, which helpfully avoids the “what is this strange feeling in my chest?” cliche, though we get that as well.

We get three types of ‘scenes’ we can read. The main one has a bear icon, and is Yuna going through her school life and attempting to make vague efforts to help the ghosts hook people up (though, by her own admission, her role is very passive) while also moving past her middle school trauma, embracing the fact that she’s really a take-charge leader sort, and finding her own love she was totally unaware of (it was under her nose all along! – the game is still filled with cliches, fear not). As the plot moves along, you get ‘cherry’ scenes, which are from the POV of the various other girls, showing us scenes that happens when Yuna isn’t there.

Speaking of which, several of those scenes involve sex. That said, though there is mild nudity (a few breasts) and some explicit terminology, anyone who buys this for the “good bits” will regret it immensely. As for the sex writing, it’s not horrible, but also not great – the post-coital pillow talk is usually more important.

After you complete the game’s main “plot”, you unlock various ‘apple’ marked scenes, and can unlock more by going back to the game and making the pointless choice you didn’t make before. (As I said, nothing affects the main plot, so you mostly just get briefly different dialogue). The ‘apple’ scenes are basically the same as the ‘cherry’ scenes, only they tend to involve spoilers – i.e., the characters reflect on things the reader was unaware of at the time. This can occasionally be harmful to the game itself – Hina gets most of her development in these apple scenes, as the game wanted her to be the stoic girl whose thoughts were a mystery to us. Which is fine, and she’s one of my favorites, but this led to her being undercharacterized for most of the game itself.

There are elements that don’t work. I mentioned Hina’s development already. Another character, Ano, has two conflicting sides that don’t always mesh very well together in the writing. There is also a teacher/student relationship, which is handled as well as can be expected, but I’d still rather have done without, especially as the teacher is the standard ‘looks like a little kid’ type. And of course, being a visual novel, you’d better be prepared for reading a whole lot of text, with repetitive music. The game is partially voiced, piping up for important scenes.

Overall, I’m pleased that I got this game, which ended up being better than I expected. The girls are all fairly intelligent, or at least idiotic in a fun, amusing way. The pairings all make sense. There’s a lot of content to justify its somewhat expensive price. And it treats its sexuality seriously, and has the girls thinking seriously about it. (Indeed, one of the two ‘unpaired’ girls, Nena, could easily be asexual and aromantic judging from the text.) If you’re curious about this sort of thing, it’s definitely recommended.

Filed Under: REVIEWS

Manga the Week of 4/20

April 14, 2016 by Sean Gaffney, Michelle Smith, Anna N, Ash Brown and MJ 1 Comment

SEAN: There’s a lot of variety out next week. Something from almost every major publisher.

lheartdk4

Kodansha gives us a fourth volume of L♥DK, everyone’s favorite “what is this thing you call consent?” shoujo romance.

MICHELLE: *snerk*

SEAN: And Noragami’s monthly release schedule chugs along with lucky Vol. 13.

Also reaching Vol. 13 is Say “I Love You”, which was introduced at the same time as My Little Monster but has zoomed past it, moving on to new volumes and new complications.

MICHELLE: I’m glad that one of them at least is still going to be around a while!

ANNA: So far behind on this, I feel guilty.

SEAN: And there’s the penultimate 6th volume of A Silent Voice, which ended with a hell of a cliffhanger last time, so I’m expecting some very good resolution from it.

ASH: I’m a few volumes behind, but this is such a great series.

SEAN: One Peace has the 2nd volume of the manga adaptation of Rise of the Shield Hero (they call it a “manga companion”, but I think it’s just a standard adaptation of the light novel).

ASH: I’m pretty sure you’re correct.

SEAN: Seven Seas has enjoyed giving us some bleak horror lately, and for those who love it, here’s a 7th Magical Girl Apocalypse.

I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the first volume of My Monster Secret, and so look forward to the second.

godslie

Vertical debuts a one-shot called The Gods Lie, which they are touting as a sports manga license. I suspect their tongue is firmly in their cheek, but either way it will be worth your time.

MICHELLE: I’m looking forward to reading this one.

ASH: As am I! I loved Immortal Rain, so I’m glad to see more of Ozaki’s work being released in English.

MICHELLE: Oh, I hadn’t made that connection! Awesome!

ANNA: What!!!! I have the first two volumes of Immortal Rain and am sad I didn’t pick up the whole series when it was in print. This is now in my Amazon cart!

MJ: Oh, this is exciting!

