• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Comment Policy
    • Disclosures & Disclaimers
  • Resources
    • Links, Essays & Articles
    • Fandomology!
    • CLAMP Directory
    • BlogRoll
  • Features & Columns
    • 3 Things Thursday
    • Adventures in the Key of Shoujo
    • Bit & Blips (game reviews)
    • BL BOOKRACK
    • Bookshelf Briefs
    • Bringing the Drama
    • Comic Conversion
    • Fanservice Friday
    • Going Digital
    • It Came From the Sinosphere
    • License This!
    • Magazine no Mori
    • My Week in Manga
    • OFF THE SHELF
    • Not By Manga Alone
    • PICK OF THE WEEK
    • Subtitles & Sensibility
    • Weekly Shonen Jump Recaps
  • Manga Moveable Feast
    • MMF Full Archive
    • Yun Kouga
    • CLAMP
    • Shojo Beat
    • Osamu Tezuka
    • Sailor Moon
    • Fruits Basket
    • Takehiko Inoue
    • Wild Adapter
    • One Piece
    • After School Nightmare
    • Karakuri Odette
    • Paradise Kiss
    • The Color Trilogy
    • To Terra…
    • Sexy Voice & Robo
  • Browse by Author
    • Sean Gaffney
    • Anna Neatrour
    • Michelle Smith
    • Katherine Dacey
    • MJ
    • Brigid Alverson
    • Travis Anderson
    • Phillip Anthony
    • Derek Bown
    • Jaci Dahlvang
    • Angela Eastman
    • Erica Friedman
    • Sara K.
    • Megan Purdy
    • Emily Snodgrass
    • Nancy Thistlethwaite
    • Eva Volin
    • David Welsh
  • MB Blogs
    • A Case Suitable For Treatment
    • Experiments in Manga
    • MangaBlog
    • The Manga Critic
    • Manga Report
    • Soliloquy in Blue
    • Manga Curmudgeon (archive)

Manga Bookshelf

Discussion, Resources, Roundtables, & Reviews

Features & Reviews

A Surprisingly Happy Engagement for the Slime Duke and the Fallen Noble Lady, Vol. 3

November 14, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Mashimesa Emoto and Kasumi Nagi. Released in Japan as “Slime Taikō to Botsuraku Reijō no Angai Shiawase na Konyaku” by HJ Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Minna Lin.

I get the feeling there’s another story that we’re missing here, especially towards the end. I remember when I was reading Accomplishments of the Duke’s Daughter and we took two books to learn about her mother’s backstory. Maybe we need that sort of thing here, because all of a sudden Slime Duke is feeling like a sequel series to the main one that starred Adele, a villainess who was shunned by her fiancee and moved to another kingdom, only for the Emperor’s son to fall in love with her. Then we get this series, which is about what happened to the main character’s younger sister, who was always worried about but never actually seen in the main series. Now, as far as I know that’s not what actually happened, I think this is indeed the main series. But it also possibly explains why I’ve found this series a bit mid-tier when it comes to Japanese romances, especially Japanese romances with slimes. Best duck romance, though.

It’s time for Gabriel and Francette’s wedding, and we spend the entire book getting there. There are two main worries. First, they want her wedding dress to have fancy pearls, and unfortunately the country that gave everyone fancy pearls is having a shortage due to the royal relatives being toxic jerks. So the two of them decide to try and make their own pearls in Gabriel’s land… but this proves easier said than done. Secondly, Francette’s mother and sister will be coming to the wedding, and she’s very worried about finally seeing them, especially since she really did not tell them “by the way, I’m now living in poverty in a slum”, which is where she was at the start of the series. Fortunately, their reunion works out. Unfortunately, we then get a wacky sibling switch leading to a less wacky kidnapping.

I’m used to dealing with heroines with a sense of self-esteem so low it’s on the floor, but this is a rare series where the entire family suffers from this problem. Everyone is very quick to credit everyone else for all the solutions to life’s problems. That said, those crediting Francette are more right than others, as she really pulls off a lot here. That said, the solution on how to make the pearls is one that I was expecting to be the FIRST thing they tried, so it felt a bit underwhelming to come up with it after exhausting everything else. Second, we get a second absentee dad, though at least the series tries to explain how it’s walking a fine line between “they should be allowed to love life the way they want” and “that doesn’t mean they’re forgiven”. And, as noted, I want to read Adele’s story. And Emilia’s, to be honest. Probably more than Francette’s.

This is the final volume, so well done. At least we’ll always have the attack duck.

Filed Under: a surprisingly happy engagement for the slime duke and the fallen noble lady, REVIEWS

Manga the Week of 11/20/24

November 14, 2024 by Sean Gaffney, Michelle Smith, Ash Brown and Anna N Leave a Comment

SEAN: November continues to be Almost Christmas.

ASH: So close and yet so far away.

SEAN: Airship has a print bonanza, as we see The Case Files of Jeweler Richard 9, The Condemned Villainess Goes Back in Time and Aims to Become the Ultimate Villain 3, Loner Life in Another World 10, Survival in Another World with My Mistress! 7, and Too Many Losing Heroines! 2.

ASH: Always love a plethora of print.

SEAN: And the early digital releases are Reincarnated Into a Game as the Hero’s Friend: Running the Kingdom Behind the Scenes 3 and The Weakest Tamer Began a Journey to Pick Up Trash 8.

I missed this last week, so already out is The Complete Poe Clan: The ’70s from Fantagraphics, a repackaging of the two hardcover releases in a nice box. Highly recommended for any student of manga.

ASH: Oh! I had missed that, too! I love that this series is available in English.

ANNA: Ooh, I think I got the first volume but not the second.

SEAN: Ghost Ship gives us 2.5 Dimensional Seduction 12 and Ero Ninja Scrolls 7

For mature Seven Seas titles, there’s a debut, The Second Alpha (2ban-me no Alpha), a BL title from Be x Boy Omegaverse. (Should I classify Omegaverse as BL, or is it a separate genre by now?) A man finds his destined omega, and they have sex after said omega goes into heat. Unfortunately, said omega is also married?

