• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Comment Policy
    • Disclosures & Disclaimers
  • Resources
    • Links, Essays & Articles
    • Fandomology!
    • CLAMP Directory
    • BlogRoll
  • Features & Columns
    • 3 Things Thursday
    • Adventures in the Key of Shoujo
    • Bit & Blips (game reviews)
    • BL BOOKRACK
    • Bookshelf Briefs
    • Bringing the Drama
    • Comic Conversion
    • Fanservice Friday
    • Going Digital
    • It Came From the Sinosphere
    • License This!
    • Magazine no Mori
    • My Week in Manga
    • OFF THE SHELF
    • Not By Manga Alone
    • PICK OF THE WEEK
    • Subtitles & Sensibility
    • Weekly Shonen Jump Recaps
  • Manga Moveable Feast
    • MMF Full Archive
    • Yun Kouga
    • CLAMP
    • Shojo Beat
    • Osamu Tezuka
    • Sailor Moon
    • Fruits Basket
    • Takehiko Inoue
    • Wild Adapter
    • One Piece
    • After School Nightmare
    • Karakuri Odette
    • Paradise Kiss
    • The Color Trilogy
    • To Terra…
    • Sexy Voice & Robo
  • Browse by Author
    • Sean Gaffney
    • Anna Neatrour
    • Michelle Smith
    • Katherine Dacey
    • MJ
    • Brigid Alverson
    • Travis Anderson
    • Phillip Anthony
    • Derek Bown
    • Jaci Dahlvang
    • Angela Eastman
    • Erica Friedman
    • Sara K.
    • Megan Purdy
    • Emily Snodgrass
    • Nancy Thistlethwaite
    • Eva Volin
    • David Welsh
  • MB Blogs
    • A Case Suitable For Treatment
    • Experiments in Manga
    • MangaBlog
    • The Manga Critic
    • Manga Report
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • Manga Curmudgeon (archive)

Manga Bookshelf

Discussion, Resources, Roundtables, & Reviews

Sean Gaffney

The Tiny Witch from the Deep Woods, Vol. 2

September 7, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Yanagi and Yoh Hihara. Released in Japan as “Mori no Hashikko no Chibi Majo-san” by TO Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Nathan Macklem.

Last time I was wondering if this would turn out to be a disgraced noble book in disguise, or a slow life book, or a mystery, and it leaned more on the mystery at the end. This second volume is, till the nasty cliffhanger, a far more relaxed affair. Misha has moved to another kingdom, and for the most part, gets treated like a savior. She responds to this well, by… well, if there is a problem with this kingdom, she is going to solve it, as she takes on princesses with poor health, herb gardens with weak effects, and secret royalty who are kind of tsundere. (She may have more difficulty in the third book – see aforementioned nasty cliffhanger.) But after the trauma of the first book, and while she’s still dealing with her mother’s death, with affects her throughout, this book is all about making Misha happy and content. Everyone loves her.

Misha and her entourage finally arrive at the Kingdom of Redford’s palace, where she greets its king, who was not expected to be king but became one after a combination of a plague – which no one ever really figured out – and various countries trying to take advantage of all the death. He’s a young man who affects a sunny, pleasant personality but is not above using people for his own ends – though he knows before he even meets her that Misha needs to be handled with kid gloves. She makes a great first impression, as it turns out that medicine in this kingdom is not all that great – the idea of a stethoscope astonishes them. That said, can she win over tougher customers, like the King’s sister, who has been ill for most of her life – wait, is she still ill? Are we sure she’s not just spoiled?

I will note that folks who are somewhat tired of the sunshine girl arriving in a new community and magically healing everyone through a combination of niceness and gumption may find this book hard going, as it leans into that cliche pretty hard. Misha does arrive with her elf – sorry, person of the forest – mentor, but she quickly goes away to do other stuff, mostly leaving Misha on her own. The kingdom does its level best to make her happy – sure, you can stay in the gardener’s shed out back instead of our lovely palace, just try not to pay attention to how expensive your “simple” furniture is. I also enjoyed the scenes with Caro, who is suffering from a classic case of child with too many expectations, and finds Misha treating him like the kid he is – complete with the standard “let’s play around with the poor commoner children” scene – a breath of fresh air.

So the first book was somewhat fraught and tragic, and this book was mostly relaxing and happy. There is that cliffhanger, though, and I’m pretty sure the third volume will swing things the other way. For fans of cute girls doing cute medical things.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, tiny witch from the deep woods

Private Tutor to the Duke’s Daughter: The Celestial Spear, Successor to the Star

September 5, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Riku Nanano and cura. Released in Japan as “Koujo Denka no Kateikyoushi” by Fujimi Fantasia Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by William Varteresian.

Aside from the incredibly complicated plot, and the “who will Allen end up with” parts, for the most part this series’ most interesting subplot has been “when will everyone finally succeed at making Allen into a noble?”. Admittedly, one of the biggest obstacles to pulling this off has been Allen himself, whose genuine low self-esteem is matched only by his crafty ability to try to escape getting credit for things. Because he has experienced what people think of the beast tribe, and also what people think of him personally. Man, a lot of people just hate Allen on site, don’t they? Allen tends to be famous for a few things: 1) being the one who made Lydia who she is today (and is now doing the same with Tina); 2) Allen solving every single major incident of the last year or so; and 3) Allen having a very small amount of mana. That last one, possibly even more than his bloodline or lack thereof, is what leads folks to be absolutely furious at him. And in this book, that proves fatal.

Despite the aftermath of the previous volume, the aforementioned fatalities, and a really big fight near the end, for the most part this is the relaxing volume I had hoped for. The entire cast ,minus Ellie (who gets a scene showing how far she’s come but you still sense the author doesn’t know what to do with her) and Cheryl (back being a princess) are headed to the Yustinian capital, there to meet an Alice who is increasingly getting unable to perform her hero-ly duties (and trying to hide it) and her brother Igna, who has a bad case of jealousy and envy, and it’s all pointed at Allen. Also coming along is Lily, and we get a lovely flashback showing how they first met, and giving a little more insight into Lily’s desire to be a maid (which, I remind you, in this world is basically “assassin/spy/soldier who serves tea”). Oh yes, and the Emperor wants to see Allen and Caren, commoners or no. That might be hard.