SEAN: And there’s a 4th Ninja Slayer volume. Are there ninjas? Will they slay? Read on to find out!

Who’s the cool seinen manga that’s got all the indie comic artists raving? Dorohedoro? Damn right. Vol. 18 drops next week.

ASH: Yeah!

SEAN: There’s also an 8th volume of the Perfect Edition of Monster.

And a 6th Tokyo Ghoul, which everyone loves but which I am strangely indifferent to.

MJ: If it makes you feel better, I haven’t gotten into it, either.

SEAN: Yen, meanwhile, is releasing its light novels a week before its other stuff, which is nice of them. That means we get a 3rd volume of Black Bullet, with its loli killers.

There’s a 4th volume of “what if Satan worked at McDonald’s” favorite The Devil Is A Part-Timer!. And if you like digital titles (as I do), Vols. 1-4 will be available digitally next week as well.

irregular1

The Irregular at Magic High School finally debuts, and it’s apparently one of the most polarizing titles in Western anime fandom. I’ve heard it called “Batman at Hogwarts”, myself. Also, is the term Mary Sue – or in this case Gary Stu – even relevant anymore?

And there’s a 5th volume of Is It Wrong To Try To Pick Up Girls In A Dungeon?, and its title continues to be the worst thing about it – I am eager for more.

Spice & Wolf comes to an end with its 17th novel, proving that you can combine cute wolf girls and economic theory if you try.

ASH: I stopped reading about half-way through, but I am glad to see that Yen was able to publish the entire series.

SEAN: Lastly, the 7th Sword Art Online novel, Mother’s Rosary, is widely considered one of its best, possibly as Kirito plays only a minor role. Asuna fans should be very happy.

MJ: I’m down for this.

SEAN: Which titles make your pure maiden’s heart tremble?

Filed Under: FEATURES, manga the week of

Midnight Stranger, Vol. 1

April 14, 2016 by Ash Brown

Midnight Stranger, Volume 1Creator: Bohra Naono
U.S. publisher: Viz Media
ISBN: 9781421579689
Released: April 2016
Original release: 2013

Midnight Stranger is the third boys’ love manga and the first series by Bohra Naono to be released in English. Naono’s first manga to be translated was Yokai’s Hunger which was initially released in print by Media Blasters but is now available digitally through Sublime Manga, the boys’ love line associated with Viz Media. Sublime also released Naono’s second manga in translation, Three Wolves Mountain, which along with Norikazu Akira’s Honey Darling was actually one of the publishers’ debut titles. Midnight Stranger is a short, two-volume series, the first of which was published in Japan in 2013. In English, Midnight Stranger, Volume 1 was released by Sublime in 2016. Like Naono’s other translated manga, Midnight Stranger has strong supernatural elements which can be fun but rather peculiar, a fair amount of comedy, and Naono’s penchant for older men. I’ve enjoyed Naono’s work in the past, so I was very glad to have the opportunity to receive a copy of the first volume of Midnight Stranger for review.

Midnight Stranger, Volume 1 contains two major storylines which aren’t directly related to each other but which could conceivably take place in the same setting. The volume opens with the titular “Midnight Stranger” and its followup chapter “Love-Hate” which are about Roitschaggata, a minor goat spirit, and Xiuhtecuhtli, an old and powerful god of fire. (The two are also the focus of the volume’s bonus chapter, “The Point of a Day Off.”) Centuries ago, due to the ugliness of his original form, Roi was mistaken for a monster rather than the benevolent spirit of healing that he is. He was nearly burned alive by a mob of humans, but was saved and granted more appealing looks by Xiu. The two of them now live together in modern-day Japan—Roi utterly devoted to his god, and Xiu oddly fond and possessive of his adoring servant. The second storyline collected in Midnight Stranger, and the basis for the four-panel comics included at the volume’s end, is “Hollow Romance,” a manga about a seemingly innocent young man named Takara Mori who is both more and less than he seems and the literal demons surrounding him.

Midnight Stranger, Volume 1, page 25Although I’ve somewhat come to expect it from Naono’s manga, the supernatural aspects of Midnight Stranger are all over the place and the worldbuilding isn’t necessarily cohesive. Xiu is based on an Aztec deity, Roi I believe is inspired by Swiss traditions, “Hollow Romance” incorporates Nordic legends, and there is a variety of other mythological beings present in the manga as well. It’s never really explicitly explained why all of these deities, demons, spirits, and legends from vastly different cultures and geographies are interacting with one another, but clearly in Midnight Stranger gods and beliefs aren’t restricted by countries or borders. The unexpected combinations, while seemingly haphazard, can be surprisingly entertaining, though. But while Naono has taken inspiration from multiples sources, which is something that I enjoy about her work, her interpretations are very much her own and frequently very little of the original tales remain. Xiu, for example, retains his name and has an appropriately fiery temper and flashy personality, but otherwise his connection to Mesoamerica is largely nonexistent.