ASH: It’s definitely its own sub-genre at the very least.

SEAN: We also see Remnants of Filth: Yuwu 5.

J-Novel Club has 3 print titles: Hell Mode: The Hardcore Gamer Dominates in Another World with Garbage Balancing 6, My Instant Death Ability Is So Overpowered, No One in This Other World Stands a Chance Against Me! 6, and Reborn to Master the Blade: From Hero-King to Extraordinary Squire 4.

Debuting digitally from J-Novel Club is Dimension Wave, from the creator of Shield Hero but apparently far less emo. A young man’s sisters win a ticket to the debut of a popular VRMMO, and give one to him. But he’s been tricked – his character is a girl! Oh well – it’s time to fish and enjoy the slow life.

J-Novel Club also gives us Butareba -The Story of a Man Turned into a Pig 5, Dagashi-ya Yahagi: Setting Up a Sweets Shop in Another World 2, From Desk Job to Death Beam: In Another World with My Almighty Lasers 2, From Two-Bit Baddie to Total Heartthrob: This Villainess Will Cross-Dress to Impress! 2, Haibara’s Teenage New Game+ 7, I’m a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic 4, Peddler in Another World: I Can Go Back to My World Whenever I Want! 9, the 3rd The Reincarnation of the Strongest Exorcist in Another World manga volume, and Zilbagias the Demon Prince: How the Seventh Prince Brought Down the Kingdom 3.

ASH: That’s a decent amount.

SEAN: Kaiten Books has a digital volume, Loner Life in Another World 11.

No debuts for Kodansha. In print, we see Grand Blue Dreaming 20, Suzume 2, To Your Eternity 21, and Vampire Dormitory 12.

ASH: I’ve been collecting To Your Eternity but need to make the point to actually catch up on reading it.

SEAN: Digitally we see And Yet, You Are So Sweet 10, Hozuki’s Coolheadedness 23, Lightning and Romance 6, Parasyte Reversi 2, and You’re My Cutie 9.

From One Peace Books we see Parallel World Pharmacy 6.

Seven Seas debuts a manhua based on a danmei novel, but for once it doesn’t seem to be supernatural. I Ship My Rival x Me stars two actors who find that A03 is doing some RL shipping of them! (OK, it’s probably not explicitly AO3.) Are the shippers onto something?

ASH: Could be!

SEAN: We also see Yes, No, or Maybe? (Yes ka No ka Hanbun ka), the manga adaptation of the BL light novel also released by Seven Seas. It runs in Dear+.

ASH: I feel like I read that one; did I read that one?

SEAN: Also from Seven Seas: Citrus+ 6, Gravitation: Collector’s Edition 3, The Ideal Sponger Life 17, The Lady and Her Butler 2, Re-Living My Life with a Boyfriend Who Doesn’t Remember Me 2, and Reborn as a Barrier Master 7.

Square Enix debuts Dragon and Chameleon (Ryuu to Cameleon), a Gangan Joker title. A veteran manga artist ends up switching bodies with a bitter, untalented rookie. Now he’s got to work his way back up to the summit.

ASH: Hate when that happens.

ANNA: It sounds complicated!

SEAN: Also from Square Enix: Just Like Mona Lisa 3 and The Villainess’s Guide to (Not) Falling in Love 3.

Steamship has a 2nd volume of Alpha Wolfgirl x Omega Wolfboy.

Tokyopop debuts a villainess light novel that spawned the manga they’ve already been releasing, Her Royal Highness Seems to Be Angry (Oujo Denka wa Oikari no You desu). A talented young woman, after losing her family to war, takes her own life… and wakes up a thousand years later in the body of a pathetic villainess type who’s being cheated on. What’s worse, the magic 1000 years later is TERRIBLE.

There’s also an award-winning one shot, A Smart and Courageous Child (Kashikokute Yuuki Aru Kodomo), which ran in Torch. A young couple are happily awaiting their child, when suddenly, days from birth, the mother hears about the assassination attempt of Malala Yousafzai and goes into shock. Can her husband be there for her? This is an experimental manga with rave reviews.

ASH: A well-received experimental manga, you say?

ANNA: Alright!

SEAN: This Reincarnated Countess Is Trying to Escape From Her Prince (Tensei Hakushaku Reijo wa Oji-sama kara Nigedashitai) is a manga based on an as yet unlicensed light novel. A princess awakens to her past Japanese memories, and realizes she’s got a horribly tragic and awful life ahead if she marries the prince. Solution: Don’t marry the prince. HOWEVER…

They’ve also got Let’s Eat Together, Aki and Haru 2.

Debuting from Udon is Ottoman: Henshin Hero Husband, a Weekly Young Jump title. A salaryman is infected by an alien… but that’s OK, as his wife is in danger from the forces of evil! He and the alien will have to join forces to win.

Udon also has My Stepmom’s Daughter Is My Ex 2.

Viz Media debuts After God, an Ura Sunday title about a young woman who gets caught up in the God-Killing Institute’s machinations. (Note: Gods are evil aliens here, think Titans and the like.)

ASH: I’m curious about this one. That cover is very striking.

SEAN: Also from Viz: Asadora! 8, Battle Royale: Enforcers 2, Gokurakugai 3, Hirayasumi 3, Mobile Suit Gundam Thunderbolt 22, Trillion Game 2, and Twin Star Exorcists 32.

Two debuts from Yen On. Festival of Heresies is a book that I can find almost no information about. It’s a one-shot, but is also the first in the “Sasaki Agency” series. It seems to be horror. A young woman can’t tell the living from the dead, and thus has trouble keeping a job. Her worried brother turns to a mysterious agency…

ASH: Speaking of striking covers; I could pretty easily be convinced to read this.

SEAN: In a World of Lies, I Fell into an Unforgettable Love (which I also can find little about) is from the author of Even If This Love Disappears Tonight. It’s one of those “I’m dying, so let me have one last bittersweet teenage love” stories.

