Sean Gaffney

A Certain Scientific Railgun, Vol. 17 | By Kazuma Kamachi and Motoi Fuyukawa | Seven Seas – After briefly wrapping up the previous arc (and, sure enough, glossing over the fact that Uiharu developed story-breaking powers), we end up flashing back to Mikoto’s first year in middle school. She’s just turned Level 5, and lacks the confidence she’ll gain later. We also see Misaki, who has the same problems (though now that Junko’s spinoff has finished, we can officially see her kicking ass in Railgun proper). As for the plot, well, it’s a turf war between the school’s three cliques, who are being manipulated by some unknown factor. Meaning this is basically now a delinquent manga with middle school girls. To be fair, that’s par for the course with this franchise. – Sean Gaffney

Hell in a Bottle | By Kyusaku Yumeno and Towoji Honojiro | Kodansha – The first work included as part of the Maiden’s Bookshelf, a series of classic short stories re-released in beautifully illustrated hardcover editions, “Hell in a Bottle” was originally published in 1928. The translation by Angela Yiu used for this volume was previously released in the anthology Three-Dimensional Reading (which, tangentially, is a great collection of stories for readers interested in modernist, Taishō era short fiction). “Hell in a Bottle” is an epistolary tale about a brother and sister shipwrecked on a deserted island as children, a tragedy fully revealed in reverse chronological order through a sequence of letters placed in glass beer bottles and thrown out to sea. The overall design and presentation of Hell in a Bottle, from the use of color and lettering to Honojiro’s beautiful and evocative artwork, greatly enhances the reading experience of Yumeno’s story. I am definitely looking forward to future volumes of the Maiden’s Bookshelf. – Ash Brown

Honey Lemon Soda, Vol. 1 | By Mayu Murata | Yen Press – Uka Ishimori was bullied in middle school for her stony mien, and chose a laidback high school with the goal of changing herself. Alas, some of her bullies have enrolled there too, but with the help of blond bishounen Kai Miura, she finds the courage to start making progress. As this is another series about a socially awkward girl who catches the attention of a popular guy who then helps her to make friends, it took a little while for me to warm to it. However, Ishimori eventually won me over with how endearing she can be in certain moments—I adored her spontaneously asking a classmate whether they can be friends and being stunned at the “Aren’t we friends already?” reply she receives. This may be reminiscent of several different series I have read, but I still enjoyed it and will be back for more. – Michelle Smith

Kageki Shojo!!, Vol. 7 | By Kumiko Saiki | Seven Seas – This entire volume is an exquisitely written kick in the teeth. After a first half where we deal with Sugimoto having to face up to the fact that Sarasa has a bit more “oomph” than she does (which is why Sarasa was cast as Tybalt), we then get a family crisis meaning that Sarasa can’t do the role anyway. I’m glad that it all worked out OK, but the frustration in that she didn’t get to perform and everyone turned out to be fine is hellacious—I worry that this will affect her getting roles in the future, if she’s going to be thought of as unreliable. Being a Takarazuka idol is hard, and this volume shows why in the best ways. Oh yes, we also write out one of the semi-regulars for a brutally realistic reason—even the side stories are harsh. – Sean Gaffney

Lost Lad London, Vol. 3 | By Shima Shinya | Yen Press – I really wish this series had been longer, with the opportunity to introduce more possible culprits. Because, to my mind, there was only one likely prospect and, indeed, I was right. This rendered a lot of the action of this final volume somewhat anticlimactic and, combined with the social criticism that I once admired getting a little more blatant and heavy-handed, I was starting to feel a little disappointed. However, the final scene between Ellis and Al redeemed it all for me, because the mystery of who killed the mayor was never really the point of Lost Lad London. It was about these two loners relying on each other and learning not to let something negative from their past dictate their whole lives. The series ends on a note of new beginnings, symbolized by one dinky little houseplant. Highly recommended. – Michelle Smith

