Manga Bookshelf

Discussion, Resources, Roundtables, & Reviews

Sean Gaffney

Yona of the Dawn, Vol. 5

by

By Mizuho Kusanagi. Released in Japan as “Akatsuki no Yona” by Hakusensha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Hana to Yume. Released in North America by Viz. Translated by JN Productions, Adapted by Ysabet Reinhardt MacFarlane.

In general, I’m always a bit wary of ‘chosen one’ narratives, which Yona of the Dawn is shaping up into being. The difficulty is striking a balance between following the chosen one because you know they will be a good person who can change the world, and following the chosen one out of a literal compulsion you can’t control that draws you to them. Yona of the Dawn tries to have this both ways, and I like that the new Dragon, Jaeha, is reluctant to follow his supposed destiny, being very happy being what he is, which is a showboating, girl-loving pirate with the classic Hana to Yume “sleepy eyes”. Of course, this is still a shoujo manga, and thus the cliffhanger has him running into Yona and immediately his heart skips a beat, because of course it does – if you’re going to write romance cliches, do them properly.

Meanwhile, as predicted, the Blue Dragon decides to come with them, and even gets named by Yona, who is, of course, still the Chosen One but balances this out by being caring and loving and sweet and nice, etc. Names turn out to be pretty important in this book, as the male cast who aren’t Hak gradually start to call Yona by her first name. Hak is an exception, though, and this is the best scene in the volume, as Yona tells him the reasons that she wants him to still call her “your highness” and treat her as royalty. It’s so that they don’t forget her father or what he did. This is immediately followed up with the heartbreaking revelation that most people in the country seem to regard the late King with contempt as a terrible King, much to Yona’s distress. (In reality, putting the distance between her and Hak may be authorial fiat – let’s face it, this is a reverse harem manga with an obvious endgame, and it’s best to delay it as much as possible.)

Most of this volume is, of course, the standard quest, as Yona and company continue wandering the land hunting for Dragon Warriors. This means that they have to stop and fight injustice whenever they can, of course, even if they’re supposed to keep a low profile (Yona’s red hair really does not help with stealth missions). The humor in this book is fairly predictable, mostly revolving around Hak’s inability to practice what he preaches, and everyone (including Yona) seeming to think that he spent time in a brothel, much to his frustration. Jaeha looks like an excellent addition to the cast, balancing nicely with the other guys’ personalities. This of course assumes that he does join the main cast, and I suspect the next volume will show us Yona trying to convince him of the righteousness of her cause.

In the end, this is another top-notch volume of Yona of the Dawn, which continues to be one of Shojo Beat’s best series.

Bookshelf Briefs 4/17/17

by and Leave a Comment

The Demon Prince of Momochi House, Vol. 8 | By Aya Shouoto | VIZ Media – Even though they both involve a girl with modest spiritual powers and a sexy, white-haired, fox-eared ayakashi guy, The Demon Prince of Momochi House is quite a distinct entity from Kamisama Kiss. That said, this volume’s plotline is somewhat reminiscent, as Himari goes in search of Aoi’s past in order to help him with a present predicament. What she finds out is quite sad, as readers likely expected, but the part I liked the best was when she was presented with the choice to either delve into Aoi’s past or her own. After indulging in a single pang for the things she was passing up, she chooses Aoi without hesitation. I always seem to say that this is Shouto’s best series by far, but it continues to be true. – Michelle Smith

Domestic Girlfriend, Vol. 1 | By Kei Sasuga | Kodansha Comics (digital only) – This manga begins with the hero losing his virginity to a girl he just met, a somewhat unusual start for a romantic drama. Said hero, Natsuo, has a crush on his young teacher, and hopes this might get it out of his system. He then finds out that his father is remarrying, and the new wife is bringing along her two daughters. If you guessed the girl he slept with, one point, but you get ten points if you guessed that the teacher is ALSO now part of his family. And so begins a torrid soap opera of a manga. I found it worked best when not focused on the romance—Natsuo’s attempts to help stoic Rui make friends was hilarious, as was his dramatization of two people having an affair. A decent start, recommended for those who like more mature titles. – Sean Gaffney

Kuroko’s Basketball, Vols. 9-10 | By Tadatoshi Fujimaki | Viz Media – There’s a lot of character development in this omnibus—everyone’s trying to improve, even Kuroko, who’s practicing a secret move. We also get even more new characters, one of whom thankfully has long hair so I can easily pick him out from all of the crew-cut guys in this series. The sports manga cliches are all present and correct, but they’re well done—one of the best ways to tell a sports manga is exceptional is that you care equally whether they’re in a game or not. The game provides the cliffhanger, though, as Seirin gets a rematch with Shutoku and we find out that Midorima has been working on improving as well. Each volume seems to coincide with a desperate cliffhanger—bring on the next one. – Sean Gaffney

Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic, Vol. 23 | By Shinobu Ohtaka | Viz Media – I knew we’d get more flashback here, but I wasn’t aware it would take up all of this volume (and presumably some of the next). In addition to hooking up Solomon and Sheba (who no doubt have Aladdin as their child), a romance that is honestly a bit rushed and underdeveloped, we also get discussion of the difference between a strong leader who rules with the will of the people and a king who rules by fiat. Solomon wants to avoid becoming power mad, a good lesson to learn, and is not being helped by everyone asking him to essentially be their chosen one. Meanwhile, David is still around, and not quite dead. A lot of good stuff, and even a bit of humor, but I’m wanting to get back to our main cast. – Sean Gaffney

Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic, Vol. 23 | By Shinobu Ohtaka | VIZ Media – Aladdin’s tale of the fate of Alma Tran continues. Solomon was the son of King David, an arrogant and authoritarian ruler, and desperately did not want to become like him. He strove to unite all species, aided by several faithful companions, including powerful magician girl named Sheba who falls in love with him. In time, he ends up reluctantly accepting the mantle of kinghood, and fathers a child with Sheba who I am assuming will turn out to be Aladdin. It’s not that it isn’t a compelling story, but it drags in spots when delving into deep discussions of rukh, and it still isn’t over, as the volume ends on a cliffhanger. I continue to be impressed with how complex Magi is for a shounen manga, but this might be a better volume to read when you’ve got the next one handy. – Michelle Smith