Also from Yen On: Classroom for Heroes 3, The Contract Between a Specter and a Servant 3, Days with My Stepsister 4, I’ve Been Killing Slimes for 300 Years and Maxed Out My Level 15, Ishura 8, Liar Liar 5, Sugar Apple Fairy Tale 7, The Trials of Chiyodaku 2, The Unimplemented Overlords Have Joined the Party! 3, and You Are My Regret 3.

And Yen Press has a pile. Agents of the Four Seasons: Dance of Spring (Shunkashuutou Daikousha – Haru no Mai) is the manga adaptation of the light novel already released by Yen. It runs in LaLa.

MICHELLE: This is the first thing on the list that really made me perk up my ears.

ANNA: Agreed!

SEAN: All or Nothing (Ichika, Bachika) is a one-shot BL title from B’s-LOVEY. Two boys come out and reveal they’re now a couple. And now the other two boys in their friend group are looking at each other and going “hrm”.

Brunhild the Dragonslayer (Ryuugoroshi no Brunhild) is the manga adaptation of the light novel already released by Yen. It runs in Shonen Ace.

Candy: Shou Harusono Art Collection is an artbook from the Sasaki and Miyano creator.

Dracula’s on the Night Shift (Dracula Yakin!) is a one-shot manga that ran in my nemesis, Comic Alive. A vampire who works the graveyard shift at a convenience store comes across a blonde vampire hunter… and now they’re living together?

ANNA: What would happen if Sean’s nemesis Comic Alive was a person, and then they were living together?????

SEAN: …please do not ship me with Comic Alive. This is not Hark! A Vagrant.

mono is a manga from the creator of Laid-Back Camp, and it runs in Manga Time Kirara Carat. Two clubs in danger of shutting down join into one club, and go around taking exciting photographs.

Oshi No Ko also gets an artbook, 1st Illustration Collection: Glare x Sparkle.

Praise Me When I’m a Good Boy (Ii Ko ni Dekitara Hometekure) is a one-shot BL manga from B’s-Lovey Recottia. A submissive teacher whose fiancee just left him tries a dating app, and finds his male dom… is a former student?

The Teen Exorcist (Shounen Onmyouji) is based on an as-yet-unlicensed light novel, and runs in Young Ace. It’s ancient Japan, and our hero, the grandson of Abe no Seimei, wants to surpass him!

The War of Greedy Witches: 32 of the Wickedest Women Duel to the Death (Majo Taisen: 32-nin no Isai no Majo wa Koroshiau) is from the creator of Kakegurui, and runs in Comic Zenon. Do you want a death game tournament battle featuring hot evil women? Starring Jeanne D’Arc? Great news.

Also from Yen: The Abandoned Empress 9 (the final volume), Apocalypse Bringer Mynoghra 2, Associate Professor Akira Takatsuki’s Conjecture 5, Bungo Stray Dogs: The Official Comic Anthology 2, Cheeky Brat 12, Cross-Dressing Villainess Cecilia Sylvie 6, Game of Familia 5, I Cannot Reach You 8, I Want a Gal Gamer to Praise Me 3, I’m Quitting Heroing 7, I’m the Villainess, So I’m Taming the Final Boss 4, In the Land of Leadale 6, K-ON! Shuffle 2, Oshi no Ko 8, What’s Wrong with Secretary Kim? 6 (the final volume), and Why Raeliana Ended Up at the Duke’s Mansion 8.

ASH: Is it a Yen week? It doesn’t seem to be enough for a Yen week.

SEAN: It’s a lot! Are you drowning? Did you bother to read to the end?

Filed Under: FEATURES, manga the week of

To Another World… with Land Mines!, Vol. 1

November 13, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Itsuki Mizuho and Nekobyou Neko. Released in Japan as “Isekai Teni, Jirai Tsuki” by Dragon Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Yen-Po Tseng.

Yeah, I know. So I had a brief gap in my insane reading schedule, and a friend had mentioned this series as one I might be interested in circling back to. I had skipped it in 2022 when it came out as I was trying to cut down on isekai stuff. But I’m a big fan of Management of a Novice Alchemist, by the same author, so I figured why not give it a try. And how is it? Well, that’s an interesting question. I think how you feel about it will depend on your answer to the following: Can something be good and yet very boring? If you say no, by definition boring things are bad, then don’t read this series, please move on to something with lots of cool things happening. If your answer is yes, it can be good, it depends on what the author is trying to do and the nature of what is boring, then I think, like me, you’ll get something out of this.

Another reason that I never read this when it first came out in 2022 is that I thought it was gonna be about someone whose skill is explosive mines, kinda like the godawful Death Beam story. It’s not. The land mines are metaphorical. A bus full of students apparently is in a fatal accident (we only hear about this secondhand) and are now meeting with a self-titled “evil god”, who wants to put them all in another world, no reincarnation necessary, and offers then some cool skills. Nao, our POV character, selects the ‘help’ skill in order to help him choose better… and discovers that some of the cooler sounding skills have lethal consequences! Those aren’t cool skills, they’re land mines! (Hence the title). Now he and his best friends Haruka and Touya are in this new world, and are finding that it’s not quite like the light novels said it was.

So this is sort of a combination of “isekais should be more realistic, let everyone grubbily struggle to survive” books with “if *I* was in an isekai I wouldn’t do all those dumb things that make interesting stories, I’d be smart and rational”. You’d expect that at least one of our main protagonists would be a loose cannon to justify the title, but no, we have smart, sensible Haruka, nebbish generiguy Nao, and hotblooded Touya, and even Touya listens to Haruka and does what she says. They don’t get any weapons, and their magic (Haruka and Nao are elves, Touya is a beastman) is either basic or nonexistent, and needs to be learned. They gather. They experiment. It’s interesting as a thought experiment, and I want to see what happens next, but as a book it struggles. Nao is especially weak right now, and I hope he gains character development.

So if you skipped this when it came out, you can probably keep skipping it. But I enjoyed it enough to want to read another one when my schedule is free again.

