Michelle Smith

A Certain Scientific Accelerator, Vol. 7 | By Kazuma Kamachi and Arata Yamaji| Seven Seas – Much to my surprise, there was one less death than I predicted in my last brief. Other than that, though, this went sort of how I expected—our heroes fought a long, hard battle and won eventually, though Estelle is warned by Accelerator that she should stay out of “the dark side” of Academy City. From what I recall in the main Index series, that’s easier said than done, though of course Accelerator simply means stay away from HIM. Of course, Accelerator cannot stop being a trouble magnet, just like Touma. And, just like Touma, he now has a beautiful girl fall out of the sky in front of him. Index was hung like a futon, and this new princess seems to have been in a suitcase. What will happen next? Good times in any case. – Sean Gaffney

My Monster Secret, Vol. 9 | By Eiji Masuda | Seven Seas – Akemi and Aizawa are on the cover this time, as if to announce that the harem sweepstakes, which has never exactly been a small part of this series, is now ramping up quite a bit. Of course, this all stems from Youko’s actions at the end of the last volume—something she’s still freaking out over, to an extent. There’s a lot of comedy but very little forward progress here, as you’d expect from this sort of series. Still, the comedy is funny, and there’s even a bit of plot. It’s also amusing to have the characters we aren’t allowed to see play a big role—Akemi from the future and Shiho’s mother. If you get frustrated by lack of forward progress, come back in a volume or two. Otherwise, this continues to be funny. – Sean Gaffney

Spirit Circle, Vol. 2 | By Satoshi Mizukami | Seven Seas – I’m really enjoying this series, but it’s surprisingly grim, even from the creator of Biscuit Hammer, which was also filled with lots of trauma. It’s probably for the best, as the humor here is not the high point. What is the high point is that we get another past life for Fuuta, which takes us back to Ancient Egypt. It shows how his past lives can get screwed over by Kouko’s past lives even if they don’t kill each other. That said, his life was not terrible. Unfortunately, doing all of this reliving of past lives may be unlinking Fuuta to his own identity, which could have ominous consequences. Spirit Circle‘s plot is intriguing and its characters are likeable. I want to see where it’s going. – Sean Gaffney

Waiting for Spring, Vol. 4 | By Anashin | Kodansha Comics – This is a shoujo romance and not a shonen basketball manga, so the result of the game may not go the way everyone wants it to. We do get some nice interaction between Mitsuki and the four guys, though, and also some suggestion that this may be a reverse harem after all, as there’s some brief ship tease with Rui and Kyousuke. This does lead us to a very good point regarding this romance, which is that things can’t progress until Mitsuki admits her own feelings, something she seems to slowly be coming to terms with. I was also amused by a healthy dose of humor AND fanservice, as everyone imagining their hot guy/girl in a swimsuit gave us a lot of amusing reactions. This is a cute, fun romance series. – Sean Gaffney

Waiting for Spring, Vol. 4 | By Anashin | Kodansha Comics – In my long review of the first three volumes, I wished for a little more basketball and this time I got my wish. Anashin-sensei achieves a good blend of tournament action and shoujo romance here, particularly as the guys are worn out from their first game and can’t sustain their lead in the second. Their loss turns into an opportunity to show rather than tell how much they’ve accepted Mitsuki into their inner circle, as she’s permitted to be present when they discuss their feelings, self-recriminations, determination to improve, etc. Ryuji endeared himself to me by crying over the loss, and even playful Rui had some harsh words for himself. I’m starting to feel like this heartwarming series might be just what I need to sustain me when Kimi ni Todoke wraps up its run in another couple of volumes. Definitely recommended. – Michelle Smith

Wake Up, Sleeping Beauty, Vol. 2 | By Megumi Morino | Kodansha Comics – It’s rare that we get to see a male lead dealing with his weaknesses as much as Tetsu does here. Still dealing with family issues, his general fear of the supernatural, and the simple nature of what’s going on with Shizu, he’s not making the best choices all the time. But he’s trying, and he’s a good kid. As for Shizu, we do eventually see more of her actual self, though that may be a worrying part of the story—due to her constant possession, she has very little idea of who she is or what she likes. That said, she’s starting to like Tetsu, and I’m wondering what will happen when she decides that she wants to control her own action more. Meanwhile, yay, a clearly villainous dad arrives just in time for the cliffhanger! Intriguing. – Sean Gaffney