Pandora in the Crimson Shell: Ghost Urn, Vol. 7 | By Shirow Masamune and Rikudou Koushi | Seven Seas – Lots of action this time round means less wacky fanservice comedy, though there is an “activation” sequence, and the villain finds that opening what he thinks is the final firewall to what he wants merely uploads Buer’s upskirt pics to the entire world. Fortunately, most of it really is the cool action sequences, which are reasonably well done and clever, and show strong heroes and easy-to-hate villains. Lots of amusing cameos as well—in addition to Kabapu and his secretary as always, I saw “Sader” at one point, as well as Tatsuya and Miyuki from Mahouka. Pandora will always be a combination of mecha (Shirow), fanservice (both authors), and whatever the heck Rikdou wants to do. Pandora is Pandora. – Sean Gaffney

Pick of the Week: Endings and Beginnings

by , , , , and Leave a Comment

SEAN: An avalanche of stuff this week. Baccano!, Horimiya, Sword Art Online… so many things. I think I have to go with the final Fruits Basket, which has been a fantastic re-release, and one of the best shoujo out there. Buy it and be frustrated by the final side pairings!

MICHELLE: I love Horimiya and Liselotte and Fruits Basket, but my most exuberant squee is reserved for the latest omnibus of Yowamushi Pedal!

KATE: I don’t know much about Yokai Diary, though the cover art and promotional blurb irresistibly remind me of the kind of manga TOKYOPOP used to license by the truckload. Count me in for this one!

ASH: I’m definitely torn this week. Like Michelle, I’m probably most excited for Yowamushi Pedal (and the wait between omnibuses seems far too long), but like Kate, the debut of Ghost Diary has definitely caught my attention.

ANNA: Ghost Diary does look interesting, that will have to be my pick as well!

MJ: There’s a big part of me that wants to go with Ghost Diary but the cover art has me all conflicted… Do I trust Seven Seas enough to give it a shot? I don’t know. In the interest of safety, I’ll join Sean in celebrating the last of the gorgeous Fruits Basket omnibus series. I’m pretty thrilled with that.

Paying to Win in a VRMMO, Vol. 2

by

By Blitz Kiva and Kuwashima Rein. Released in Japan as “VRMMO wo Kane no Chikara de Musou suru” by Hobby Japan. Released in North America digitally by J-Novel Club. Translated by Elizabeth Ellis.

Having established its premise and characters in the first book, the Paying to Win series goes about trying to tweak and fix a few things that weren’t as strong as they could be in the second. This involves a) introducing a new potential love interest who isn’t in middle school and Ichiro’s cousin, and is also able to be a little more critical of Ichiro’s callous lack of tact; b) have a flashback to show us how he managed to get so ridiculously leveled up before Asuha was able to join him, and also explain things like how he got a suit of armor that is literally a business suit. But most importantly, and most effectively, this second volume doubles down on showing you how obviously, knowingly, and teeth-grindingly irritating Ichiro is to everyone and everything around him, and the effect this has on both the secondary characters and the reader.

I cannot emphasize this enough: holy Mother of God, Ichiro is annoying. You will want to punch him in his cool, smug, self-satisfied face multiple times as you read this book. It’s far more clear in this second novel that it’s deliberate, and reader sympathy is meant to be with the young gamer and wannabe fashion maven Iris rather than him. He is the sort of character that, were he an antagonist or a villain, would receive the absolute best retribution possible, possibly while screaming “THIS CANNOT BE!!!”. Sadly, Ichiro is the hero, and the book’s whole purpose is that he really is this good at everything. Only King Kirihito was able to actually challenge him in the game, and since this is a flashback to the previous week, you know that he’s going to succeed at everything ridiculously easily here. That said, I liked his insistence that it doesn’t matter if Iris’ butterfly brooch is aesthetically good or not – he likes it, so therefore it’s fine.

Iris herself is a good character, far more developed than Asuha/Felecia, mostly as she gets to express everything the reader wants to. Every time Ichiro praises her creations, it sounds like he’s really calling them awful, simply due to how bluntly he speaks all the time. I liked the glimpses of her real-world life, and showing off how talented kids who are used to being the center of attention can get crushed when they go to a school that specializes in talented kids and realize other people are, in fact, better than they are. She also has a nice sense for biting retorts, as I’ve said. The author’s afterword says that webnovel readers have nicknamed her “the Evil God”, and I look forward to seeing why, though I can hazard a guess or two.

Other than Iris, the main reason to plow through this book despite Ichiro is the writing style – it’s funny and assured, and the narration has its own distinct voice, something I always enjoy. This is also due to the translation, of course, which is excellent – probably my favorite J-Novel Club translation to date in terms of noticing the quality (though Sera did get gendered at one point, which only serves to remind us how ridiculously difficult it is to avoid giving away gender in English). Recommended to anyone who loves seeing smug jackasses win effortlessly and be smug about it. Also, bonus points for having Voltron show up, only one volume after the SAO sentai team parody.

The Water Dragon’s Bride, Vol. 1

by

By Rei Toma. Released in Japan as “Suijin no Ikenie” by Shogakukan, serialization ongoing in the magazine Cheese!. Released in North America by Viz Media. Translated by Abby Lehrke.

Holy catfish, this is dark. Don’t be thrown off by the cutesy picture of the heroine looking adorable on the cover, this is a fantasy that comes close to pure horror at times. Starting off with every parent’s worst nightmare, we move from crisis situation to crisis situation, and it’s a small miracle that Asahi (the aforementioned heroine) manages to be as strong as she does throughout. The water dragon in question is one of those “what are these strange things called human emotions” types, who has to be reminded of things like “humans eat in order to stay alive” She manages to find a good friend in a small village, but sadly Subaru’s mother comes from the School Of Evil Moms (TM) and Asahi ends up in probably worse trouble than if she’d just stayed hidden. There’s a lot going on here, so it’s a good thing you can’t tear your eyes from it.