I was actually faked out by one scene in here showing Lydia, Stella and Alice all agreeing to something after looking through ancient laws no one uses anymore. A lot of folks have been divided into camps in terms of “which girl will win”, and we know which camp I’m in. I had assumed this was some sort of polygamy thing, and was surprised Lydia went along. But in fact it’s nothing of the sort. If Allen can’t get a title or a noble house in his own country, well, let’s give him one from a different country. He really can’t weasel out of this, though he tries. It’s not helped that his sister is over the moon about it (and we’re also reminded how much she’s done to save the world – really everyone in Allen’s generation is a superhero. Caren knows that an Allen with a title is an Allen who will get the recognition he deserves. Though she may be less wild about Allen needing to get married, which I think may also be an issue.

And bad news to fans of the books: if you’ve seen the anime running this summer, you now have to preface recommending them with “It’s better than that, I promise”. Still, readers of Book 16 will definitely enjoy Book 17.

Filed Under: private tutor to the duke's daughter, REVIEWS

Manga the Week of 9/10/25

September 4, 2025 by Sean Gaffney, Ash Brown, Michelle Smith and Anna N Leave a Comment

SEAN: We’re really getting into the thick of September now. Stay close, it might be dangerous.

ASH: It’s just now barely September, don’t scare me like that!

SEAN: No print light novels for Airship next week, but we do see Adachi and Shimamura 12 and A Tale of the Secret Saint ZERO 3 in early digital.

Denpa Books has the 4th volume of March Comes in Like a Lion, according to retailers.

ASH: It will be good to see!

MICHELLE: Woot!

ANNA: Nice!!

SEAN: Ghost Ship has a 3rd and final volume of Isekai Affair as well as Parallel Paradise 23.

J-Novel Club has three print debuts. Campfire Cooking in Another World With My Absurd Skill (Tondemo Skill de Isekai Hourou Meshi) is a manga from Comic Gardo based on the light novel also published by JNC.

ASH: I’ve forgotten what the absurd skill is this time.

SEAN: Isekai Tensei: Recruited to Another World (Isekai Tensei no Boukensha) is coming out in 2-volume omnibus format, so this is the first two books. The plot is every single reincarnated in another world cliche you can possibly imagine. It sells pretty well.

Making Magic: The Sweet Life of a Witch Who Knows an Infinite MP Loophole (Maryoku na Majo ni Narimashita: Souzou Mahou de Kimama na Isekai Seikatsu)is light novel that is not coming out as an omnibus. This is sort of the distaff “riddled with cliches” series, as it’s a young woman who has the overpowered stuff.

Also in print: An Archdemon’s Dilemma 18, Ascendance of a Bookworm 33 (the final volume of the main series, though more side stories and spinoffs are coming), The Brilliant Healer’s New Life in the Shadows 2 (manga version), Gushing Over Magical Girls 3, The Magic in this Other World is Too Far Behind! 10, and Seirei Gensouki: Spirit Chronicles 10 (manga version).

ASH: Hooray, Bookworm! (Though, surprising no one at this point, I have some catching up to do.)

SEAN: J-Novel Club has four digital debuts. The Crown of Rutile Quartz (Rutile Quartz no Taikan – Slaine to Ou to Eiyuutan) is a manga version of a light novel already released by JNC. It runs in Drecomics.

Looks like a Job for a Maid! The Tales of a Dismissed Supermaid (Maid nara Touzen desu. ~Nureginu wo Kiserareta Bannou Maid-san wa Tabi ni Deru Koto ni shimashita.~)is manga version of a light novel just announced by JNC. The manga runs in Comic Earth Star Online. Nina may be a maid, but that does not stop her falling into a “noble lady accused and thrown out” plotline.

ASH: I’m not sure anyone should be dismissing a supermaid.

SEAN: We’re starting a new imprint, J-Novel Knight, devoted to BL light novels. The first of these is Romance Revived: An NPC Was the Final Boss’s Love (Shi ni Modotta Mob wa Last Boss no Saiai deshita), which seems to be a one-shot. A man is reincarnated into his own fantasy story… but doesn’t remember till he’s framed, killed, and sent back in time. Now that he knows what’s going to happen, he has to protect the king! The really hot king!

ASH: As one does! (I’m happy to see this imprint emerge.)

ANNA: This does sound like a (hot) problem!

SEAN: Scooped Up by an S-Rank Adventurer! This White Mage Is One Heck of a Healer (Yuusha Party wo Tsuihousareta Hakuma Doushi, S Rank Boukensha ni Hirowareru – Kono Hakuma Doushi ga Kikakugai sugiru) is a manga version of a light novel as yet unlicensed, but an anime is currently running. If you’ve read a “thrown out of the hero’s party” book, you know what you’re getting here.

Also coming digitally for light novels: The Apothecary Diaries 15, The Brilliant Healer’s New Life in the Shadows 7, Earl and Fairy 11, The Hero and the Sage, Reincarnated and Engaged 5, and Infinite Dendrogram SP 1 (a side story).

And digital manga includes A Cave King’s Road to Paradise 7, The Eternal Fool’s Words of Wisdom 6, Full Clearing Another World under a Goddess with Zero Believers 9, Goodbye Overtime 3, The Invincible Little Lady 10, The Invincible Summoner Who Crawled Up from Level 1 4, Isekai Tensei 11, A Livid Lady’s Guide to Getting Even 5, Only I Know That This World Is a Game 9, and A Wild Last Boss Appeared! 7.

No debuts for Kodansha, but we get print for A Kingdom of Quartz 3, Magic Knight Rayearth 2 2, Medalist 10, Re:Anima 2, Tank Chair 5, Thunder 3 6, WIND BREAKER 14, and With a Dog AND a Cat, Every Day is Fun 8.

ASH: I’m behind on them all, but there’s some good stuff here.

SEAN: For digital we get Blue Lock 33, A Condition Called Love 17, Gang King 33, I Have a Crush at Work 11, and That Beauty is a Tramp 6.

Living the Line debut My Gorilla Family (Gorilla to no Kekkon), a horror short story manga from the early 1970s. It’s the 5th in the Smudge series that is collecting gekiga oddities.

ASH: I love gekiga oddities, so I’ve been thoroughly enjoying what Smudge has been releasing.

ANNA: Not likely to pick this up but I’m glad it is out there!!!

SEAN: One Peace have a debut, The B-Rank Adventurer with a Scary Face Becomes a Father for the Hero and His Friends (Akuninzura shita B-kyuu Boukensha – Shujinkou to Sono Osananajimi-tachi no Papa ni naru). Based on an as yet unlicensed light novel, this Dengeki Comic Regulus title stars a trash mob guy who one day finds a kid at the side of the road and decides to raise them. The trouble is this kid is the future hero!

ASH: That does have the potential to be troublesome.