Filed Under: REVIEWS, to another world with land mines

Bookshelf Briefs 11/12/24

November 12, 2024 by Sean Gaffney and Michelle Smith Leave a Comment

Blue Box, Vol. 12 | By Kouji Miura | Viz Media – Of course, I was right. This is the confession volume. But that’s not really a spoiler, because the nature of this book—it’s still half sports, in case anyone has forgotten—is not going to allow it to wrap up here. Indeed, the nature of both their lives and their current living situation means they actually have to hide their budding relationship. Still, just because we know that further complications and torment will be coming along does not mean that we cannot revel in this sweet and earned confession, which ends up being even sooner than either had anticipated thanks to the sort of coincidence that always happens in manga. They’re really good kids, and I’m glad they’re together. Now, let’s have basketball and badminton angst. – Sean Gaffney

The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn’t a Guy at All, Vol. 1 | By Sumiko Arai | Yen Press – The sheer amount of buzz this title got was ridiculous—possibly the most I’ve ever seen for a yuri series—and I am delighted to say that it absolutely lives up to the hype. A trendy high school girl has a crush on the guy who works at her favorite used CD store, who shares her taste in 1990s American rock. What she doesn’t know is that this “guy” is the nerdy girl who sits next to her in class! It’s amazing what a face mask and hoodie can do. Some series play up the handsomeness or beauty of a character and the art never quite captures it. That’s not the case here—Mitsuki is absolutely 100% hot, and you immediately see why Aya falls for her. Add to this the green color scheme, which makes the art pop, and you have a total winner. – Sean Gaffney

Monthly Girls’ Nozaki-kun, Vol. 15 | By Sorata Akiduki | Yen Press – Given the type of series we are in, it’s not a big surprise that Ryousuke and Miyako are unsure whether they’re dating, even after a confession. As you can imagine, it takes a lot of wacky gags for them to actually get to the “we *are* dating” point. As for the other couples, situation much the same. Seo and Wakamatsu are sorta kinda there, Hori and Kashima have to deal with an accidental first kiss but can’t help but turn every single event of their lives into theater improv, and Sakura… well, Sakura knows that any resolution for her and Nozaki is going to have to wait till the final chapter of the manga, and at the moment the manga doesn’t show a sign of coming to a close. So Sakura is the same Nozaki-centric stalker we know and love. Worth the wait. – Sean Gaffney

My Hero Academia, Vol. 39 | By Kohei Horikoshi | Viz Media – I have made no secret of the fact that I ship Izuku and Ochako. That said, I’m not militant about it, and this volume isn’t for that pairing, despite Ochako literally saying she loves Izuku out loud. No, this is for the Togachako shippers, and oh my God, what a way to go out. Toxic yuri becomes redemptive but still ultimately doomed yuri, it’s as if he read the minds of all the fans as to their favorite AO3 tags. Oh yes, and in case you don’t care about those three, there’s also the Todorokis, who have their own little doomed but redemptive thing going on, as everyone kills themselves (almost literally) trying to apologize at Dabi harder. So much going on it’s hard to remember that we also get All Might’s powered suit, with its attacks based on 1-A hero names. Fantastic. – Sean Gaffney

Otaku Vampire’s Love Bite, Vol. 1 | By Julietta Suzuki | Viz Media – It took a while for me to warm up to this one, as it very much leans hard on the otaku side of the equation at first. This despite the heroine being named “Hina Alucard.” Ironically, whereas a lot of these supernatural series find an innocent human unaware her friend is involved with the supernatural, here Hina is already a vampire, she just doesn’t know that her new best fan friend/possible love interest is already being loved by other vampires and the like. That changes in one scene where one mook tries to kill her off, not realizing that she’s not just ANY vampire. When she points to her feet and says “Now kneel,” I went OK, we’re back, everyone. Definitely want to read more of this, which seems to be very fluffy, as fits its author—with a sharp edge, as fits its author. – Sean Gaffney

Pink & Habanero, Vol. 1 | By Mika Satonaka | Yen Press – Although the premise of this series didn’t immediately grab me, I will pretty much give anything published in Margaret a chance. And it’s true that Pink & Habanero is largely paint-by-numbers shoujo. Mugi Miyao has just started high school and would like a boyfriend. She discovers that the prickly hottie in her class, Kei Kosuke, has a part-time job at a knight café, and subsequently proves to him that she’s a good person by not even considering divulging his secret, leading him to defend her from creeps (twice) and help her make a friend when she’s been struggling to do so. While much of this first volume was predictable, I liked their dynamic, especially that Mugi continues to be forthright in her communication with Kei, heading off tiresome plots built on misunderstandings. I will be back for volume two! – Michelle Smith

Tales of Wedding Rings, Vol. 14 | By Maybe | Yen Press – So much for the victory lap. Well, not true. Nefritis’ first time went swimmingly, and Hime ended up coming along for moral support/extra sexiness. Saphir just isn’t into Satou in that way, so doesn’t care. And Amber is also mostly in the “whatever” category. That leaves Granart, and she is finding that getting across to Satou that she wants the same sexual relationship that he has with Hime and Nefritis is going very badly. She’s simply too aggressive, and attempts to try a softer, more subtle attempt at his heart also fail miserably, leading to her running away in despair. Satou is still not really getting the “harem” part of this harem, to be honest, though I do appreciate that there are wives who are just in it for the politics. That said… in the end, Granart gets what she wants. Ecchi fun. – Sean Gaffney

Tamon’s B-Side, Vol. 5 | By Yuki Shiwasu | Viz Media – Last time I said this wouldn’t get an anime, and whoops! They’ve announced one for next year. This possibly explains why we come close to ending the series with this volume but back away, ending up resetting things after a confession that almost, kinda, but not quite gets through to our heroine who for once isn’t dense about it—she doesn’t WANT to “get it” as it will interfere with the roles she has in her head. That said, if there is an anime the best part will be the comedy and not the romance, as this is still hysterical. At one point Utage gets so excited she jumps THROUGH the ceiling, and in the next panel we see Tamon sponging the blood off her head. Given that Nozaki-kun is not a shoujo book despite appearances, this may be the funniest shoujo running right now. – Sean Gaffney