We actually start off in modern times, as Asahi is a normal and seemingly somewhat spoiled girl who ends up being literally dragged into her family’s backyard pond by a wave of water and winds up in a fantasy-style world. (I have a sneaking suspicion the parents will never be seen again, and shudder to think of their reaction to their daughter literally vanishing when they turned away briefly.) Luckily, she meets Subaru, a nice young kid about her age. Sadly, she has pink hair and purple eyes, something that this world does not seem to have run across, and therefore must be EEEEEVIL. As a result, they perform a ritual to the local Water God and offer up Asahi, which is to say they tie a large rock to her ankle and throw her to the bottom of the lake. Then she meets the Water Dragon, who reminds me a bit of Ayame from Fruits Basket. Sadly, it’s Ayame before he grew up and wised up, so he’s pretty much a callous jackass.

Things move on from there, and I won’t keep describing the plot, but I will once again say that there’s some amazingly traumatic stuff in here, and the artist captures it beautifully. Asahi’s sacrifice, the starvation, the skeletons in the water, the hallucinations of each other that she and Subaru see… there’s a good reason this runs in shoujo/josei hybrid Cheese! and not, say, Ribon. That said, it’s not all doom and gloom, mostly thanks to Asahi’s basic spunky personality, as even when she’s despairing she still tries hard. And there are a few laughs in the book, mostly involving the Water God getting roundly mocked by the other nature gods for being, well, a petulant manchild. I have no doubt that his maturation, with the help of Asahi, is the point of this book. That said, Asahi is about 8-9 years old, so if it does end up being a romance I’m rooting for her kid friend rather than the God. I suspect a timeskip in the near future.

In short, I was somewhat blown away by this new series. Dark it may be, but I can’t wait to read more.

Manga the Week of 4/19

by , , , and Leave a Comment

SEAN: It’s another one of those weeks next week. Hunker down.

We start off with J-Novel Club, which has the 3rd volume of Grimgar of Fantasy and Ash. This is the first book that wasn’t adapted to the anime (which stopped with Book 2), and is apparently even more grim than Grimgar normally is.

Kodansha has its usual plethora of digital-only license rescues next week. Alive 13, Gakuen Prince 11, Pumpkin Scissors 10, and Yozakura Quartet 9.

ANNA: I liked some of these when they were coming out, but probably not enough to snag them as digital only. Still, this is so nice for fans of these series who were left in limbo before!

SEAN: If you enjoy Attack on Titan’s anime adaptation, which has just started up again, Kodansha has Attack on Titan: The Anime Guide.

And Attack on Titan: Before the Fall has now reached double-digits, and still has more plot to go.

ASH: Overall, I do like the Before the Fall manga more than I like the original light novel; it seems more well-developed to me.

SEAN: Kodansha had some digital-only debuts THIS week, which I didn’t mention last week as Kodansha didn’t announce them till the day they came out, much to my frustration. The first is Domestic Girlfriend, a shonen romantic drama from the creator of fan-favorite GE Good Ending. It’s the shonen equivalent to those “shoujo potboilers” I talk about.

The second is a more familiar face: GTO: Paradise Lost has its first volume out. This has been running on Crunchyroll’s manga list for some time. It features Onizuka… in jail?

MJ: Hmmmm, I’m always a fan of GTO, so I may check this out.

SEAN: Back to next week: Kiss Him Not Me! has also reached double digits, and will likely go longer now that Kae has been reassured she doesn’t have to worry about stringing her guys along.

Maga-Tsuki has 13 volumes, and this is the 7th, so it’s the halfway point.

And there’s a 4th Welcome to the Ballroom, which I expect features our lead collapsing in exhaustion.

MICHELLE: Heh.

ANNA: Already behind on this series!

SEAN: One Peace has more than one title out this week! The first is the 4th volume of heartwarming, oddball, and sort of creepy Kuma Miko.

And there’s a 7th volume of Rise of the Shield Hero, for those who like isekai-style male power fantasies.

Seven Seas has an 11th Dragonar Academy.

Ghost Diary is the debut from Seven Seas, a supernatural fantasy from Dengeki Daioh that, at 3 volumes, is at least short. That said, it looks more on the Ancient Magus’ Bride end of the spectrum.

ASH: I’m really curious about this one! (Also, I didn’t realize it was only three volumes.)

ANNA: Huh, that sounds manageable.

SEAN: I missed a SuBLime title last week; they also have a 2nd volume of Spiritual Police.

MJ: Somehow I must have missed this first volume. But based on the title alone, I’m inclined to check it out.

SEAN: Vertical Comics gives us a 4th volume of Immortal Hounds.

Viz has a double dose of Tokyo Ghoul. Not only do we get the 12th volume, but we also get another novel based off the series, called Past.

And now let’s jump into Yen, starting with the light novels from Yen On. The Asterisk War has a 3rd volume of magical school battles.

Baccano! has a 4th volume the last one to be adapted to the anime. That said, the anime cut about half the novel from its adaptation, so there’s lots of new content for fans to get into here.

Black Bullet’s 6th volume wraps up another two-volume arc. Will it be depressing? Bet on it.

The Devil Is a Part-Timer! has a 7th volume that is composed of short stories set towards the start of the series.

Goblin Slayer’s 2nd volume promises a lot more… well, goblin slaying.

The Irregular at Magic High School’s 4th volume will wrap up its tournament arc, and is a very long book. It would be the longest out this month except…

Is It Wrong To Try To Pick Up Girls In A Dungeon? tops it, with this 8th volume (ALSO composed of short stories) hitting 400 pages or so.

KonoSuba rolls out its 2nd volume only two months after its first (I think the first was meant to be December), and hopefully will be as hilarious as that first volume was.