SEAN: Seven Seas has some “novel/danmei/etc” debuts this week. Copper Coins: Tong Qian Kan Shi is a historical fantasy about an amnesiac monk, a dragon and a ghost going on a road trip. There’s also a special edition with a double-sided bookmark, a paper folding screen, a set of three postcards, and a sticker sheet.

ASH: That absolutely sounds like something I would read.

MICHELLE: Definitely sounds like the setup for some hijinks.

SEAN: Breathless Time Traveler (Anata wa Koko de, Iki ga dekiru no?) is a one-shot from the author of Toradora!. A college girl is killed in a traffic accident, but now finds herself time looping up to the moment of her death! Can she fix things?

ASH: Interested in this one, too!

The manga debut is Magic Maker: How to Create Magic in Another World (Magic Maker – Isekai Mahou no Tsukurikata), a MAGCOMI manga based on a light novel Seven Seas will release next year. A reincarnated boy is sad to find he’s in a world without any magic. But… can he make some?

ASH: Signs point to “yes.”

ANNA: What if he couldn’t, just as an interesting twist??

SEAN: Also from Seven Seas: CALL TO ADVENTURE! Defeating Dungeons with a Skill Board 10, Dance in the Vampire Bund: Age of Scarlet Order 15, Diary of a Female Lead: Shujinkou Nikki 4, The Dragon Knight’s Beloved 9, Dungeon Friends Forever 5, The Eccentric Doctor of the Moon Flower Kingdom 11, The Legend of Dororo and Hyakkimaru 10, Rozen Maiden Collector’s Edition 3, and Someone’s Girlfriend 4.

ASH: The Legend of Dororo and Hyakkimaru is another series I’ve been meaning to read more of.

MICHELLE: I still need to check out Diary of a Female Lead.

SEAN: Square Enix Manga debuts Bride of the Death God (Shinigami no Hanayome – Yomei 7-nichi kara no Koufuku), a supernatural shoujo from Gangan Pixiv. A grim reaper tells a girl she’ll die in one week. He is puzzled at how grateful she is – as she’s known she has a terminal illness. Love ensues.

ASH: Awww.

MICHELLE: Hm.

ANNA: Curious about this one.

SEAN: They also have The Emperor’s Caretaker 4.

Steamship debut His Sensual Whisper: The Voice That Sets Me On Fire (Tonari no Joushi wa Zetsurin Ikebo), a josei series from LoveParfait. A woman has a fetish for deep sexy voices, but is the guy she just met actually the one for her?

ANNA: It takes all kinds!

SEAN: SuBLime brings us Engage 3 and Megumi and Tsugumi 6.

Titan Manga debut Sanda, a shonen title from Weekly Shonen Champion. From the creator of BEASTARS, it stars a boy who is attacked by a girl as she thinks that he is cursed, and this led to her friend disappearing. They then go on a trip to find this friend.

ASH: Yes, Virginia, there is a Santa Claus in this manga.

SEAN: Titan Manga also have a 2nd volume of Yan.

Tokyopop has You Can’t Live All on Your Own! 2.

MICHELLE: Still need to read the first one!

SEAN: From Viz Media we get Animal Crossing: New Horizons 9, Deadpool: Samurai 3, Komi Can’t Communicate 35, Minecraft: The Manga 3, Seraph of the End 33, Splatoon 3: Splatlands 5, Tsumiki Ogami’s Not-So-Ordinary Life 2, and Yashahime: Princess Half-Demon 7.

Yen Press debut Land, a seinen title from Weekly Morning. This is coming out as a 3-in-1 hardcover. A young girl lives happily with her father. Unfortunately, her older twin is very unhappy, and goes to the mountains swearing vengeance. What’s the story behind these twins?

ASH: I am immensely curious about this one.

SEAN: Also from Yen Press: Chained Soldier 12, It’s All Your Fault 2, Murciélago 25,and Triage X 28.

ASH: I’d somehow missed (or had forgotten) that Murciélago was still ongoing!

SEAN: Did you survive the manga trek? What did you end up with?

Filed Under: FEATURES, manga the week of

Imperial Reincarnation: I Came, I Saw, I Survived, Vol. 3

September 4, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Masekinokatasa and Kaito Shinobu. Released in Japan as “Tenseishitara Koutei deshita: Umarenagara no Koutei wa Konosaki Ikinokoreru ka?” by TO Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Jason Li.

I appreciate that even now that we’ve had our coup and Carmine is allowed to not act like an idiot all the time, the best scenes in the book are still either him trying to be very clever and then realizing everyone was already way ahead of him, or him realizing that he’s kind of screwed up but can’t say anything about it. The latter is possibly the most darkly funny moment of the book, when his imprisoned mother pushes her lover out of the tower to his death, and everyone wonders why there were no bars in the window, and Carmine quietly realizes he removed them when it was Vera-Sylvie’s tower and forgot to replace them. OOPS. More awesomely, when Carmine points out (and you can see his logic) that he has to be on the battlefield leading the charge, he immediately gets some extra help he really does not want, because they know what he’s like, and “I might need to sacrifice myself” would be on the table unless they take it off.

The entire volume consists of the aftermath of Carmine taking power and trying to consolidate it, figure out who he can trust and who he has to execute, and preparing for war, as the sons of the folks he just murdered are declaring themselves independent and amassing armies. He can’t even really trust his own allies – his spymaster, at one point, deliberately makes himself less trustworthy to remind Carmine not to trust even those he’s closest to 100%. He’s always going to be the Emperor, which means he’s always going to be at risk of getting killed. His biggest concern besides allies is money and weapons, as well as an army to use those weapons. Money is the biggest worry, which is why he has to try to make a deal with the largest merchant company in the world right now. Fortunately, she, um, comes to him and offers a great deal? Not suspicious at all!

The most interesting part of the book was probably the meeting between Carmine and Hilaire Fechner, the head of the Golden Sheep Trading Company. Her behavior throughout the exchange, and even the interior art, makes you think of her as basically Mikuru from Haruhi, the sort who’s always crying and apologizing – she literally comes in apologizing in such a Japanese style Carmine suspects she too is reincarnated from Japan. Then of course we see her making deals and revealing secrets that essentially end up with everything going the way she wanted. You would expect most authors to at least confirm a little that she’s really crafty and this is an act, or have a side story from her POV later. But no, all we have is Carmine’s realization that she’s putting one over on them – the act doesn’t drop even for the reader, and it could be that she’s really like that. I want to see more of her.

You really, really need to be prepared for the lead character to ramble on about military alliances and trade agreements for 250 pages. If that’s your cup of tea, and you don’t mind that Carmine is still too young to have this series get TOO harem-ey, this could be right up your alley.