Snow White with the Red Hair, Vol. 22 | By Sorata Akiduki | Viz Media – We do indeed go on the road this volume, but last time I asked for less of Hisame/Kiki (they’re both here) and also suspected there would be less romance. Instead Shirayuki is once again the center of attention, and once again cannot simply come out and say “I’m dating Zen”, so things get awkward. That said, she and her group are also being manipulated, which makes her rather angry. I actually really love seeing Shirayuki in fury mode, if only as it’s a very mild, gentle fury rather than exploding rage. As for those who are hoping for more evidence of a Shirayuki/Zen/Obi OT3, well, you won’t be disappointed here either. That said, it does look like getting the cure spread will be hard.-Sean Gaffney

Tatsuki Fujimoto Before Chainsaw Man: 17-21 | By Tatsuki Fujimoto | VIZ Media Given the critical reception for Look Back and Goodbye, Eri and the strong sales for Chainsaw Man, it’s no surprise that VIZ decided to license Tatsuki Fujimoto Before Chainsaw Man. The first installment of this anthology series, 17-21, focuses on Fujimoto’s earliest published work. As you might imagine, volume one is a mixed bag, filled with ambitious stories that sacrifice character development in favor of show-stopping plot twists and detailed layouts. The exception is “Love Is Blind,” in which a lovelorn teen’s awkward, earnest outburst saves the world from annihilation. Fujimoto does a great job of subverting sci-fi and romance tropes with bold, imaginative artwork that honors the intensity of the hero’s feelings while acknowledging how solipsistic they are–a level of nuance that’s missing from the other stories. Here’s hoping 22-26 is more satisfying. – Katherine Dacey

Hello, Melancholic!, Vol. 3 | By Yayoi Ohsawa | Seven Seas I don’t think this series was cancelled, per se, but I am sad that this is the final volume, as it felt like it was just getting started. As you can likely guess, this final volume focuses on our main couple (the other pairings get side chapters that, alas, are not collected here) and their attempts to realize that they actually do like each other that way, as well as dealing with Minato’s terminal anxiety. I appreciated the way that this book showed that sometimes pushing a person to do something way outside their comfort zone can be a good thing, and I also enjoyed Hibiki being forced to realize that she may be more like her father than she thinks. Easily the best trombone-related yuri I’ve ever read, this is also an excellent manga even without the trombone. – Sean Gaffney

Kaguya-sama: Love Is War, Vol. 24 | By Aka Akasaka | Viz Media – This volume flat-out tells you that we’ve reached the final arc of the story, and the back half of it is dedicated to that arc, kicked off by Kaguya vanishing from school. Before that, we get a lot more Ishigami and Iino ship tease, some more of Maki being a good friend but a terrible romantic partner, and Chika wondering why on Earth she doesn’t have any romance in her life? (Kaguya offers to set her up with Hayasaka, and given how much Chika fawns over another girl in this book, it’s probably not a bad idea.) There are still plenty of laughs here, but no doubt the final arc will be a serious one. Let’s hope that Kaguya can not only stay together with Shirogane, but survive to the end of the series. – Sean Gaffney

Komi Can’t Communicate, Vol. 22 | By Tomohito Oda | Viz Media – It can be very, very difficult to confess your love to a crush, especially in Japan, where casual dating is far less of a thing than it is over here. That said, I feel the plotline of “when will Manbagi confess, get rejected, and try to move on?” is taking forever, and that’s not helped by this volume, which gives her the perfect opportunity to confess, but she just can’t work up the guts. It doesn’t help that this is killing Komi too, and Manbagi knows it. The rest of the volume is mostly just the rest of the school trip, the high point of which was my realization that they’re staying at the same hotel that I stay at when I go to New York. (It’s got a lot of international customers.) Still good, but get on with it! – Sean Gaffney

Love at Fourteen, Vol. 12 | By Fuka Mizutani | Yen Press – I don’t think I’ve been this disappointed over the direction a series went since Bunny Drop. Now, don’t worry, no one breaks up here or anything. We even get a flashforward showing our main couple still together (if fairly static). The issue is that the author ran out of ideas for the main couple and so decided to bring in their fetishes, and we pay as much attention to them as we do to the Love at Fourteen. There’s not one, but THREE teacher-student romances, one of which explicitly has the girl decide to romance the teacher so he’s not seduced by a gay man. There’s the middle schooler and the mature looking fifth-grader. There’s the middle schooler and the OL, who get married at the end. Why was this so seedy? – Sean Gaffney