The debut novel is much anticipated. Rokka: Braves of the Six Flowers, a fantasy with heroes and stuff that… OK, I know extremely little about, but I look forward to finding out.

Sword Art Online has a 10th volume, and Kirito is still stuck in Alice-land. Will he and Eugeo be able to rescue her? And will our other regulars get mentioned at all?

MJ: i have fallen way behind in my SAO reading… going to have to fix that.

SEAN: As for Yen’s manga titles, there’s a 10th Akame Ga KILL!.

Alice in Murderland has a 6th volume of very very pretty looking murder.

Aoharu x Machinegun has a 4th print volume.

ASH: So far I’ve only read the first volume of Aoharu x Machinegun, but I found it entertaining and so plan on reading at least a few more volumes.

SEAN: And A Certain Magical Index’s 9th manga volume is adapting the 7th light novel.

Fruits Basket’s Collector’s Edition comes to an end with the 12th and final omnibus. Given the series only had 23 volumes, I expect there will be a lot of extra content at the end to fill it out.

ASH: I’m really glad that Fruits Basket is back in print again. I’ve been meaning to give it a re-read; looks like the time is right for that.

MICHELLE: There was at least one fan book, and maybe two. So I guess a bunch of that stuff will be at the end.

MJ: So much love for this. So much.

ANNA: Looking forward to fan books!

SEAN: Horimiya’s 7th volume will have great romantic comedy and hopefully not have the binding fall apart on me like the 6th volume did.

ASH: Oh, no!

MICHELLE: Yay, Horimiya!

SEAN: KonoSuba also has a 3rd volume of its manga adaptation.

Liselotte & Witch’s Forest has a 4th volume, for a double shot of Takaya.

And everyone’s favorite guilty pleasure, Scum’s Wish, has volume 3.

ASH: I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the first two volumes.

MICHELLE: Me, too.

SEAN: Taboo Tattoo has a 6th volume, and I’m sorry this is starting to sound like a broken record, but I have little to say about these titles.

And I believe this is the 3rd and final volume of survival game manga Tohyo Game.

Finally, Yowamushi Pedal gives us a 5th omnibus or this cycling manga and its desperately earnest hero.

ASH: Woo-hoo! I enjoy Yowamushi Pedal so much! I wish there wasn’t such a wait between omnibuses.

MICHELLE: Same! For a series so long, even the omnibus treatment is going to take forever.

SEAN: That’s a ridiculous amount of manga. Are you getting any?

Assassination Classroom, Vol. 15

by

By Yusei Matsui. Released in Japan by Shueisha, serialized in the magazine Weekly Shonen Jump. Released in North America by Viz. Translated by Tetsuichiro Miyaki. Adapted by Bryant Turnage.

(This review talks about *that* spoiler, the one everyone already knows, but I thought I’d warn you anyway.)

Now that we have the North American Weekly shonen Jump magazine, serializing the popular series at the same time they come out in Japan, surprises are very difficult to hold on to. Doubly so here, as the anime has also aired. But at the time when the Kaede Kayano revelation came out, it was quite a surprise, trust me, and everyone went back to look at their previous volumes to see if this was something truly planned fro the beginning or something that the author came up with on the fly. He helpfully tells us that it’s the former, showing us tiny specs of art that hinted that Kayano was Not What She Seemed. And this extends forward as well, as Kayano is in reality the younger sister of the class’ former teacher, who she alleges that Koro-sensei killed. How that happened is apparently part of the next volume. Yusei Matsui really ties this together beautifully, making it one of the best volumes in this already excellent series.

I’ve complained a few times about how, given she’s the closest thing we get to a female lead among the students, Kayano’s character has been somewhat flat. Now it turns out that this was not only deliberate but engineered on her part, trying not to attract too much attention and therefore setting herself up as the cute but plain friend of the real “main character”, Nagisa. The flashbacks not only show the lengths she went to to engineer her attack on Koro-sensei (who, as she reminds us herself, she named in the first place), but also the tremendous pain that hiding her altered state has caused her over the past several months. It’s been the perfect acting job. That said, sometimes you can get too caught up in your role, and Nagisa sees what Kayano isn’t letting herself – that she really has had fun in this class, made true friendships, and most importantly, has seen that Koro-sensei is maybe not the sister-murdering monster she thought.

This leads to the funniest scene of the volume, where Nagisa has to stop a dying Kayano from burning out her brain due to overuse of her tentacled form. He does this by a callback to Irina’s ‘foreign language techniques’, essentially kissing her into submission. Not only is this great ship fodder for fans of this pairing (and no doubt very annoying to Nagisa/Karma fans), but we also see Irina saying that he could have done better, the other students muttering that *they* could have done better, and Karma and Rio getting pictures and video of the whole thing on their cellphones, because they are glorious assholes. The entire scene just calls out how well-written the whole series is.

There are other things going on here, mostly in the first half. We learn about the principal’s past, which shows – surprise! – that he’s a former idealist who had tragedy turn him to the dark side. And the Peach Boy play, which is hysterical and also features a glorious moment where they discuss Kayano acting in a lead role, and she quickly ducks and says she’ll be in charge of props. (Highlights of the play discussion also include Irina suggesting the student’s do a strip show, and Karma suggesting Nagisa act in drag as Sada Abe (which Viz, wisely probably, forces the curious to Google). If you avoided the series before because it looked too silly or the premise was sketchy, you should definitely catch up, as it’s top tier Shonen Jump. And if you already read the weekly chapters and saw the anime, buy this anyway, as the reread factor is high.

Pick of the Week: ‘Tis the Season to Be Jellyfish

by , , , , and Leave a Comment

MICHELLE: There are a lot of Kodansha releases that I’ll be picking up this week, both digitally and in print, but the one I look forward to the most is the fourth Princess Jellyfish omnibus. It’s always amusing, but offers character development, too!