Filed Under: imperial reincarnation, REVIEWS

Welcome to Olivia’s Magic Jewelers, Vol. 2

September 4, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Rinrin Yuki and Suzaku. Released in Japan as “Olivia Maseki Houshokuten e Youkoso: Ka to Mise wo Oida Sareta no de, Outou ni Mise wo Kamaetara, Naze ka Moto Konyakusha to Gimai no Kekkonshiki ni Dero to Iwaremashita” by Mag Garden Novels. Released in North America by Cross Infinite World. Translated by Jordan Taylor.

I enjoyed this a great deal more than I did the first volume, though I do feel a bit guilty about that, as the main reason I enjoyed it was I kept waiting for Olivia to finally break down. We already knew she was an earnest young woman with a low opinion of herself, and we saw, at the start of the first book, her treatment at the hands of her abusive adopted father, cheating fiance, and terrible stepsister. But she ran away to the capital, made a name for herself, has a shop, and also has the most attractive man in the city in love with her, though she has not quite cottoned on to that last one. That means that this book, where she is forced to go home, be a witness at her sister’s wedding to her ex-fiancee, and then discuss her birth father’s old shop with evil adopted father – well, she reaches her snapping point.

Things start off well. Olivia now has her shop, and is satisfying customers once she manages to get out of her own head and stop stressing. She has a capable assistant who tries to make her rest (with limited success). She has her friends who helped her when she first came to the city. And she has Elliot, who sure seems to show up an awful lot around her. When she gets the letter telling her to return home for the wedding, everyone springs into action. She’s given a fashion and makeup upgrade, and Elliot decides to start taking her out to fancy restaurants and the theatre – not for any ulterior motives, of course, just as a pal. He’s also agreed to go with her when she returns home. Because the one thing Olivia and all her friends agree on is that this is a giant trap.

The third quarter of this book is dedicated to getting on Olivia’s last nerve. Her father’s shop sits abandoned and covered in weeds. The one employee who used to work there, but had to retire due to injury, is missing. At the wedding itself, her stepsister proves to be a shrieking harridan, demanding Olivia publicly apologize. The noble who controls the area – her ex-fiance’s father – decides to have Olivia marry him after all. And when she refuses, thanks to the help of Elliot, who the noble is terrified of for some reason, they go with Plan B, which is to knock her out, kidnap her, and say she’ll be imprisoned for life making artifacts. Apologies for all the spoilers, but this is a good way of showing that when we learn Elliot’s true identity (which should not surprise any reader who’s paid attention), she just gives up and goes back home by herself. The definition of the final straw.

Now, of course, they make up, which is the last quarter of the book. And there’s a third book which implies that Olivia’s low nobility status (which means she can’t marry Elliot) may soon be fixed by a secret in her family’s past. But for me, the best part of this book was seeing Olivia suffer. It was very realistic and well handled. Sorry, Olivia.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, welcome to olivia's magic jewelers

Welcome to Monstrous Miss Sophie’s Enchanted Salon of Healing, Vol. 2

September 2, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Sachi Konzome and Harenochihareta. Released in Japan as “Bakemono Jou Sophie no Salon: Gokigenyou. Kawa Ichimai nara Naosemasu wa” by Mag Garden Novels. Released in North America by Cross Infinite World. Translated by Dawson Chen.

Endings are hard, especially when a book is only two volumes long. Honestly, I think this might have worked better as one big brick, but I can guess why the publisher didn’t want that – these are chunky books as it is. But the main issue is that the first volume was alternating between Sophie and Kurt and their budding love and Sophie essentially having a new customer every chapter with a scar and a story. The second volume also starts out this way, but it almost reads like the author was told to wrap things up, as a little over a third of the way into the book, we end up dealing definitively with Sophie’s skin issues and disfigurement, as well as her self-loathing which is preventing her from accepting Kurt’s love now that he has finally realized what emotions are and that he has them. It’s still a good book, but it feels unbalanced.

The book starts with Sophie still taking care of clients with issues. We meet two kids who claim to be lost princesses but the truth is something far more tragic and well-worn; a clown following in his grandfather’s footsteps who wears his tragedy on his face; a beastman gatekeeper who is struggling to bring up a wayward daughter; and a bartender who is troubled by her past as a pirate. Throughout this we also get Kurt, who is going off to help fight a monstrous dragon, a task so dangerous that he gives Sophie half his dog tags, something you usually only give to your wife or fiancee. She’s very, very worried about him. Then, he returns, with a nasty scar (which she heals of course), and a proposal. She rejects him bitterly due to her condition. Can something be done about that?

The book wears its heart on its sleeve, sometimes a bit too much. Sophie’s cure amounts to finding a doctor who knows what it actually is, and the psychological component of it all, which I was sure might cause her to reject an immediate cure, does not come into play – at least not like that. The little girls’ story is tragic, but also somewhat incomplete – I was expecting the story to circle around to the mother and daughters once more, but it never did. The back half of the book is almost pure fluff – the one cure Sophie administers is to a literal living magical creature that makes people happy. It’s an emotional book, but I wish it had a bit more heft to it. Everything here happens pretty much exactly as you could have guessed. And they all lived happily ever after.

Still, it wasn’t that long, and I enjoyed Sophie essentially collecting tragedies and then upending them. That’s what I’ll remember this series for the most.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, welcome to monstrous miss sophie's enchanted salon of healing

Pick of the Week: Our Annual Pick

September 1, 2025 by Michelle Smith, Ash Brown, Anna N, Sean Gaffney and Katherine Dacey Leave a Comment

MICHELLE: I’m very intrigued by Adabana, but I can’t pass up the yearly opportunity to pick Kaze Hikaru!

ASH: Kaze Hikaru is always a worthy pick! But I’ll go ahead and make the debut of Adabana my official selection this week. I haven’t read the creator’s other work, but I have heard good things about this one. (I also happen to really like the cover.)

ANNA: I cannot resist the opportunity to celebrate the annual release of Kaze Hikaru!

SEAN: I admit I am about 30 volumes beyond on Kaze Hikaru, but I am in agreement with it being the pick.

KATE: I only have eyes for Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear this week… NOT! (Remember that annoying tic from the 90s?) Like everyone else, I’m naming the latest volume of Kaze Hikaru as my official POTW, but I’m also delighted to see that there’s a new installment of Skip & Loafer.

Filed Under: PICK OF THE WEEK

Babel: The End of the Journey to Restore Language

September 1, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Kuji Furumiya and Haruyuki Morisawa. Released in Japan as “Babel III: Torikago Yori Izuru Youki” by Dengeki Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Amelia Imogen.