This Monster Wants to Eat Me, Vol. 2 | By Sai Naekawa | Yen Press – I kinda guessed that there would be more to Miko than it seemed, what with her mysterious absences from school all the time and her possessiveness towards Hinako, but I wasn’t quite sure what sort of monster she would turn out to be. That ends up being the big reveal of the second volume—not that she’s supernatural, but what type. As you can imagine, when you have two very possessive monster girls fighting over the one they love, sparks are going to fly. I do appreciate, though, that the series never gets away from its core premise, which is that Hinako has a lot of suicidal thoughts, and those don’t magically go away when she meets Shiori any more than they do when she met Miko. This is still compelling, and is apparently getting an anime soon. – Sean Gaffney

The Troublesome Guest of Sotomura Detective Agency | By Sakae Kusama | TOKYOPOP – It’s been a long time since I’ve enjoyed a BL one-shot as much as I enjoyed this one. (It took me about halfway through to remember I’d read something else by Sakae Kusama long ago.) Serious and high-strung Kei Matsuda runs a detective agency and when a case brings him back in contact with high school acquaintance and serial freeloader Ryouji Kamiko, the two embark upon a physical relationship that gradually becomes something more. The romance angle is certainly good, but I loved that the cases Matsuda and Kamiko investigate receive even more page time than the steamy scenes and are genuinely interesting. This is one of those times where part of me wishes there were just plain more of a story, even as I concede that the ending here is wholly satisfying. Heartily recommended. – Michelle Smith

Filed Under: Bookshelf Briefs

A Tale of the Secret Saint, Vol. 7

November 12, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Touya and chibi. Released in Japan as “Tensei Sita Daiseijyo ha, Seijyo Dearuko Towohitakakusu” by Earth Star Novels. Released in North America by Airship. Translated by Kevin Ishizaka. Adapted by Michelle McGuinness.

Sometimes I enjoy a good bit even if it’s obvious. Indeed, sometimes I love it because it’s obvious. And Secret Saint is, let’s face it, a series that runs on comedy, tragic backstories aside. So I have to inform you that I was smiling gleefully all through the main plot of this series, which was a perfect combination of Fia being intuitive and clever based partly on her instinct and partly on her past knowledge, and Fia being a complete dimbulb who has no idea how the world of 300 years later works and doesn’t bother to find out. There’s also an extended scene between the captains which basically serves as an excuse for Desmond to scream for 65 pages or so at the top of his lungs. That said, by the end of the book I had noticed that, despite having supposedly been the start of a brand new arc to move the story forward, not a hell of a lot happened and there were side stories galore.

Fia returns from her extended vacation to find that all the other new knights have met with the King, which is something that happens with all the first-year knights. Fia, having been absent, now has to have her turn. The king, Laurence Nav, looks about as you’d expect. What is perhaps unexpected is that he has THREE court jesters, all of whom take the opportunity to pour scorn on and belittle Fia. Ah ha! This must be one of those tests! It is indeed, and as you’d expect Fia breaks it wide open. After this, the captains all have a meeting to discuss the strange and terrifying events of the last few books – all of which deal with Fia. And then Fia is asked to meet with the current Great Saint, who is supposed to be marrying the king. That should go well. After all, Fia is a knight, not a saint.

So, apologies for giving away the obvious gimmick of this book, one of the jesters is the real king, and the other two are his closest advisors. Fia figures this out due to a combination of 300-year-old knowledge and her magical saint powers, but it’s the way she carries it off that makes this so fun to read. She’s forced to play a poker game that’s really an excuse for the king to wave his secret identity in front of the knights’ faces without giving it away, so is rather upset when Fia, in fact, figures it out and wins in her own way. I really enjoy this sort of Fia, and hope we see more of her in the next book, which I suspect may get a bit Villainess-ey. I admit I’m not as fond of Fia not realizing that her powerful dragon familiar disguising himself as a chibi-version does not really count as a disguise, or once again not understanding that things are very, very different 300 years later. But you can’t have one without the other, really.

I’m not sure when we’ll get Book 8, but I won’t have to wait long to read more about Fia. Or rather, about Serafina. Tales of the Secret Saint’s getting a prequel series, and it’s out soon. Till then, this was fun.

Filed Under: a tale of the secret saint, REVIEWS

The Otome Heroine’s Fight for Survival, Vol. 3

November 10, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Harunori Biyori and Hitaki Yuu. Released in Japan as “Otome Game no Heroine de Saikyō Survival” by TO Books. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Camilla L.

Much as this series seems most of the time to be ignoring the whole otome heroine part of the title in favor of the fight for survival, it never quite forgets about it altogether. There’s always one or two scenes reminding us that not only is Alia supposed to be the “heroine” of this otome game (and has memories that are not hers of life in Japan), but there’s also another minor villainess who is reincarnated – and is terrified of Alia, to the point where its thrown her relationship with the “main” villainess, Elena, off. That said, the next volume of the series would appear to delve more deeply into that plotline, so rest assured it will be relevant soon. But not yet. For this volume is all about Alia’s ability to fight and fight and fight some more, and the various ways she wins against all sorts of enemies and monsters that should be too much for her to handle.

Alia has gotten a bit of a reputation, as we first see her here taking out a team of slavers who’ve been working together for ten years, and she is now known as The Ashen Princess, Lady Cinders. She’s also returning to the city where the first book happened, and running into the same cast, who inform her that there’s an Orc General, 4 Orc Soldiers, and about 50 Orcs who have infiltrated an abandoned village, and they’re on the verge of invading inhabited human cities. It’s time for Alia to do something ludicrous, like take them all on. After this, she’s met by Viro, who has a job offer that she really can’t refuse: kill Graves. Unfortunately, not only has Graves also been training really hard and leveling up since he last tried to kill her, but he’s also brought in a killer panther monster.

The author says that this book is about strength, and that’s certainly true. Alia may not be as strong as the enemies that she’s facing, but to us, the reader, she ludicrously strong – as she is to the residents of that city, as the old blacksmith who gave her her first knife stares in awe at what she’s been doing to wear it out. The author also says this is about “why people and monsters fight”. Alia is very surprised, at the end of the battle between her and the Orc General, when he speaks to her, asking her name and asking why she’s doing this. In that case she has to, as otherwise the human settlement would be destroyed. But later, with the panther monster, she’s more ready to communicate and compromise, and while that doesn’t help with her actual mission – alas, the main villain lives to fight another day – it gets her a friend and familiar. Who is also a killer monster. Even if it sleeps in a cardboard box.