Wake Up, Sleeping Beauty, Vol. 2 | By Megumi Morino | Kodansha Comics – I really appreciate Tetsu’s sense of ethics here. He’s still afraid of Shizu and her situation, but thinks to himself, “I have to earn what I’m being paid. I have to stop being scared and be a better friend to her.” Soon, he realizes that he’s not actually afraid of Haru and Shinobu, the friendly spirits who regularly inhabit Shizu and look after her, and even infuriating Mirei helps him to loosen up. It’s just Shizu herself who scares him, since she lacks a strong sense of self, but he endeavors to learn her likes and dislikes and soon realizes that she’s actively trying to make him happy. She just has an utterly self-sacrificing way of going about it. What could’ve made her this way? Enter Evil Dad, right on cue. I will definitely be seeing this short series through to its conclusion. – Michelle Smith

Anonymous Noise, Vol. 6 | By Ryoko Fukuyama | VIZ Media – On the heels of the electrifying performance in volume five, volume six was likely destined to be somewhat of a disappointment. The story jumps ahead three months. Momo has been gone the whole time—for completely unclear reasons he insists he can’t stay and be together with Nino—and Nino has been in a singing slump. Meanwhile, Yuzu has made some mysterious promise to his mother and has been composing like a fiend, although nothing he’s written is very good. This volume is, essentially, about everyone finding the desire to move forward, be it Nino learning that her voice did reach Momo before he left, or Yuzu realizing Momo’s songs are currently better than his, or Haruyoshi convincing Miou to go out with him. I suppose it’s good that I care a little more about the band members now, but that central love triangle is never going to captivate me. – Michelle Smith

Dreamin’ Sun, Vol. 5 | By Ichigo Takano | Seven Seas – The beginning of this volume is excruciatingly cringe-inducing, as Shimana (teen girl) attempts to induce Fujiwara (grown man) to fall in love with her by dramatically proclaiming her love in a crowded auditorium at her school’s Founder’s Day Festival. It was so bad I actively wanted him to reject her, but he bafflingly agrees to consider it. It seems like he’ll say no, but then one of the teachers, with whom he obviously has a history, shows up and suddenly he declares that he likes Shimana and is going to date her. Later, he clarifies that he doesn’t like her the same way she likes him, but that he’s determined to fall for her. Um, why her? Why not the perfectly nice age-appropriate lady who likes you?! The creepy teacher keeps popping up and it turns out she has a kid… who looks to me like Fujiwara! Dun dun dun. – Michelle Smith

Dreamin’ Sun, Vol. 5 | By Ichigo Takano | Seven Seas – I was impressed that this volume went in a few ways that I wasn’t expecting it to. After Shimana’s public confession, which made me cringe because I HATE THOSE, I was expecting a rejection, as the landlord clearly is not that into her. But he agrees to date her, which made me wonder if this was going to get a lot more angsty than I was expecting. Then, much to my surprise, we get an awesome conversation where he admits he doesn’t love her but wants to—he wants her to make him fall for him. That’s rather sweet, but could also go SO BADLY. Given we’re at the halfway point of the series, I’m expecting things may get worse before they get better. Also wow, did Zen get written out entirely? Poor Zen! – Sean Gaffney

Imperfect Girl, Vol. 2 | By NISIOISIN and Mitsuru Hattori | Vertical Comics – The story makes no bones about the sheer brokenness of both main characters, and much as “U” is clearly the more broken of the two, I like that it doesn’t skimp on showing us just how screwed up our narrator is. The “looking back at my past” narration helps there as well, though the best chapter in this volume may be the one that shows us the girl’s day at school. (I was expecting her to be bullied, but no.) That said, the preview worries me, and I really hope that this series stays away from any disquieting relationships. I think it will, though, if only as there’s only one volume left. I series that runs almost entirely on pure mood, but that’s not really a bad thing. – Sean Gaffney

Natsume’s Book of Friends, Vol. 21 | By Yuki Midorikawa | VIZ Media – I hope I always feel this delighted to read a new volume of Natsume’s Book of Friends. There are some truly charming stories this time. First, Natsume helps a lowly minion wake his master when others (including Nyanko-sensei) would like to thwart him and receive the reward themselves. Next, he helps the yokai protector of a bookstore defeat an evil spirit, and there’s a few nice moments between the yokai and Natsume’s friend, Kitamoto. But my very, very, very favorite story involves a miniature clay figurine of Nyanko-sensei and the noble spirit who inhabits it. There’s something so adorable and touching about watching this dinky little kitty making sure he’s taken care of the evil spirits near the shrine where he used to live before finally moving on, paddling along a stream in his little wooden bowl. I couldn’t possibly love it more. – Michelle Smith