SEAN: Yeah, out of everything here the thing I most want to read is definitely Princess Jellyfish, though I am intrigued by the new Fujishima title as well.

KATE: I don’t know if I can choose between the fourth volume of Princess Jellyfish and the second volume of Tokyo Tarareba Girls–that’s a little like being asked which of your kids you like best, y’know? Still, deciding between two Akiko Higashimura titles is a great dilemma to have. I’m also intrigued by Toppu GP, even if the title irresistibly reminds me of Ed Sullivan’s old mouse sidekick, so I’ll be checking that out, too.

ANNA: I am also going to throw in for Princess Jellyfish, although I need to read the 3rd volume too. Just more Princess Jellyfish to enjoy!

ASH: Princess Jellyfish is the obvious pick for me this week, too! Of course, I’m very happy to see the gorgeous new edition of Revolutionary Girl Utena finally make its way onto the shelves as well.

MJ: I’m rather torn this week, but I think I will also need to go with Princess Jellyfish. That Utena set is really alluring, though.

Bookshelf Briefs 4/10/17

by and Leave a Comment

Black Clover, Vol. 6 | By Yuki Tabata | Viz Media – Most of this volume is taken up with one big fight, but the single focus is quite welcome, and it helps to give depth to another one of the Black Bulls, as Yami shows up to save our heroes and promptly shows off that his powers are (if you’ll pardon the cliché) on a completely different level from our heroes. He’s utterly cool, and I fully expect he will die tragically somewhere down the line, but that day is not today. Asta also does some leveling up, though, and we see that the Midnight Sun cult is after his grimoire—and is rather ticked off that he has it at all. Black Clover continues to remind me of various series mushed together (Magi stands out this time), but it’s fun and readable. – Sean Gaffney

Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma, Vol. 17 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | Viz Media – I expected a more serious arc and I was right. Erina’s father has changed the rules so that all chefs are equal, but that just means that no one is allowed to express themselves in any way. The middle third of this book is like eating a bag of gravel, as smug snake Eizan is such an obvious villain that even one of his fellow Council members (Rindo, who is wonderful and appears to be siding with the enemy just because she’ll be more entertained by what follows) points it out. Meanwhile, the Polaris Dorm is due to be shut down… or at least it would be, but Megumi and company get out their riot gear and stand their ground. Hard to read in places, but excellent. – Sean Gaffney

Haikyu!!, Vol. 10 | By Haruichi Furudate | Viz Media – I tend to like the training parts of sports manga more than the actual matches, and that proves to be the case here, as this is a stellar volume. Everyone is watching the other teams to try to find ways to improve, and despite a fight over staying the course vs. risking failure with something new, Hinata and Kageyama are the same. The exception is Tsukishima, everyone’s favorite jerk, whose apathy is starting to concern everyone. Surprise, it stems from a tragic flashback that crushed his dreams. Can you really strive to improve yourself if you don’t really care all that much? How do you make something you’re good at fun? Haikyu!! is one of Jump‘s best pickups lately, and I am happy it’s a monthly concern. – Sean Gaffney

Honey So Sweet, Vol. 6 | By Amu Meguro | VIZ Media – Honey So Sweet is consistently cute and adorable, and this volume definitely offers up an assortment of heartwarming moments for our lead couple. That said, a fair amount of what happens here feels like something I’ve seen before. Even within this own series, in fact. It begins with Nao running into yet another wounded delinquent. This time it’s a guy named Nishigaki who, it turns out, idolized Onise in junior high and doesn’t think Nao is cool enough to be his girlfriend. When the new school term begins, he and his twin sister, Miyabi—yes, fraternal twin sibling firsties just like in Say I Love You.—begin attending school with the other characters, and Onise is very nice to socially clueless Miyabi, who seems to be developing feelings for him, which of course worries Nao. Still, I’m sure a happy ending awaits. – Michelle Smith

Honey So Sweet, Vol. 6 | By Amu Meguro | Viz Media – This was a stronger volume than the previous one, despite the fact that we’re introducing yet another love rival. Miyabi is a twin, and also very introverted, to the point that it takes her a minute or so to respond to anything someone has said to her. I appreciated that the solution was not “you just need to be more extroverted,” as it is in many other Japanese manga—the idea of telling people she responds slowly was good. That said, now we get to see how Nao deals with jealousy, though given that this is a pretty sweet manga, I think it will be fine. Taiga’s flashbacks were also quite good, showing off what drew him to Nao and the difficulty he has looking like a thug. Cute shoujo—not top-tier but definitely readable. – Sean Gaffney

In/Spectre, Vol. 3 | By Kyo Shirodaira and Chashiba Katase | Kodansha Comics – This volume has a large hurdle to get over, in that it’s almost entirely exposition, as our trio discuss what Nanase really is and how to deal with her, along with a heavy dose of Japanese urban legends. Luckily, Kotoko’s amazing pettiness and jealousy still livens things up, and despite her discussion of losing her virginity in the first book you sense she and Kuro haven’t gotten very far at all. We also get a discussion of how Kuro wins his fights—he can alter probabilities, to an extent. Of course, this tends to involve seeing a lot of bad futures. And he can’t be everywhere, as the cliffhanger shows another murder gumming things up. I still find this quirky mystery refreshing. – Sean Gaffney

Yona of the Dawn, Vol. 5 | By Mizuho Kusanagi | VIZ Media – It was a foregone conclusion that Yona would persuade the Blue Dragon—ostracized for his abilities—to join her, but despite the predictability, her acceptance of him is still touching. She names him Sinha, and with his awkward kindness, he instantly becomes my favorite character. Unfortunately, he’s promptly sidelined during the second half of the volume, as the gang ventures into a port town in search of the Green Dragon, a pirate named Jaeha who plans to fight to escape his fate. And then he sees Yona at the end of the volume. I hereby predict that he will be won over eventually, too. A little formulaic? Sure, but it’s still good fun, and I’m always a bit sad to see a volume end. – Michelle Smith

My Big Sister Lives in a Fantasy World: Humanity’s Extinction Happens During Summer Vacation?!

by

By Tsuyoshi Fujitaka and An2A. Released in Japan as “Neechan wa Chuunibyou” by Hobby Japan. Released in North America digitally by J-Novel Club. Translated by Elizabeth Ellis.