The final volume of this series delves deeply into the question of what drives humanity to succeed. In the past of this world, humanity was pushed to the brink, and feared powerful witches. These days there are no more witches, and things are relatively peaceful. But will humans make the same mistakes they made before, just because they don’t remember what it’s like to life in fear and thus innovate? If you’re nodding along to this, congratulations, you agree with the villain of this book. If you’re staring and wondering what the hell this teenage history logic is, you’re a lot more like Shizuku, who has to try to deal with this while also finding a way to return home and also deal with the fact that – as we’ve occasionally noticed since the very first book when she looked at that forbidden tome – there’s something a bit off with her. Fortunately, she has Erik by her side this time, as opposed to written out by the author.

Shizuku continues to work on her language learning aids, but there’s a new problem. Some of the kids at the castle, after hanging around the older children, regain the innate language abilities. Does this mean the thesis that she and Erik have been so carefully working on is completely wrong? That said, she has other things to worry about. She’s apparently staying up for hours at night reading the blue-covered book she has, though she never remembers doing this. A neighboring country invites her there as they want that book, and are… well, not willing to kill her, but willing to hide her body if she gets killed by something else. Worst of all, a witch has appeared and recreated a very familiar witch’s tower (well, familiar if you read Unnamed Memory), and wants people to challenge it. And she’s also going around slaughtering women and stealing their souls. That’s bad.

I have to admit, I enjoyed this series more for the plot and worldbuilding than the characterization. Shizuku and Erik’s relationship can best be described as “kinda nice”. She and Ortea (and, for that matter, she and Lars) had a much more interesting back and forth. I also note that she only says “I love you” to Ortea in this book. But no, dull love prevails. Ah well. This also sort of gives away that she does not return to Japan, though if any reader is surprised by that they must not read many series like this. The best part of the book is what is actually up with Shizuku, and how they manage to use it to save the day. That said, while I would not call her behavior suicide ideation, we do get a lot of “I must sacrifice myself to save everyone” and she jumps off a very high building – again – with worse consequences this time. You can see why Lars finds her frustrating.

There’s a sequel to Unnamed Memory that is apparently also a sequel to this, but I’ve no idea if it will be licensed given the UM anime was a dud over here. Fans of the author will enjoy this.

Filed Under: babel, REVIEWS

Villains Are Destined to Die, Vol. 1

August 30, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Gwon Gyeoeul and JINSA. Released in Japan by D&C Media. Released in North America by Ize Press. Translated by Tapas Entertainmnt Inc.

I have not really dipped my toe too much into the Korean end of the villainess market. I generally have an allergy to vertically scrolling titles that I blame on being old, and aside from taking a look at Beware the Villainess, which runs on the deep rage of the heroine, I had not been taking in the manwha/webtoon end of the genre. But I saw that this also had a novel coming out, and I like text, so I decided to give it a try. It’s decent enough, though it definitely lives and dies on how much you like the heroine, who can be a lot, especially in this first book. I was actually reminded a bit of I Swear I Won’t Bother You Again!, as abuse in a past life leads to the actions the heroine takes in this life. In the case of Villains Are Destined to Die, though, the past abuse was in Korea, and this new “villainess” runs far more on bitter cynicism than anything else.

The premise will be familiar to many: Our unnamed heroine stumbles across a mobile game called Daughter of the Duke’s Super Love Project, and gets obsessed with it, particularly the Hard Mode, where you play as the adopted daughter who is the villainess in the Normal Mode of the game. In fact, she tries to hard to beat the ending she apparently dies, and finds herself in the body of Penelope Eckhart. Her family now hate her, the servants despise and abuse her, and if she doesn’t do anything she’s going to be tortured and executed within a year. Fortunately, she has her knowledge of the game – though she never got close to winning hard mode – so this shouldn’t be too difficult… except that she’s only given three option dialogue trees, and they’re all terrible options.

Fortunately, and this happens almost immediately so it’s not much of a spoiler, she gains the ability to turn off the “you have three bad options” screen fairly quickly. She does still see affection meters, though, which are all so abysmal you wonder what Penelope was like before our heroine”s reincarnated self took over. We gradually find out, and it turns out that the heroine and Penelope have a lot in common in terms of how they grew up – which makes things more interesting, as the influence of her past abuse makes this new Penelope far too distrusting and bitter, and a few times she shoots herself in the foot in her efforts to save herself. She also has the same issue a lot of these reincarnated villainesses have, which is she sees this world as a game, and doesn’t see the others as people. She’s got a tough road ahead of her, even if she is softening a bit by the end of this book.

I didn’t even mention the men in the series – angry brother 1, angry brother 2, yandere crown prince, mysterious sorcerer, and grateful slave. That said, I also didn’t mention the game’s heroine, who has not even shown up yet by the end of this volume. Villainess fans who want something a bit more bitter may find this to their liking.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, villains are destined to die

Witches Can’t Be Collared, Vol. 1

August 29, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Yuri Yumemi and Wata. Released in Japan as “Majo ni Kubiwa wa Tsukerarenai” by Dengeki Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Andrew Cunningham.

One thing that I tend to do on social media is that every month, I post a screencap of an Excel Spreadsheet showing my light novel preorders. This is meant as an amusing gag to show off that I frankly read far too many Japanese light novels, and I should be reading fewer of them. That said, sometimes it gets noticed by translators who happen to see their book isn’t there, and they say “hey, why aren’t you getting this new series?” Inevitably, my answer is something along the lines of “it’s not really my genre”. This happened a while back with Playing Death Games to Put Food on the Table, and while I had to admit that the first volume was very well done, I didn’t really read more of it because I’m not a fan of death game books. This new series is a police procedural, and after reading it I admit that the reasons that I was told to read it are valid. It’s quite fun in a lot of spots. Nevertheless.

Rogue Macabesta is a detective in a world that is basically “My Hero Academia but with magic instead of quirks”, which means it’s his job to hunt down villains who use magic for crime. He’s finally done enough, and been noticed enough, that he’s about to be promoted to a desk job. Honestly, he trips all sorts of flags about retiring, so it should not be a surprise that his boss has a new mission for him. There’s a serial killer no one can catch, who is aging and de-aging people to death, and she wants him to catch the culprit. Using the witches of the 6th District, who are all hundreds of years old and have slaughtered thousands. They’re all sociopaths, though this being a light novel that mostly means they’re sociopaths in amusing eccentric ways. Can he and Miseria, who can control people like puppets, get along enough to find the killer?