Still full of stats, still full of fights, still strangely compelling. Will definitely read more.

Filed Under: otome heroine's fight for survival, REVIEWS

From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman: My Hotshot Disciples Are All Grown Up Now, and They Won’t Leave Me Alone, Vol. 4

November 8, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Shigeru Sagazaki and Tetsuhiro Nabeshima. Released in Japan as “Katainaka no Ossan, Kensei ni Naru: Tada no Inaka no Kenjutsu Shihan Datta noni, Taisei Shita Deshitachi ga Ore o Hōttekurenai Ken” by SQEX Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Hikoki.

What is the audience for this series? Honestly, it’s primarily “people who just like to read light novels”, followed by “people who are curious if the series will ever end with him choosing a girl or will it go poly’. That said, I wonder if there are actually any kendo practitioners who might be reading this, because a lot of this 4th volume seems to be written to those students, telling them not to forget the basics. Well, and also reminding muscleheads trying to teach newcomers that “do everything I did without knowing the reason behind it” is a great way to be a terrible teacher. But just maybe the audience for this series is guys who are Beryl’s age who just like to fantasize about still being able to do all the cool athletic things they could do when they were young. Because once again, Beryl is awesome.

After the events of the last book, Beryl is once again left with some free time, and so Lucy asks him to drop by the magic academy to look at the sword magic course taught by his old student Ficelle. Unfortunately, she’s apparently not the best teacher, so Beryl is asked to come by to see if he can help. Since Mewi is also in this class, Beryl agrees, and finds that Ficelle’s teaching is far to spartan and hardcore. Trying to teach the five kids in the class a little less evilly, while offering advice and words of praise, Beryl not only earns the love of the students but also reminds Ficelle of what she was like when she was a student herself. Unfortunately, not all the faculty is happy to see Beryl, and he’s warned to NEVER GO IN THE BASEMENT. Take a wild guess what the climax of the book is.

I have to admit, this is a lot more meandering than the previous books. You get the sense the author realized that Ficelle is the only former student who they never really circled round and gave more depth, so they wrote a book to fix that. Unfortunately, Ficelle is not only a meathead but a stoic meathead, so it can sometimes be hard to get the character development she desperately needs. The best moment was probably the pat on the head. There’s also a group of students who have “spinoff volume” written all over them, especially the ludicrously genki Cindy, who reeks of the protagonist of some other series. The big dramatic climax of the book is not that great, as it barely gets any setup besides that one annoying teacher. I was, I admit, amused by Beryl achieving the impossible without actually knowing it. Someone needs to get him together with the star of Der Werwolf and have them self-deprecate rap battle.

The next volume’s cover suggests it will be for Yotsuba fans… erm, Curuni, I guess that’s her name. And not Yotsuba from Quintuplets. (looks at Vol. 5 cover art) Christ, even the ribbon is the same, only blue. In any case, if you like swordfighting, old men, and no romantic resolution, you’d like this.

Filed Under: from old country bumpkin to master swordsman, REVIEWS

The Oblivious Saint Can’t Contain Her Power: Forget My Sister! Turns Out I Was the Real Saint All Along!, Vol. 4

November 7, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Almond and Yoshiro Ambe. Released in Japan as “Mujikaku Seijo wa Kyō mo Muishiki ni Chikara o Tare Nagasu: Imadai no Seijo wa Anede wa Naku, Imōto no Watashi Datta Mitai Desu” by Earth Star Luna. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Dawson Chen.

Every volume of this series has me being fairly ambivalent about it, so it feels very appropriate that, when I read the afterword to this 4th and final volume, my first thought was “yeah, you should have gone with your initial instinct, it would have felt far more real and in character”. But I suppose it wouldn’t be Oblivious Saint if it wasn’t hitting all the really obvious beats. And thus Flora, who is really fascinating in the first part of the book as we see her literally consume herself with desperate rage to the point and death, ends up suddenly realizing how horrible she’s been her whole life after realizing how much Carolina looks like their late mother. It’s a head-tilting swerve, and is 100% unironic and, if I’m being honest, 100% out of character. But I guess the author’s right. Ending dark would subvert the very basic story being told.

It’s time for the big Saint Competition final, and there are twenty-three candidates competing. That said, the only ones the reader has to worry about are Carolina and Flora. Carolina is told to stop holding back, and she certainly does so, wiping the floor with everyone else. Meanwhile, Flora is also doing very well, but it’s clearly killing her – literally. She ends up having to have her life saved by her sister, the ultimate humiliation. Anyway, in a plot point so obvious I’m not worried about spoiling, Carolina wins and is now the Saint of all, with full approval of the church. Hell, she even grows SIX angel wings when she goes all out to heal Flora. Now she has only two things to worry about: going back to her birthplace for a festival, and trying to actually consummate her marriage.

I had anticipated that Ed and Carolina’s lack of a sex life would end up being a plot point, and I was mostly wrong – there’s no “you aren’t really married, ha ha!” twist, and Gilbert’s obvious love for Carolina is dealt with (surprise) in a very straightforward and earnest way. That said, the best part of the book is Ed confessing his worries to Teodore – that he is so aflame with passion that he will only end up hurting his new bride with his fiery, violent lovemaking. To which Teodore, rightly, calls Ed a massive coward and says that all his worries are complete and total bullshit. Teodore’s sarcastic, biting remarks have been a high point of each book, so I was pleased to see him point out that Carolina has obviously also been wanting to have sex with him and, if Ed keeps this up, may simply think he doesn’t love her like that at all. Rest assured, by the end of the book they have done the deed, and Carolina is fine – in fact, she worries he was so gentle HE wasn’t satisfied.

In the end, this was a bit too on-the-nose for me, and I sort of wish Flora got the unhappy ending she longed for. There are better saint books.