Neon Genesis Evangelion: Legend of the Piko Piko Middle School Students, Vol. 2 | By Yushi Kawata, Yukito and khara | Dark Horse Comics – It has always seemed to me that Evangelion has had more “gag comic” spinoffs than most series, and with Piko Piko they seem to have hit on a real winner. While it’s hard to top the amazing front cover, I found myself laughing hard at multiple times while reading this, which is all you want out of a humor title. The cast are exaggerated to extremes, but still feel in character, oddly enough. There are a lot of hysterical visuals, such as the sushi belt, but the dialogue takes the cake—Carl Horn’s adaptation is absolutely the best reason to buy this, and adds so much to what’s already pretty funny. Honestly, this may be the most enjoyable Evangelion that’s not the original manga. – Sean Gaffney

Pandora in the Crimson Shell: Ghost Urn, Vol. 9 | By Shirow Masamune and Rikudou Koushi | Seven Seas – The most interesting part of this volume of Pandora may come in the author’s notes, where Rikudou admits he’s not drawing the manga anymore, but has farmed it out to Hitotose Rin due to health issues. He’s still doing the story (thus presumably confirming that Shirow’s no longer even remotely involved), but there’s no change in the artist credit either, no doubt due to Japanese manga rules. As for the volume itself, it was fairly light and fluffy for a Pandora volume, and the sequence with the runner who had prosthetics verged on being interesting. Still, I found myself getting bored faster than usual, making me wonder if this is finally the time to drop it. – Sean Gaffney

Anonymous Noise, Vol. 6 | By Ryoko Fukuyama | Viz Media – Theoretically, a bare minimum of screaming should mean a substandard volume, but I must admit the tortured soap opera plot of Anonymous Noise is growing on me a bit. I mean, there are still a few issues—Momo runs away from his love problems like many other manga love interests (though usually it’s the woman who’s running off), and the attempt to have him get to know his new classmates is awkward and fake—deliberately so, I suspect. And Nino and Yuzu are having a spat, but also have music coursing through them—well, Yuzu does, Nino is trying to learn how to sing in a non-screaming way and not doing well. Meanwhile, the secondary pairings are starting to happen. How much longer does this run if they’re pairing the spares? – Sean Gaffney

Blue Exorcist, Vol. 18 | By Kazue Kato | Viz Media – There is interesting stuff going on here, like the resolution of Shura’s mini-arc (complete with dramatic haircut) and Amaimon coming in as a transfer student and immediately beign a giant jackass. But I’m most impressed with Shiemi’s response to Rin’s confession, which is very honest, has a long look at why this is totally in character for her, and sinks the ship but perhaps not permanently—this isn’t an “I love someone else” rejection so much as a “I have no idea how to love” rejection. Rin also takes it in a very mature way, insisting that they’re still friends and he will help her achieve her goals of becoming an exorcist. As love confessions that don’t work out go, this is absolutely top tier. – Sean Gaffney

Haikyu!!, Vol. 19 | By Haruichi Furudate | Viz Media – Back and forth we go, and for a lot of this volume it’s part two of what we had the previous volume, showing that Tsukishima is growing and learning a whole lot, and what’s more, may actually be (hold on to your hats) ENJOYING volleyball. Now it’s Hinata’s turn, as being short means he has to work even harder and use even more energy, and “try to block properly” is mean, but also accurate. And so our heroes are up against a wall again, but I’m sure someone will have a revelation or use a cool move or… I’m so sorry, I enjoy Haikyu!! a lot, but there’s a limit to what I can talk about in a review. SPORTSBALL! Also, that extra comedy manga at the end reeks of “getting around untranslatable Japanese wordplay.” – Sean Gaffney

Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You, Vol. 28 | By Karuho Shiina | VIZ Media – I have recently learned that this series is complete in 30 volumes and I am not ready for it to be over yet! That said, it definitely feels like things are moving in that direction. This volume covers Christmas and New Year’s (and Sawako’s blizzard-induced sleepover at Kazehaya’s house during which nothing more serious than kissing ensues), after which everyone will have a couple of weeks to study at home before their college admission tests. Sawako and Kazehaya seem poised to weather their upcoming separation just fine, Chizu tells Toru that she’s dating his brother, and Ayane… repeatedly gets flustered in Pin’s presence. Am I assigning too deep a meaning to the panel where he promises quite seriously to “think about it” regarding giving her a gift if she passes her exams? I can’t believe I’m rooting for a student-teacher romance! – Michelle Smith