After three volumes, I’m still not quite sure how seriously I should be taking this series. Based on the premise and what actually happens in the books, you’d think the answer would be ‘not seriously at all’. And that’s probably the right answer, given the sheer amount of ridiculous things going on here. This is a parody of a certain melancholic series, and as a result is going to be over the top. At the same time, this is also the “this was a success, please expand on the plot and backstory a bit” volume, so we start to try to understand why Mutsuko is the way she is, and why Yuichi woke up one day seeing ‘roles’ over people’s heads. It’s a worthy goal, I suppose, but does mean you get a lot of wordy exposition at the start of the book, and if you think about it too hard it doesn’t really explain much at all.

The story picks up where we left off, with the club (and younger sister, who is there just because) heading off to a remote island, where Mutsuko has planned survival training. The remote island is a bit blatant, to the point where the characters spend several pages discussing the Haruhi equivalent without actually naming it. Once they get there, after conveniently jettisoning the minor characters, they find themselves drawn into a cult conspiracy to sacrifice virgins in order to resurrect an alien who is being worshipped as a god by the local anthropomorphic villagers. Yuichi, along with Natsuki, his serial killer-turned-love interest, is sidelined from the sacrificing for the most part, which is likely a relief, as when he does arrive to confront the God, he ends up one-shot killing it. In between these events, we get Aiko worrying about her vampiric heritage, Yoriko vacillating about how incestuous she really is, and Mutsuko being both obnoxious and disturbing at the same time.

When the book is being as light and frothy as this synopsis makes it sound, it’s excellent. Yuichi’s deadpan “well, whatever” reaction to events is shared by others in the cast now, and makes the whole thing less ridiculous and overpowered than it would sound if it was written in a more grandiose manner. Much as the series is riffing on Haruhi (to the point where much of the exposition discusses the idea that certain people can influence the world so that it obeys their whims, with the implication that Mutsuko is one such person), Mutsuko and Yuichi are only superficially similar to Haruhi and Kyon. Where the book falters a bit for me is when it does try to take itself too seriously. Kanako’s discussion about why she likes isekai stories hints at a much darker take on her character than I’d expected, and given how little she matters in the books to date it feels like pure setup and nothing else. Also, if you’re going to mock the “the sacrifices have to be virgins” cliche, don’t follow through with the “the non-virgins were raped and killed” part of that. You can’t mock your cliche and eat it too. That left a bad taste in my mouth.

In the end, this is an enjoyable series of books, but I find I’m enjoying the metatext a bit more than the text. the series walks a fine line between deconstructing this sort of light novel schtick and just going along with it. So far it holds up, but it needs to realize that dropping more serious content into the middle of it may be harder than initially thought. We’ll see what happens next – judging by its subtitle, the fourth book looks to double down on the Haruhi comparisons.

Species Domain, Vol. 1

by

By Shunsuke Noro. Released in Japan by Akita Shoten, serialization ongoing in the magazine Bessatsu Shonen Champion. Released in North America by Seven Seas. Translated by Krista Shipley, Adapted by Karie Shipley.

Monster Girl titles are here to stay, and have tended to come in two varieties. Thankfully, this is the second variety, and so fanservice and borderline content is not on the menu. Instead, this is something that should appeal to fans of series like My Monster Secret or Interviews with Monster Girls, as it has much the same flavor. It can be a bit odd and off kilter, though not so much that it reaches the out there weirdness of A Centaur’s Life. Its strongest qualities is its dialogue, of which there is a lot – this is a series with a group of classmates who talk and talk and talk, and it’s a relief we find the talk funny. And there are the usual manga cliches present within – the elf girl is a misunderstood tsundere, the angel girl is overenthusiastic and puppydog-ish, the dwarf girl is low key and stoic, etc. It’s solid and unassuming.

This is not a “I must hide my secret from the world” sort of book – there are several fantasy types at the school, and it’s accepted as simply being part of how the world works. That said, Kazamori, the elf girl on the cover, is battling the fact that everyone assumes she’s an elf who can use cool wind magic and has powers – except she’s been raised by humans, so has nothing of the sort. What’s worse, she feels the need to act haughty and proud as an elf should, even though the turmoil of emotions that stir within her is a more accurate read of her character. It also leads to most of the humor in the book, particularly when she collides with Ohki, a normal boy who denies that magic exists – everything can be explained with science. Which is fine, except all of the ‘science’ he demonstrates is ludicrously impossible to anyone but him.

This is the start, but refreshingly we also do focus on the other characters. It’s hard not to look at Unli the dwarf and not think of Terry Pratchett’s Cheery, as she’s essentially a cute small schoolgirl with a full beard and a penchant for meat. I was very amused at the relationship between her and her human classmate Tanaka, which everyone interprets as romantic and then when they find out it’s really not all hell breaks loose in terms of their suppositions. The title really seems to enjoy making fun of audience expectations – there’s an omake chapter that has Kazamori dream of what would happen if she was the cool girl with elf powers she wants to be, and Ohki was the fired up “I will prove it is science” shonen lead, and it’s hilariously boring.

Like many recent licenses these days, this will not win any awards for originality or surprises, but it’s fun and likeable, the sort of manga that you read with a smile on your face, even if it sometimes turns into a bit of a smirk. The translation and adaptation are excellent as well, which is key for a series that depends so much on its conversations. A good debut, recommended for fans of the ‘monster girl’ genre or comedic school manga in general.

Manga the Week of 4/12

by , , , and 1 Comment

SEAN: Unlike Viz and Yen, Kodansha doesn’t usually pile it all on in one week. That said, hope you like Kodansha this week.