The witches are a lot of fun, especially Miseria, who I would hate to have to deal with in real life, but as a character she’s great. being an obnoxious tease and also knowing exactly what buttons to push to irritate Rogue. That said, all the other witches note that compared to their previous detectives they’ve worked with (who are all dead), she’s really taken a liking to him. Catherine, the other major witch we meet this time around, is essentially the chronic pathetic wet girl that you see in series like these – think Yunyun – but that changes fast. I wasn’t too surprised by the change, but it was handled well. So what’s wrong with the series? Nothing, except it is indeed a police procedural, meaning most of it is finding bodies, searching for clues, interrogating folks, and finding more bodies. Also, the author straight up says this is The Silence of the Lambs but with magic rather than cannibalism, which, again, not a selling point for me.

If you do enjoy this genre, and don’t mind some snarky amoral girls taking over the pages, this is absolutely right up your alley.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, witches can't be collared

Manga the Week of 9/3/25

August 29, 2025 by Sean Gaffney, Michelle Smith, Anna N and Ash Brown Leave a Comment

SEAN: It’s the start of September, so I must still be asleep. Probably for the best, I’m tired.

ASH: Agreed. A rest sounds really good right now.

SEAN: Yen Press have two runoff titles from August, Blend-S 3 and mono 3.

No debuts for Viz, but we get new volumes! Blue Box 17, Dark Gathering 15, Gokurakugai 4, Kaiju No. 8 14, Kaiju No. 8: B-Side 2, Kaze Hikaru 33 (just 12 years to go till it’s finished!), The King’s Beast 16, Let’s Do It Already 6, Nue’s Exorcist 2, A Star Brighter Than the Sun 3, and Wolf Girl and Black Prince 15.

MICHELLE: Insert annual Kaze Hikaru squee.

ANNA: I am joining in on this squee.

ASH: As will I!

SEAN: Two debuts for Tokyopop. Do You Really Want Only a Meal? (Mitasu no wa Kuufuku Dake desuka?) is a BL series from Comic Qurie. A tired office worker hires a housekeeping service, and gets a quiet young college student… who immediately admits to love at first sight!

Eternal Covenant is a BL series that’s Korean, so the Korean BL equivalent? A man who has grown up thinking he’s a monster is told that no, he actually just can use magic.

Tokyopop also has the 2nd volume of Reincarnated in a Mafia Dating Sim.

ASH: I actually just got my hands on the first volume of this.

SEAN: Square Enix Manga has Assassin & Cinderella 2, Just Like Mona Lisa 7, and The Strongest Sage with the Weakest Crest 26.

Seven Seas has some new stuff. I’m Running for Crown Princess, but All I Want is a Steady Paycheck! (Taikouhi Kouho Dakedo, Kenjitsu ni Ikou to Omoimasu) is a shoujo title from B’s-LOG Comic. A poor minor noble is encouraged to run for Betrothed to the Crown Prince, as even the losers could get steady work as ladies in waiting. But the competition is fierce. Fortunately, our heroine is blunt and has common sense.

ANNA: I enjoy a practical shoujo heroine.

ASH: Likewise!

SEAN: Let Me See the Real You, Senpai! (Senpai, Naka Misete) is a BL series from the creator of Punks Triangle. Our main character is an introverted recluse, but on Youtube he’s a popular VTuber! Then he meets another VTuber, and they agree to meet up… and the other guy is so handsome! It’s in Magazine Be x Boy.

The Princess I Loved in My Past Life is Now a Middle-Aged Dad (Zense de Aishita Hime ga Tensei Shitara Oji-san deshita) is a seinen series from Web Action. The title is the plot.

MICHELLE: This may be the most “the title is the plot” I’ve ever seen!

SEAN: There’s also a novel debut that’s not part of Airship. Godzilla Minus One is the novelization of the hit movie.

ASH: Oh, nice!

SEAN: And there’s danmei, as we get Heaven Official’s Blessing: Tian Guan Ci Fu 6 (deluxe hardcover) and You’ve Got Mail: The Perils of Pigeon Post – Fei Ge Jiao You Xu Jin Shen 4 (the final volume). And Lout of Count’s Family 5, which is Korean danmei.

Also from Seven Seas: Choking on Love 3, Drugstore in Another World 11, Heroine? Saint? No, I’m an All-Works Maid (And Proud of It)! 4, I Got Married to the Girl I Hate Most in Class 3, Kuma Kuma Kuma Bear 12, Level 1 Demon Lord and One Room Hero 9, Skip and Loafer 11, The Strange House 4, and The World’s Fastest Level Up 6.

MICHELLE: I think I would probably like Skip and Loafer.

ASH: I’m pretty sure I would, too.

SEAN: One Peace Books has a 5th and final volume of Kurokiya-san Wants to Lead Him Around by the Nose.

KUMA has the 3rd and final volume of Happy of the End.

No debuts for Kodansha, but we see Anyway, I’m Falling in Love with You 8, Initial D Omnibus 7, Roar: A Star in the Abyss 2, Tune In to the Midnight Heart 3, and Vinland Saga Deluxe 8.

ASH: I’m still eyeing those deluxe volumes.

SEAN: And in digital we get How to Grill Our Love 16 and Shangri-La Frontier 22.

J-Novel Club has one debut, and it’s a manga. Old Knight, New Post: From Retiree to Her Majesty’s Blade (Inkyogurashi no Ossan, Joou Heika no Ken to naru) is a Drecomics series about a retired knight who has to go back into service to protect his daughter.

ASH: I’m potentially intrigued.

SEAN: Light novels from J-Novel Club next week: Butareba -The Story of a Man Turned into a Pig- 7, Campfire Cooking in Another World with My Absurd Skill 16, Chivalry of a Failed Knight 7, Hell Mode 10, Imperial Reincarnation 3, Private Tutor to the Duke’s Daughter 17, The Tiny Witch from the Deep Woods 2, and You Were Experienced, I Was Not 8.

New manga includes Butareba -The Story of a Man Turned into a Pig- 7 (yes, the LN and the manga), From Villainess to Healer 3, The Frontier Lord Begins with Zero Subjects 10, Infinite Dendrogram 13, and Oversummoned, Overpowered, and Over It! 9.

Whoops, I forgot about Hanashi again. They have three light novel debuts! Technically out this week, but let’s ignore that. The Abandoned Reincarnation Sage: Building a Mighty Empire of Monsters Within the Monsters’ Forest (Suterareta Tensei Kenja: Mamono no Mori de Saikyou no Daima Teikoku wo Tsukuriageru) A wise man casts a spell to let him maintain his memories into his next life… then gets abandoned as a baby. Whoops. Fortunately, he’s raised by demons.