Filed Under: oblivious saint can't contain her power, REVIEWS

Manga the Week of 11/13/24

November 7, 2024 by Sean Gaffney, Michelle Smith, Anna N and Ash Brown Leave a Comment

SEAN: So. Manga.

The debut from Viz Media is Wanted! Eiichiro Oda Before One Piece. It is what it sounds like, a collection of stories Oda wrote before One Piece, including the series’ ‘pilot’.

ASH: Interesting!

They’ve also got a re-release of X-Men: The Manga, the classic late 90s Marvel manga adaptation that is now available in a big 500-page volume to start with.

ANNA: Alright!

SEAN: Also from Viz: Fly Me to the Moon 26, Hayate the Combat Butler 44, Helck 12 (the final volume), I Want to End This Love Game 4, I’m the Grim Reaper 2, One Piece 107, Radiant 18, Sakura, Saku 5, and Seraph of the End 31.

Two debuts for Tokyopop. I Was Reincarnated as the Heroine on the Verge of a Bad Ending, and I’m Determined to Fall in Love! (Bad End Mokuzen no Heroine ni Tensei shita Watashi, Konse de wa Renai suru Tsumori ga Cheat na Ani ga Hanashite kuremasen!? @COMIC) is based on an as-yet unlicensed light novel. The Japanese title seems to mention incest subtext the English one is not. Hopefully it’s just the usual overprotective brother thing. It runs in Comic Corona.

The other debut is Sanctify, a BL title from Placebo. An exorcist whose past lives have been tragic has to investigate a cult with the help of a mysterious cop. A mysterious hot cop.

MICHELLE: Hm. I do like BL with supernatural elements…

ANNA: Mysterious hotness sounds promising.

SEAN: SuBLime debuts Someday I’ll Fall for You (Itsuka Koi ni Naru Made), a BL title from moment. Two childhood friends discover the wonders of “helping each other out” at night, but then one of them gets a girlfriend. Given this is a BL title, I don’t see this ending well for her.

ANNA: Maybe she’s just not that helpful.

ASH: *snerk*

SEAN: They also have the 9th volume of Black or White.

Steamship has an early digital debut. The Obsessed Mage and His Beloved Statue Bride: She Cannot Resist His Seductive Voice (Yandere Mahoutsukai wa Sekizou no Otome shika Aisenai: Majo wa Manadeshi no Atsui Kuchizuke de Tokeru) is along the lines of the last LN Steamship released, at least in terms of the male love interest. Our heroine, to save the country, turns herself to stone for twenty years. Now her cute teenage assistant is an older, sexier man, and still totally in love with her.

ASH: Oh, my.

SEAN: It also gives us the 5th volume of Fire in His Fingertips: A Flirty Fireman Ravishes Me with His Smoldering Gaze.

Square Enix gives us By the Grace of the Gods 11 and The Strongest Sage with the Weakest Crest 21.

Seven Seas has some new stuff. My Kitten is a Picky Eater (Neko ni wa Neko no Neko Gohan) is a josei title from Manga Mee. A man picks up a dying cat and tries to nurse it back to health… but the cat hates store-bought food!

MICHELLE: Just this synopsis stresses me out!

ANNA: Some josei, do you say?

ASH: Josei cat manga, even! (But, yeah, that’s a potentially stressful scenario.)

SEAN: Yonoi Tsukihiko’s Happy Hell (Yonoi Tsukihiko no Shiawase na Jigoku) is a josei title from Petit Comic (!). A woman is forced into an arranged marriage to save the family farm. Unfortunately, she’s already in love. Also unfortunately, her new fiance doesn’t believe in love at all. Opposites attract!

ANNA: Always glad for even more josei!

ASH: More! And in the same week, too!

SEAN: Also from Seven Seas: 365 Days to the Wedding 5, Classroom of the Elite 12 (the final volume), Crossplay Love: Otaku x Punk 10, Dance in the Vampire Bund: Age of Scarlet Order 12, Delinquent Daddy and Tender Teacher 5, DUNGEON DIVE: Aim for the Deepest Level 6, No Longer Allowed In Another World 7, Sheep Princess in Wolf’s Clothing 4, Tokyo Revengers 25-26, Tokyo Revengers: A Letter from Keisuke Baji 2, and The Tree of Death: Yomotsuhegui 3 (the final volume).

One Peace Books has a 2nd volume of Kurokiya-san Wants to Lead Him Around by the Nose.

Debuting in print from Kodansha is Home Office Romance (Telework Yotabanashi). This Weekly Morning title from the creator of Sweat & Soap has an office worker at a brutal job welcome the pandemic as it means he can work from home… and also get to know the pretty grad student next door! It’s complete in one volume.

ASH: Sweat & Soap was great; I’ll need to check this one out.

SEAN: There’s also Sailor Moon (Naoko Takeuchi Collection) Manga Box Set 1, which has 6 volumes, posters, a holographic box… it’s fancy schmancy.

Sheltering Eaves (Koboreru Yoru ni) is a Josei title from Kiss. (Kiss *and* Petit Comic in the same week?) It’s from the creator of Perfect World, and features a girl sent to an orphanage due to her mother’s abuse. Now, four years later, she’s going to have to move out… but she has feelings for her fellow orphan who… well, sheltered her. See the title.

MICHELLE: Interesting! Josei is, to my delight, fairly common nowadays!

ANNA: Amazing, what a week!

ASH: I was not expecting that! (Also, what I read of Perfect World was rather good.)

SEAN: Also in print: A-DO 5, Hitorijime My Hero Manga Box Set 2, I See Your Face, Turned Away 3, Medaka Kuroiwa is Impervious to My Charms 9, ORIGIN 7, Sue & Tai-chan 5, and Wandance 11.

There’s also a digital debut. Did you enjoy As the Gods Will: The Second Series when it came out about 8 years ago? Well, now it’s time to read the original. (I do hear the 2nd series is more of a reboot.) In any case, this Bessatsu Shonen Magazine title is a death game series.

Also digital: Because I, the True Saint, was Banished, that Country is Done For! 6, Drops of God: Mariage 9, Gang King 23, Her Majesty’s Swarm 3 (the final volume), Manchuria Opium Squad 3, Otherworldly Munchkin: Let’s Speedrun the Dungeon with Only 1 HP! 10, and Tokyo Tarareba Girls Returns 2 4.