But first, J-Novel Club has a 2nd volume of Playing to Win in a VRMMO, the bulk of which is apparently a flashback to the time gap in the first book.

Kodansha continues to pump out digital-only series, both new and old Del Rey castoffs. For the former, we have the 2nd Ace of the Diamond, another Museum, and the second Tokyo Tarareba Girls. For the latter, new volumes of Gakuen Price, School Rumble, Yagyu Ninja Scrolls and the omnipresent Pumpkin Scissors.

MICHELLE: I kind of fell behind on keeping up with these, alas.

ANNA: I bought the first volume of Tokyo Tarareba Girls but haven’t read it yet, so far behind already.

ASH: I don’t know how much it really means, and I’m trying not to get my hopes up lest they be dashed, but Kodansha actually called some of these titles digital-first recently. I’d love to see more print editions!

SEAN: And there’s lots of print as well. Attack on Titan is so popular it’s not getting a Choose Your Own Adven… (cough) sorry, Choose Your Own Path Adventure, a totally not-litigious title, called Year 850: Last Stand at Wall Rose.

ASH: I’m really curious about this one; I loved gamebooks growing up. (And I have to admit, I still do.)

SEAN: Fairy Tail is up to Vol. 59, but I believe that this may be the final arc.

The Prince in His Dark Days is at Vol. 4. Are the days still dark?

MICHELLE: I believe this is the final volume, too.

SEAN: Princess Jellyfish’s 4th volume is probably the release I’m most excited about in this bunch.

MICHELLE: Me too.

ANNA: Indeed.

ASH: Still incredibly happy this series is being released!

MJ: Ack! I’m behind!

SEAN: But there’s also the debut of a new Kosuke Fujishima series. Toppu GP is the somewhat awkward title, and after combining fast bikes/cars with policewomen, goddesses and college kids, Kodansha is finally letting him actually do a racing manga. Should be fun.

MICHELLE: Huh. I suppose I should check it out.

SEAN: Seven Seas has a 5th volume of Not Lives, which I have Not Read in some time.

And a 7th volume of my “favorite” guilty pleasure (and by favorite I mean it makes me cringe so much but I read it anyway) Pandora in the Crimson Shell: Ghost Urn.

SuBLime has a 6th volume of The World’s Greatest First Love. (Spoil me, is it really that great?)

MICHELLE: No clue.

ASH: I find the series’ supposed romance much less compelling than its behind-the-scenes portrayal of the shoujo manga publishing industry.

SEAN: And Vertical gives us a 6th volume of Devil’s Line.

Lastly, there’s some more Viz. We have a 62nd volume of Case Closed. Catch up before you’re 63 volumes behind!

And a 20th Itsuwaribito, which I think may be nearing its end soon.

Magi reaches Vol. 23, and always makes me happy.

ANNA: So, so far behind on this title as well.

SEAN: And a 7th volume of Monster Hunter: Flash Hunter.

Lastly, the Revolutionary Girl Utena box set which got delayed at the last minute is now out in stores (unless Diamond shipped it to you early, like they did me). It’s the shoujo manga version of Utena, and I will leave it at that.

ASH: I actually haven’t read the series, but I have read the standalone manga The Adolescence of Utena which I loved and which is also included in this absolutely gorgeous box set.

SEAN: There’s a lot of variety this week. What appeals to you?

Flying Witch, Vol. 1

by

By Chihiro Ishizuka. Released in Japan by Kodansha, serialization ongoing in the magazine Bessatsu Shonen Magazine. Released in North America by Vertical Comics. Translated by Melissa Tanaka.

Relaxed and easygoing titles have always been a thing in Japanese manga to some extent, but over the last ten years or so it really seems to look like they’re coming into their own, or at least coming to North America more often. Whether it’s school life, village life, or workplace life, there is a growing need for watching a cast of mild to strong eccentrics go about life at their own pace, usually with at last one “straight man” to boggle at their antics. And as you may have gathered, Flying Witch continues in this genre, showing us a young witch who moves out into the sticks in order to train, and her laidback adventures with a group of (mostly) normal villagers.

Makoto is the witch, and she’s a bit of an airhead, although not to the extremes that some of these series try to go. She wants to do her best to be a better witch, but is easily distracted, has a Ryouga Hibiki-like sense of direction, and also has absolutely no idea how to hide her identity as a witch, which is supposed to be a secret, from anyone at all. She’s moved in with her cousins, and on the very first day she’s trying out a new broom in front of the youngest one, not particularly noticing that she isn’t supposed to be floating in the air. The cousin, Chinatsu, is probably my favorite character in the book; at first shy and a little reluctant to like this new girl, she gradually warms up once she realizes Makoto is a witch, and is a nicely realistic young girl.

Less successful is Kei, the main male lead, who unfortunately is not straight-laced enough to be the main “tsukkomi” that this series needs. (That falls to his classmate Nao, who holds up her end of the bargain admirably, and is the recipient of the manga’s funniest and also possibly creepiest moment.) Kei is simply too laid back and relaxed, and as a result has a tendency to have no personality. He seems to be a ‘minder’ sort, like Yotsuba’s dad, but these girls are too old to really need to take charge of, so mostly he exists so that the series isn’t made up entirely of girls. I was pleased to see that the witch aspect was not forgotten – this felt like one of those series that would settle into slice-of-life and forget its roots, but each chapter does have a small element of the supernatural in it, from the terrifying mandrake root to the Harbinger of Spring (whose matter-of-fact introduction reminded me of some of the better Zetsubou-sensei chapters) to Makoto’s older and more accomplished sister, who arrives, makes chaos, and then leaves.

There’s not much to grab a hold of here, and I doubt a “real” plot will form. But who wants a real plot to form anyway? Flying Witch is filled with cute, nice, slightly weird girls living their everyday life and doing witchcraft. If you enjoy slice-of-life eccentricity, it’s right in your strike zone.