I Got Reincarnated as a Cultist Mob in an Eroge Full of Maniacs with Death Wishes (Zenin Kakugo Gangimari na Eroge no Jakyouto Mob ni Tenseishiteshimatta Ken) is, I hope, a comedy. Guy reincarnated in a game as a background male, but the background males tend to get sacrificed. He tries to run away, but every woman around him suddenly notices him, and they’re all yanderes. I’m sure fans of this sort of thing are delighted.

I’m Just a Villager, So What? (Murabito desu ga Nani ka?) stars a guy in a village whose “class” is villager. Despite this, he’s friends with two OP kids his own age. Then, when he turns 15, one of them kills him. That’s when he finds that, like Subaru he can return by death. Now he’s going to do things differently.

Ghost Ship has the 15th volume of The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, REALLY Love You.

I usually skip FAKKU, for obvious reasons, but they are starting the sequel to Nana & Kaoru, subtitled Black Label. For over 18s.

Dark Horse Comics debuts Adabana, from the creator of Harem Marriage. Two brutal murders occur, and someone confesses to the crime. But there’s a much darker story going on here. This ran in Grand Jump, and is apparently excellent but tragic.

MICHELLE: Intriguing!

ANNA: Hmmmm….

ASH: I have heard good things.

SEAN: Dark Horse also has a new re-release, as we see Blood Blockade Battlefront Omnibus 1. More from the creator of Trigun, playing in the world of superheroes.

Cross Infinite World has How I Became King by Eating Monsters 3, Welcome to Monstrous Miss Sophie’s Enchanted Salon of Healing 2 (the final volume) and Welcome to Olivia’s Magic Jewelers 2.

Airship has Drugstore in Another World 7, How a Realist Hero Rebuilt the Kingdom 19, and Too Many Losing Heroines! 5 in print.

Any back-to-school manga? Honestly, most schools opened before Labor Day.

Filed Under: FEATURES, manga the week of

The World’s Strongest Witch: I’m Starting My Free Life in a World Where Only I Can See the Online Strategy Guide, Vol. 1

August 28, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Mochimaru Sakaki and riritto. Released in Japan as “Sekai Saikyou no Majo, Hajimemashita: Watashi dake “Kouryaku Site” wo Mireru Sekai de Jiyuu ni Ikimasu” by SQEX Novels. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Phil Charbonneau.

This was one I took a flyer on because it sounded very silly. It’s always dangerous when you try to read a comedy, or a book that’s trying to be “zany”. You need to commit to the bit. But you also have to be careful not to drive off your readership without something too out there. This comes close, and I admit may not be for everyone, but I was quite pleased with how it turned out, because it is absolutely ludicrous. It takes its basic idea and does all the dumb things you’d want a book like this to do. Unlike Bofuri (and more on this later, but I guarantee Bofuri will be what you think of once you start this), the main character is part of this world. Also unlike Bofuri, there is no one with common sense to tell her when she’s being too ridiculous, just NPCs who are absolutely agog.

Lorna Hermit used to be Lorna Guugelheit, and spent most of her childhood ensconced in her family’s mansion and totally ignorant of anything they did. But then she manifests the skill that all these “sort of based on a game” worlds have people do, and it turns out to be SSS-Ranked. Her family is horrified! Skills go from A to G! To have her skill be SSS, it must be ludicrously bad if it’s that late in the alphabet! Needless to say, she is thrown out of the family and dumped in the incredibly dangerous forest at the edge of her domain. Then she actually figures out what her skill does… she can access the wiki page for her world, which turns out to be a game! Not that she knows this, all she knows is that the “gods” are giving her helpful hints on where the monsters and valuable herbs are. Unfortunately, she immediately gets the endgame “most powerful weapon” – by wiki searching – and so is just a LITTLE bit overpowered…

Lorna will remind you of Maple quite a bit, to be honest, but by the end of the volume I was struck by the fact that this is a secret villainess story. Noble girl thrown out of her family, who all turn out to be not-so-secretly evil. She goes to the nearby town to make a life for herself and dazzles everyone around her. But if I’m being honest, this series is really for those who like Kuma Bear and Make My Abilities Average but wishes there were fewer 8-year-olds and more magic battles. Lorna is a classic airhead, so keeps using the smallest spell she can think of, even when with her MP the smallest spell can still take out top-tier bosses. Antagonists see how thick her mana is and drop to their knees in terror. Best of all is the internet skill itself. Lorna deals with popup malware, cryptocurrency, and comment trolls telling her to take off her panties. She thinks it’s the gods speaking to her. By the end of the volume, even the elves believe commenters are using slang of the gods, and adopt it themselves. This book is ridiculous.

So, not for everyone, but I had a ball. I will definitely check out a second book, though this risks getting old fast. Also, terrific pun that I missed until the very end of the book.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, world's strongest witch

Banished from the Hero’s Party, I Decided to Live a Quiet Life in the Countryside, Vol. 14

August 28, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Zappon and Yasumo. Released in Japan as “Shin no Nakama ja Nai to Yuusha no Party wo Oidasaretanode, Henkyou de Slow Life Surukoto ni Shimashita” by Kadokawa Sneaker Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Dale DeLucia.

I admit I had sort of hoped that this volume would be entirely devoted to Red and Rit’s wedding, given the cover. And there are a few bits with everyone being really happy for them, getting the wedding dress made, etc. And yes, it does end with the wedding. But sadly this has always been a slow life series where the slow life struggles against the rest of the universe trying to drag everyone back into its troubles, and so the bulk of this book is trying to resolve the demons and God. That said, how it’s resolved ends up being pretty slow life in the end, as it’s just Red using… not his blessing, because that’s the whole point, but winning by being clever and strong. I am hoping, though, that this is the last we see of both sides of the conflict, and that the honeymoon volume (the final one) really is slow life.

A letter arrives from Yarandrala saying that she’s coming back to Zoltan. As such, Red and Rit realize that the time has finally come to set a date for their wedding. They’re try to keep the news quiet… which lasts about three seconds till everyone they know is screaming “they’re finally getting married?!?”. Unfortunately, there’s a nasty cold going around… or is it just a cold? Investigating, Red finds a mysterious plant near where the tomb they raided was. He also finds the demon lord and his aide, who Red and Rit have a long history with. We’re told that they’re trying to be heroes now, and certainly they’re saving villages and giving good advice about the sickness… but can they be trusted? And will Demis simply give up and let Ruti live her own life?