Natsume’s Book of Friends, Vol. 21 | By Yuki Midorikawa | Viz Media – As the author herself notes in her copious afterword notes, we’ve rarely seen Natsume and Nyanko-sensei at odds, and I’m not sure that the author really pulls it off in this battle to see who earns the sleeping god’s favor and gets sake as a reward. (To be fair, the author admits this as well.) My favorite story in this volume involved Natsume’s friend Kitamoto, one of “those two guys” in his class, and a bookshop with a cute yokai acting as the clerk. Mostly as I like old bookshops. That said, I suspect most fans of this series will be most interested in the final chapter, which flashes back again to the wacky teenage misadventures of Natori, Matoba, and their amazing powers of bishonen. A good solid volume. – Sean Gaffney

The Night Beyond the Tricornered Window, Vol. 4 | By Tomoko Yamashita | SuBLime – We begin with Mikado taking a case to Mukae instead of Hiyakawa because he’s thrown by the latter’s suggestion that they could make money cursing people. Even after Mukae tells him that Hiyakawa has placed a “leash” on him binding them together, he’s still unable to forget how much Hiyakawa has helped him and can’t simply abandon him. In the end, and without Yamashita-sensei actually spelling it out, it seems that Mikado’s plan is to take a more active role in helping people, using the bond between them to pull Hiyakawa along onto a more righteous path. I do dearly love how Yamashita trusts her readers to understand things. This particularly comes into play in the chapter about Mikado’s parents and the poignant nonverbal panel in which Mikado’s father realizes that his son has inherited his abilities. All of this plus some ongoing plot threads make for a standout volume. – Michelle Smith

Species Domain, Vol. 4 | By Shunsuke Noro | Seven Seas – Again, I am impressed by how well the author is sticking to Dowa being a dwarf, which means not only does she have her big bushy beard, but when we get the obligatory beach arc, we see her swimsuit body and she is absolutely ripped, as you would expect from a dwarf. The beach arc itself is mostly a bunch of shenanigans, as the two rival clubs face off against each other in a series of amusing contests. More interesting is the ship tease between Ohki and Kazaori, both at the start (a forced date) and at the end, where Ohki’s “future vision” invention works a bit too well, and gives us a Kazamori who has literally lived the next ten years. And yes, she spoils everyone. A fantastic non-perverse monster series. – Sean Gaffney

The Water Dragon’s Bride, Vol. 4 | By Rei Toma | VIZ Media – In order to interact with and understand Asahi more, the Water Dragon God has taken on the guise of a human. When Asahi requests that he take her and Subaru somewhere fun, they end up attracting notice and, ultimately, Asahi is summoned by the child emperor, who refuses to believe she doesn’t have some kind of special powers, since she’s hanging out with a god. There’s an interesting balance here between slow-burn relationship stuff—Asahi attempts to shield her steadfast protector Subaru from the knowledge that she desperately wants to go home (though he knows already) and the Water Dragon God makes strides toward caring about Asahi’s feelings—and worldbuilding, what with the introduction of the emperor and some rumination on the possible loneliness of gods. I definitely plan to keep reading! – Michelle Smith

Drifters, Vol. 5 | By Kohta Hirano | Dark Horse Comics – It is becoming harder to avoid mentioning the elephant in the room with the Drifters series, which is that the lead villain, the so-called “Black King,” is clearly meant to be Jesus Christ. If that weren’t plainly obvious yet, it’s definitely obvious when we hear the Black King can give his troops food by breaking loaves and fishes. The author will likely avoid showing his face or naming him for obvious reasons, but he’s certainly enjoying teasing us. In fact, that’s the main reason to read Drifters. It may be frustrating, confusing, sexist, and filled with more goofy superdeformed caricatures than actual serious poses, but you can tell on every page that the author is having an absolute ball drawing it. – Sean Gaffney

The Full-Time Wife Escapist, Vol. 8 | By Tsunami Umino | Kodansha Comics (digital only) – Mikuri and Hiramasa continue to live separately and, as he grows increasingly anxious about the situation, we see her discovering that she’s really good at coming up with ideas to help a local business association attract more customers. This is interesting, but waaaay more compelling is the dynamic between Mikuri’s aunt Yuri and Kazami, a man 25 years her junior who has confessed his romantic interest in her. I really love getting to see Kazami be embarrassed and vulnerable, and the insights into his past are valuable. Despite having many girlfriends, he has little experience with romance, and even though Yuri rejects him in the end, he’s still grateful to know that he was capable of genuinely falling for someone. Of course, I still hope they’ll get together in the ninth and final volume. Looking forward to it, even though I’ll miss this series! – Michelle Smith

Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You, Vol. 28 | By Karuho Shiina | Viz Media – The manga keeps rolling along, and the only remaining unresolved plot, aside from “will everyone pass their exams?,” is Ayano and Pin. As a result, that shoulders the bulk of what’s going on here, and it’s still unclear if Shiina is actually going to pull the trigger or not. In fact, it’s unclear if Pin is being overly dense or if he is deliberately being overly dense—I suspect the latter. Certainly the rest of the cast have no trouble with Ayano going after her teacher, possibly as she’s ALMOST of age, as opposed to a lot of other teacher/student romance manga. Beyond that, we get warm and fuzzy by the bucketload, including Sawako spending the night at Kazehaya’s house (no, nothing happens.) – Sean Gaffney

Of the Red, the Light, and the Ayakashi, Vol. 9 | By nanao and HaccaWorks* | Yen Press – The main story of Of the Red… ends here, with many things explained, including the fates of Yoshiki and Akane as well as Yue’s origins. It’s bittersweet and more or less makes sense. That said, there have always been a few things about this series that I’ve never really understood, and though I’ve got a better sense of things now, I’m still not 100% clear on how things happened at the end. But I think I know, and I like the characters and the atmosphere, and that’s evidently good enough for me to enjoy a series. I’m looking forward to volume ten, which appears to be an epilogue of sorts, and wouldn’t grumble too much if the bittersweet ending became a happier one. – Michelle Smith

One Week Friends, Vol. 1 | By Matcha Hazuki | Yen Press – I’m quite fond of a lot of 4-koma-style slice-of-life series. I’m quite fond of cute-but-serious romances. Combining the two of them, though, I’m not sure if it works out. I suspect the author and publisher aren’t too sure either, as One Week Friends waffles back and forth between 4-koma style and longer, regular manga-style stories. The issue is there aren’t very good punchlines in the 4-koma, which defeats the purpose. The story itself, about a girl who for some reason or another forgets all her good memories after one week (and thus can never make friends) is decent enough, but I kept watching it slowly stop and start and try to rev its engine and the whole thing just needed to be better. – Sean Gaffney

Say I Love You., Vol. 18 | By Kanae Hazuki | Kodansha Comics – And so another shoujo manga comes to an end. Yamato and Mei’s post-high school life has sped along, and now Yamato is out of college and struggling to get his photography career off the ground. It’s nice to see he’s not instantly hailed as some superstar, and by the time he achieves sufficient success to propose to Mei (evidently when they’re both 25), it feels hard-won. Too, I appreciated Megumi’s struggles, and liked how her story played out, both career-wise and romantically. I suppose the fact that everyone ends up paired off and/or married is a shoujo trope, but it still makes for a satisfying resolution, and I admit I totally cried at Yamato’s proposal. I’ve really enjoyed this series and look forward to rereading it one day. Definitely a keeper. – Michelle Smith

A Terrified Teacher at Ghoul School!, Vol. 1 | By Mai Tanaka | Yen Press – Another day, another yokai series—I’m starting to miss vampires, let me tell you. This one is definitely on the comedic side, and features the titular terrified teacher, Haruki, as he starts at a new school only to discover that everyone in it is some sort of yokai. For the most part, the yokai we see are very traditional, and we get such classics as the girl with the long neck and the Zashiki-warashi. There are extensive endnotes, which are helpful, and the class is goofy and fun without being annoying. Unfortunately, the same can’t be said about the teacher—I simply didn’t like Haruki much, and given he’s the star that’s a problem. I hope he gets a bit less terrified as this goes on. – Sean Gaffney

The Water Dragon’s Bride, Vol. 4 | By Rei Toma | Viz Media – I enjoy each volume of this more than the last, always a good thing with an ongoing manga series. Here we get more of the Water Dragon God trying his best to see how humans work, and for the most part failing rather miserably. He’s still a jerk (and indeed Asahi tells him this), but he’s also the most interesting romantic interest, as Subaru has unfortunately become a bit faceless. And there’s also the problem that they’re starting to get noticed, which brings Asahi to the Emperor of Not-Japan, who is young and clearly wants a miracle worker, whereas all Asahi can offer him is human advice. (Also terrific impressions.) I’ve never gotten into Toma’s stuff before, but this is really good. – Sean Gaffney

Yowamushi Pedal, Vol. 7 | By Wataru Watanabe | Yen Press – We’ve finished Day One of the race, and the result is… well, let’s just say inconclusive. It does remind you why Midosouji is such a good antagonist, though, and it’s not just for his extremely creepy faces. (It is mostly for that.) Meanwhile, it was just about time for the unfortunate injury to occur, though here it’s not so much an injury as illness that does in Tadokoro, who seems to be suffering from heat exhaustion of some sort. Fortunately, Onoda is not about to leave anyone behind, even as everyone else is telling him to do so. That’s just not how he rolls. Singing Pretty Princess songs is how he rolls. Will Day Two finish by the end of the next omnibus? I wouldn’t bank on it. – Sean Gaffney