Humor is also prominent in Midnight Stranger, though in tone the manga does shift between comedic and ominous. Granted, there is plenty to find amusing or ridiculous in Midnight Stranger, such as Xiu making his living in the mortal world as an idol or Roi gaining a young boy he cured as a best friend and confidant. Roi is actually the source of quite a bit of the humor in Midnight Stranger. He has a complex about his appearance, not realizing how adorable his new goat form is or how attractive he is as a human. He’s also apparently a little slow in recognizing that Xiu has feelings for him—readers aren’t privy to the hundreds of years of the extremely tedious evolution of their relationship, just the time period in which Roi finally figures it out and the heated sex that follows. Whereas Roi and Xiu’s story becomes more comedic as it progresses, Naono takes the opposite approach with “Hollow Romance” which becomes increasingly darker and grotesque, all while still maintaining a sense of humor. I particularly liked “Hollow Romance,” but I am curious to see what lies in store for Roi and Xiu in the next volume of Midnight Stranger.

Thank you to Viz Media for providing a copy of Midnight Stranger, Volume 1 for review.

Filed Under: REVIEWS Tagged With: Bohra Naono, manga, Midnight Stranger, Sublime Manga, viz media

UQ Holder!, Vol. 7

April 12, 2016 by Sean Gaffney

By Ken Akamatsu. Released in Japan by Kodansha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Weekly Shonen Magazine. Released in North America by Kodansha Comics.

Seven volumes into UQ Holder, and again I’m asking the question I’ve wondered about since it started: who is this meant to be for, exactly? I don’t know how Japanese fans of Negima reacted when it came to its messy end, but the Western fans were appalled and angry, for the most part. And after seemingly destroying his own series due to an argument with the parent company (details will likely remain forever sketchy), Akamatsu has now leaped 80 years into the future, helpfully thus losing most of the main cast of Negima, and begun what seemed like a spiritual sequel but has now amounted to a direct sequel. And just as Negima was able to ditch some of the wacky comedy and naked fanservice of Love Hina in favor of fighting and battles, UQ Holder takes it further, and you can almost safely read this in public.

uqholder7

I know that there are readers of this series who have not read Negima, having picked up the series via Crunchyroll or Kodansha, and are purely interested in the new story and new generation of characters. This volume must be particularly frustrating to them, as almost all of it features old Negima cast members, old Negima plots that never got resolved, and teases of Negima characters long-dead doing badass things. As a Negima fan, I admit it’s nice to see Mana again, and even if it was just a tiny flashback, the idea of Ku Fei and Yue teaming up to win the Grand Magic Games tournament is both hilarious and awesome. And, of course, we have the major UQ Holder characters who *are* carryovers from Negima: Yukihime (aka Evangeline) and Fate.

This leads to what is probably the most interesting part of the volume, when touching an application for Tota to do the Grand Magic Games triggers a booby trap that shows them a vision of Negi, Nagi… and the Mage of the Beginning, who is delighted to see Evangeline again, and (it’s implied) Tota as well. The reason this is the most interesting part of the volume are Eva and Fate’s reactions, which are desperate and yearning, the most emotion we’ve seen from either of them this entire series. Eva’s love for both Negi and Nagi was a significant part of Negima, and now in UQ Holder it seems it hasn’t diminished.

Of course, this leads to what kickstarts the next arc, as after this she realizes (I assume, motives are murky) that Tota is in danger if he’s near her, and forbids him from fighting in the tournament, or even leaving headquarters. Needless to say, all this does is spur him on to try harder. And it also spurs the author on to work in more Negima references. Not only can Tota seemingly use Dark Magic Erebea, but he is revealed to literally be a clone of Negi, which will no doubt lead to some excellent soul-searching and character development on his end, but from a meta perspective is both hilarious and sad.

I enjoy UQ Holder for what it is, but then I’ve read Negima, and have gotten over my grudge. For anyone else trying this series, I imagine it must seem like the image of Negi we see in this volume: a cool image surrounded by the dark, binding tentacles that make up its past.