Demis has never been anyone’s favorite, and I think that applies to the readers as well as to the cast of the series. Here they possess a long-forgotten minor villain, Eremite, in order to make their point. Unfortunately for Demis, as with a lot of gods in fantasy series like this, they’ve long since lost the “I must help humanity because it’s the right thing to do” part of their godhood and are left with the “why does everyone not simply do exactly what I want them to?”. It feels thematically appropriate, if a bit pat (the fight goes ludicrously well) that Red is the one to defeat both Demis and Taraxon. On the bright side, this means the wedding happens (relatively) smoothly, without needing to worry about anyone’s blessing suddenly turning them evil. Best of all, Ruti allows Red and Rit to get married with not one single incestuous remark! Let’s hope it’s an excellent sign of maturity. Maybe she won’t even go on the honeymoon with them.

The next volume is the last, and honestly, this series has gone on a bit too long. But not to the point where I’m annoyed reading it. This was good.

Filed Under: banished from the hero's party, REVIEWS

Agents of the Four Seasons, Vol. 5

August 26, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Kana Akatsuki and Suoh. Released in Japan as “Shunka Shūtō Daikōsha” by Dengeki Bunko. Released in North America by Yen On. Translated by Sergio Avila.

After all the trauma of the first four, I noticed this one was a stand-alone volume, and I hoped that it might be a breather, a chance to relax and perhaps have a more lighthearted plot. And indeed the first half of this book fulfilled my wish. For the most part we have not had to deal with the supernatural person being in love with their minder in this series. Agents tend to love other agents, or other unrelated people. This also applies to the Archer of Twilight. Oh, sure, they are so ridiculously close to their minders that you can see the relationship as homoerotic (see my prior reviews regarding Hinagiku and Sakura), but we haven’t really had a romantic relationship until this book. Kaya is a teenager who is unable to deal with a crush, and her minder, Yuzuru, who clearly loves her deeply but is repressing it. The two of them push against each other, and get grumpy and sad, and it’s adorable. Well, until it isn’t.

Last time we met the Archer of Twilight, Kaguya, whose arrows brought about the night. The Archer of Dawn had a brief, minor appearance, but we get to know her here. After being chosen to be Archer, she was assigned a custodian, but he quickly found that walking up and down a mountain every day for years was too taxing for him. His son, however, Yuzuru, proved only too happy to step in and take care of Kaya. And now she’s in high school. She’s even able to go to an actual school, thanks to concessions from the organization behind all this. She’s a bit worried about Yuzuru, though, who’s so awesome and deserves so much better than staying with her his entire life. Even if she really wants him to, but is too shy to say so. And then there’s a landslide, and everything goes to hell.

While you can rest assured that the bad guys who want to control everyone and everything involved with the seasons and the day/night cycle are still here and still bad, I was rather surprised to find that they weren’t behind the natural disaster that leads off the second half of the book. Sometimes tragic stuff happens and it’s just because of natural causes. That said, the theme of this series is still present and correct. When Kaya makes the decision she does later in the book, she knows that she’s going to be punished for it. Everyone does, in fact, and other people are trying to take the punishment so she doesn’t have to. The best part of the book is when, in the epilogue, Kaya is told her punishment will end soon, she briefly feels it’s not nearly bad enough. Whereupon she’s told “You’re still in high school.” As these books go on, other people are bringing up over and over again what they are doing to children, and pushing back is becoming less a travesty and more a necessity.

We’re back to an arc next time, with more focus on Autumn, who played a major role in this book. Till then, this remains very well-written but also a bit worrying. These poor kids.

Filed Under: agents of the four seasons, REVIEWS

An Unruly Summon, Vol. 1

August 25, 2025 by Sean Gaffney

By Cathfach and Kurodeko. Released in North America by J-Novel Club.

This was one of the winners of the J-Novel Club original light novel contest, where they had judges (including Carlo Zen, author of The Saga of Tanya the Evil) picking out who created the best work. The winners got a cash prize, publication, and illustrations by a Japanese light novel artist (in this case, the Lady Bumpkin and Her Lord Villain artist). The premise of this story interested me, as it looked like it might be a deconstruction of the standard isekai. Which it is, but not as much as you’d expect. Honestly, this has its roots in those old fanfics where the author wrote the story asking “what if everything were the same except the main character was sensible and asked questions?” Thomas, the main character of this story, is sensible and definitely does ask questions, but that only gets him so far, because this is a world that has been at war for a while, and has summoned heroes before, and they are not happy they have to do it again. So they try to rig the game in their favor. This goes badly for almost everyone.

Thomas Smith is walking drunkenly back to his apartment with his friend Simon when he spots a purple “whirlwind” in front of him. On touching it, he ends up in another world. There, he is told that the world is under threat from demons who are on the verge of destroying humanity, and he has the power to help them fight back. He’s also assigned four pretty women – Stephanie, the King’s daughter; Christine, a knight; Wendy, a mage; and Mary, a slave. As he learns about magic and swordplay, and discovers that, much to his surprise, he really does seem to have heroic abilities, he also starts to connect the dots that they’re lying to him. In fact, the reader knows this from the start. Previous heroic summonings haven’t always gone well (and, in a nice meta joke, tend to be Japanese teenagers), so they gave him a “harem” and are trying to get him to be their good little puppet. The more he learns, however, the more everything completely goes off the rails.

This is a solid book, which wants to play around in the isekai sandbox but also try to examine some of its cliches. Slavery is examined closely here, and it’s horrifying in many ways. About 40% of the way into the book, we get a HOLY CRAP moment, and you wonder if that’s going to help solve the slavery thing, but that ends up not really being the case. Because this is a world where no one really understands how magic works. A lot of it is just “because it’s magic”. And Thomas finds that the success and failure of his spells lean a lot on his feelings towards others – even if they’re unconscious. Which means if he is unconsciously blaming others for their past horrible actions, even if he wants to save him the magic can simply not work. The world is also just starting to show off its complexity – it’s clearly meant to be multiple volumes, though I’m not sure how ongoing series work when it’s a contest winner. Possibly depends on sales.

I will admit, the character I most want to see more of in future books is the one who only appeared on the last page. So I would like to see more of this. For fans of isekai who want dark!gray!independent heroes.

Filed Under: an unruly summon, REVIEWS

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 11
  • Page 12
  • Page 13
  • Page 14
  • Page 15
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 378
  • Go to Next Page »
 | Log in
Copyright © 2010 Manga Bookshelf | Powered by WordPress & the Genesis Framework