The Music of Marie | By Usumaru Furuya | One Peace Books – In this visually arresting, maddeningly empty story, Usumaru Furuya envisions a world in which humanity has been stripped of its technological progress. Marie, an enormous clockwork automaton, floats through the sky, keeping a seemingly silent vigil over her creators. Only one person can hear her celestial music: Kai, a young man who is torn between his feelings for Pipi, a childhood friend, and his emotional connection to Marie. Furuya’s illustrations are gorgeous, but the story never quite finds its groove, see-sawing between Pipi’s increasingly desperate attempts to win Kai’s affection and Kai’s efforts to uncover who built Marie, and why. The script sounds a few cautionary notes about the dangers of idolatry and technophobia, but Furuya’s penchant for making icky jokes spoils the mood. – Katherine Dacey

No Longer Allowed in Another World, Vol. 1 | By Hiroshi Noda and Takahiro Wakamatsu | Seven Seas This manga has one joke, and if you’re not here for the joke, you’ll probably want to stay away. The joke is that the protagonist of famous novel No Longer Human, about to kill himself along with his lover Sacchan, is instead hit by the inevitable isekai truck, and ends up in a fantasy world. This is a broad comedy, and the parodies of isekais are hilarious if (like me) you’ve read too many of them. That said, the main character here tries to kill himself multiple times over the course of the volume, and if suicide as comedy bothers you, absolutely do not read this. For those with no such issues, and who are familiar with No Longer Human, it’s pretty funny. – Sean Gaffney

Orochi: Perfect Edition, Vol. 1 | By Kazuo Umezz | VIZ – It’s pretty rare for me to disagree with critics like Helen Chazan and Chris Mautner, but I was underwhelmed by Orochi, especially when compared with some of Kazuo Umezu’s other translated works. The stories read like half-recalled dreams, with baroque plot twists and dialogue that makes Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? seem like a work of cinéma vérité. To some extent, that’s true of Umezu’s other work, but at least Cat-Eyed Boy and The Drifting Classroom pack a visual and an emotional punch, both of which are sorely lacking in Orochi; the title character is such a cipher that she registers more as a walking plot contrivance than a person, thus blunting the tragedies she helps set in motion. – Katherine Dacey

Rainbow Days, Vol. 1 | By Minami Mizuno | VIZ Media – I typically enjoy manga that was serialized in Margaret or one of its offshoots, but in Rainbow Days I have found the exception. Natsuki Hashiba is a wholesome teen with more worldly friends, and when they try to warn him that his new girlfriend is a gold digger, he refuses to listen. Alas, they were right. I found Natsuki to be a bland protagonist, but he’s at least better than one of his friends, Katakura, whose only personality trait is “into S&M.” Practically any time he’s in a scene, he’s either holding a whip (at school, no less!) or making comments about mouth gags. At no point is any of this ever funny. I do like Natsuki’s new love interest—and her abrasive, overprotective, and smitten best friend—and honestly I just wish those two had their own manga instead, because I really can’t do fifteen more volumes of this one. – Michelle Smith

The Shadows of Who We Once Were, Vol. 8 | By Yae Utsumi | Kodansha Comics (digital only) – I wouldn’t exactly say The Shadows of Who We Once Were has been a fun series to binge—it’s about teens being held hostage by a former classmate and forced to participate in deadly experiments, after all—but it’s certainly been riveting in its own bleak way. From the outset, readers knew the total of deaths related to the incident, and the final two turn out to be quite a surprise. I also appreciated how the reporter factored in, and the cynical detail that her subsequent article managed to change public opinion for, like, three months. The best part of the series, though, is the way the survivors have changed from the incident, in many cases for the better. Overall, I really liked this series and hope that it will one day have a print release. – Michelle Smith