Filed Under: REVIEWS

Bookshelf Briefs 4/11/16

April 11, 2016 by Sean Gaffney and Michelle Smith 1 Comment

assclass9Assassination Classroom, Vol. 9 | By Yusei Matsui | Viz Media – There’s a lot packed into this volume, ranging from showing how much more Class E is actually learning from Koro-sensei, to kicking off some romantic ship tease between Irina and Karasuma (good to see his the typical romantically clueless male). But the most important part of the volume discusses what it actually means to be an assassin, and how it’s different from being a soldier, or being a fighter. Koro-sensei is teaching the class the skills they need at assassination, but do any of the kids really have the desire to kill someone? (Or even the tragic background that we see Irina has here.) But, most importantly, will Kayano ever get to do anything ever? We may at least find that out next time. – Sean Gaffney

golden3Golden Time, Vol. 3 | By Yuyuko Takemiya and Umechazuke | Seven Seas – Any chance at romantic moves forward is shut down in the first few pages—Kaga rejects Banri’s confession, but hopes they can be friends. Honestly, it’s for the best for both of them. Banri is still dealing with his amnesia—and judging by the flashback we see, was quite different back then from his present self. Kaga, meanwhile, is still a hot mess of issues, which she handles in the most extroverted, aggravating way possible. Then there’s the added issue of Linda, who clearly knew Banri in the past—and he is aware of this—but is keeping it from him for some unknown reason. Essentially, we continue barrelling along far too fast, and the ensuing car crash, when it comes, will be awful in the best way. – Sean Gaffney

honeysweet2Honey So Sweet, Vol. 2 | By Amu Meguro | Viz Media – Now that we have resolved the whole “he’s really mean” plot that kicked this off, and Nao is able to realize that she does not, in fact, have romantic feelings for her uncle after all, the series can go on to do what it does very well, which is be sweet and charming. When you have two very awkward leads (and their awkward friend—Yashiro is really the odd one out here), there’s usually a lot of cute blushing, awkward almost missed dates, and apologies. Of course, as we find near the end, Taiga can’t quite get away from the fact that everyone still views him as a thug. And there’s also the dreaded new guy who enters the picture at the end of the volume. Enemy? New love interest? Ah well, at least it will be sweet. – Sean Gaffney

honorstudent2The Honor Student at Magic High School, Vol. 2 | By Tsutomu Sato and Yu Mori | Yen Press – I don’t think I even reviewed the first volume of this. When the Irregular volume was delayed from November to April, its spinoff manga was left in place, sadly. As a result, we see an alternate telling of a story I haven’t read yet, told from the perspective of the sister of the main novel character. On the plus side, the world is well-formed, and should please those who like ‘magic academy’ series in general. On the minus side, the heroine seems to be flawless with the exception of her massive brother complex, and anyone reading this had better have a very high tolerance for incestuous feelings of yearning. I suspect this series will work better after the novel comes out next month. – Sean Gaffney

mlm13My Little Monster, Vol. 13 | By Robico | Kodansha Comics – The thirteenth and final volume of My Little Monster includes assorted goodies for the die-hard fan. There are a few chapters from the point of view of characters whose perspectives we don’t generally see, a lovely wedding ceremony (with Nagoya the chicken included!), quite a lot of 4-koma, some character profiles, fanbook excerpts, even a maze. I’d say we did learn a few new things about some characters, and even though I wish for more detail about Natsume and Sasayan’s future, the glimpse we get here will sustain me. It says a lot about this series that Robico’s joke sequel announcement at the end of the volume made me go, “I’d read that!” Any chance to spend a little more time with these characters was and will always be welcome. – Michelle Smith

ph24Pandora Hearts, Vol. 24 | By Jun Mochizuki | Yen Press – One of these days, I’ll have to read Pandora Hearts straight through because I am still forgetting things in between volumes. As a result, some of what happens in this final volume is rather confusing. The basic gist, however, is that the world the characters inhabit is crumbling, and our heroes must find a way to stabilize their existence without changing the past. The characters are well-served here—I was happy to see the living draw upon their memories of the departed when deciding which side they were on and the ending also delivers major feels. Happy, sad, lovely and bittersweet, it’s everything I could’ve wanted the conclusion of this story to be. Well done, Mochizuki-sensei. – Michelle Smith

Filed Under: Bookshelf Briefs

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 492
  • Page 493
  • Page 494
  • Page 495
  • Page 496
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 1049
  • Go to Next Page »
 | Log in
Copyright © 2010 Manga Bookshelf | Powered by WordPress & the Genesis Framework