Bookshelf Briefs 4/3/17

by and Leave a Comment

Cells at Work!, Vol. 3 | By Akane Shimizu | Kodansha Comics – Much to my surprise, Red Blood Cell takes a back seat in this volume, though she gets the entire first story to herself, in an amusing but predictable variation on “I protect her journey without her ever seeing me.” White Blood Cell is front and center, though, dealing with pranking cold germs, and a community of hair that has been beset by acne. There’s also Memory Cell, whose memory proves to be less amusing than his tendency to panic and overthink things, and Killer and Helper T Cell, who are vitriolic best buds who were once in Killer T boot camp together. The plots are the opposite of original, but the fun in Cells at Work! is seeing how the author meshes the cliches with genuine information. Great fun. – Sean Gaffney

Danganronpa: The Animation, Vol. 4 | By Spike Chunsoft and Takashi Tsukimi | Dark Horse – I’ve had issues with the rushed pacing during this entire adaptation, and it reaches a climax in this final volume, which is SO rushed it becomes almost a liability. And of course it’s compressing an anime that was already compressing a visual novel. That said, there are some striking visuals as you’d expect, particularly the revelation of the real villain and their final fate. Dark Horse hints at the end of the volume they may license more, and I’m vaguely interested, but honestly, this manga works better as an ad to get you to buy the game rather than as a story in itself. And as a vehicle for some truly wretched bear puns. – Sean Gaffney

Food Wars: Shokugeki no Soma, Vol. 17 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | VIZ Media – This is not your usual volume of Food Wars!. In fact, most of it is fairly frustrating, as the restrictive regime of Erina’s father must be established before Yukihira presumably succeeds in triumphing over it. Azami Nakiri swiftly disbands all research societies and essentially outlaws creativity, mandating that all students be allowed to cook only approved recipes decided on by an elite group. Of course Yukihira rails against this, but when Polaris dormitory is threatened, he decides to challenge corrupt Eizan from the Council of Ten, even knowing that the judges are in his pocket. Alas, the reveal of Yukihira’s cooking waits until next time. The best part of the volume is runaway Erina being welcomed by the Polaris crew, but otherwise volume seventeen provides setup for a satisfying installment without really being one itself. – Michelle Smith

He’s My Only Vampire, Vol. 10 | By Aya Shouoto | Yen Press – With this volume, He’s My Only Vampire comes to an end. The details of Kana’s true origins are not belabored, but we do get some background on the origin of the stigmas and why Eriya is the way he is. As I expected (having previously read Shouoto’s Kiss of the Rose Princess, with its somewhat baffling finale), it doesn’t entirely make sense, but it makes enough sense for a reader like me, who doesn’t care enough anymore to quibble. The final confrontation is a bit rushed, but there’s a five-years-after epilogue that caps things off decently. In the end, this was an okay series—better than Kiss of the Rose Princess but not as good as The Demon Prince of Momochi House—but not one that I am likely to reread. – Michelle Smith

The Honor Student at Magic High School, Vol. 6 | By Tsutomu Sato and Yu Mori | Yen Press – Honoka’s status as girl with a crush who frets a lot is so ingrained that I was actually very surprised at seeing her crush her competition in her event that starts the fourth volume. It’s always nice to see characters like her succeed after all their hard work. The same cannot be said for Subaru and Nanami, two minor characters whose job is to show off how good the other school’s candidates are. And Honoka may be in trouble in future events, as she seems to have given away a secret to a new friend/spy. There’s also some amusing side stories, including showing that the two girls who kidnapped Honoka and Shizuku at the start of the series are in fact dating each other. Good stuff for Mahouka fans. – Sean Gaffney

UQ Holder, Vol. 10 | By Ken Akamatsu | Kodansha Comics – Last time we saw lots of unexplained Negima references, and this time we’re going back even further, as the start of this volume is nothing more than an extended riff on Love Hina—unsurprising given they’re all running an inn with an onsen at this point, but still, you can’t help but laugh. Kirie gets more focus and depth, and reminds me that Akamatsu loved to use Chisame more than the others as well. As for Kuromaru, she’s pretty much come down on the ‘she’ end of the equation with her growing chest, but her feelings for Tota are still causing her great difficulty. Oh well, it wouldn’t be Akamatsu without harem romance not going anywhere. Coming out slower, but still for for those who like Akamatsu. – Sean Gaffney

Pick of the Week: April Goodies

by , , , and Leave a Comment

SEAN: My non-manga pick of the week is the digital re-release of Louis Sachar’s Sideways Stories from Wayside School and its two sequels, aka MY CHILDHOOD TOUCHSTONE. But since it’s actually a manga site, I will pick the new volume of Assassination Classroom, aka “the one everyone has been waiting for”. I really love this series.

MICHELLE: I am all about the prose books, too, especially digital re-releases of favorites. But, yes, manga. This week I’m going with the debut volume of The Water Dragon’s Bride by Rei Toma, whose Dawn of the Arcana I enjoyed very much.

KATE: If I had to choose a title — and death was not an option — I’d vote for I Am a Hero. It’s a zombie manga for grown-ups, with adult characters, intense action sequences, and a protagonist who may or may not be going insane. If you’re a Walking Dead fan (comic or TV show), this might be in your wheelhouse.

ANNA: No surprise, I am torn between two great shoujo fantasy titles for my pick of the week. The Water Dragon’s Bride has an extremely strong first volume and the darker themes in the story really set it apart from typical shoujo fare. On the other hand, there’s the fifth volume of Yona of the Dawn, which is also an excellent fantasy series. I think the bickering, archery, and action puts Yona over the top for me, so that is my pick.

ASH: Oh, there are quite a few things that I’m interested in this week, so it’s hard to narrow it down to just one pick! Since it looks like the rest of the Manga Bookshelf crew has all the great shoujo fantasy well-represented, I’ll take this opportunity to mention Haikyu!! since it hasn’t been yet. I’m not especially interested in volleyball, but I’m enjoying the series’ positivity and energy immensely, and the characters are great, too.