In print from J-Novel Club: Ascendance of a Bookworm 27 and the 8th Seirei Gensouki: Spirit Chronicles manga volume.

ASH: Bookworm!

SEAN: Digitally the debut is From Villainess to Healer: I Know the Cheat to Change My Fate (Kaifukushoku no Akuyaku Reijou) is a manga adaptation of an as yet unlicensed light novel. The manga runs in Flos Comic. Otome game, broken engagement, doomed, flee and become something else, etc.

Also from J-Novel Club: Ascendance of a Bookworm: Fanbook 5, The Hero and the Sage, Reincarnated and Engaged 2, the 3rd A Late-Start Tamer’s Laid-Back Life manga volume, The Reincarnation of the Strongest Exorcist in Another World 2, and A Surprisingly Happy Engagement for the Slime Duke and the Fallen Noble Lady 3 (the final volume).

One release from Ghost Ship, Becoming a Princess Knight and Working at a Yuri Brothel 3.

Lots of Mature Seven Seas stuff, though. Mostly BL, mostly webtoon. I never know how to talk about webtoon stuff. It makes me feel old, these vertically scrolling newfangled things. In any case, The Big Apple is a BL webtoon about a CIA assassin and his trying to quit… even though you can never quite being an assassin.

ASH: That often seems to be the case.

SEAN: That Time I Got Stuck to the Guy I Hate (Kirai na Yatsu to Kuttsuku Mahou ni Kakaru Hanashi) is a oneshot BL manga from Magazine Be x Boy (now that’s more like what I’m used to). Two roommates who don’t get along one day find they literally can’t pull themselves apart from each other.

MICHELLE: That… is kind of a flimsy premise.

ANNA: Usually these premises are filled with nuance and depth.

ASH: I will admit to being amused.

SEAN: And there’s a 4th volume of ENNEAD.

Dark Horse Comics have the 2nd Trigun Maximum Deluxe Omnibus, featuring Vol. 4-6.

Airship has the print debut of The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, Really Love You: Secret Love Story, which is a short story collection that is as bonkers as the main manga series.

ASH: I should really get around to reading the manga (and short stories) at some point.

SEAN: Also in print: Reincarnated as a Dragon Hatchling 8 and Reincarnated as a Sword 15.

For early digital, there is a debut. Heroine? Saint? No, I’m an All-Works Maid (And Proud of It)! (Heroine? Seijo? Iie, All Works Maid desu (Hokori)!). A former Japanese farm girl is reincarnated and becomes a maid to a poor noble family. Except… she seems to have holy magic? And men are flocking to her? Is she a heroine? Meh. Who cares? She’s a maid!

Pretty big list. We’re heading towards Christmas, that won’t change. Anything for you?

Filed Under: FEATURES, manga the week of

The Magic in This Other World Is Too Far Behind!, Vol. 10

November 6, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Gamei Hitsuji and Yunagi. Released in Japan as “Isekai Mahou wa Okureteru!” by Overlap Bunko. Released in North America digitally by J-Novel Club. Translated by Hikoki.

First of all, let’s get rid of that elephant in the room. The 11th volume is, as of this writing, not out in Japan yet. I really hope there is not a 5-year-gap between books 10 and 11 the way there was between Books 9 and 10, thank you very much, if only as I had to try to remember things I had long since forgotten when I assumed this series had gone the way of, say, Altina the Sword Princess. Secondly, I apologize to this book for having to read it today, when I was, for reasons I won’t get into, a bit distracted. That said, in the end we are here to see Suimei do cool magic things, and we definitely get that here – at least in the second half. The book is basically a ‘darkest before the dawn’ sort of book, and the first half or so focuses on Reiji, who feels his own hero power is Too Far Behind, and is prepared to possibly turn evil in order to solve the issue.

Suimei and his party are still in Japan as this book starts, which is unfortunate, as the demons have chosen this moment to attack… supposedly. It’s a somewhat puzzling, half-assed attack, as if their real goal is something else – much to the frustration of one of the demon generals. Unfortunately, with only one mage, a girl from Japan who’s new to the profession, actually present, the battle is not going well, especially as there are new artificially created demons that are sort of Noumu from My Hero Academia, only more insectoid. Reiji, without Suimei there to back him up/save his ass, is feeling powerless and pathetic, and unfortunately the power within him takes this time to tell him to beg for more power no matter what. The “no matter what” being a corruption that starts to happen almost immediately.

I feel for Reiji, but I will not deny that once Suimei returns to the story I was far more invested in actually reading it. I suspect we’ll be getting an “I know you’re still in there somewhere, fight!” moment for our hero soon. He and Suimei do share one very obvious trait, though, which is their total inability to see exactly how many young women want them. The scene in the baths was easily the most “light novel” in the volume, and honestly after the darkness of the previous 3/4 of the volume it felt like a breath of fresh air despite having an “oh no I fell and now your face is in my boobs” moment. The other highlight is the climax of the book, which helps to show off Suimei’s two superpowers, which are being incredibly overpowered and also being an incredible dick. His taunting of the demon general was hysterical, and, again, helped to take the edge of an “is our protagonist dead for real” scene even though we knew the answer was no.

So yeah, this was good. Was it worth the wait? Nothing is worth that wait. Hopefully the next one comes sooner.

Filed Under: magic in this other world is too far behind!, REVIEWS

The Dorky NPC Mercenary Knows His Place, Vol. 1

November 5, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Toryuu and hamm. Released in Japan as “Kimo Ota Mob Yōhei wa, Mi no Hodo o Wakimaeru” by Overlap Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Josh DM.

Sometimes you don’t need everything to be new. Sure, we love it when there’s a groundbreaking work that creates a new template going forward, but sometimes all you need is a different ingredient to make everything not quite stay the same. There have been other light novels that are set in space, of course, but those are irrelevant to me as I don’t read those. I did give this a try, though, as part of my “every once in a while I’ll try something I wouldn’t normally read” pick. And it’s good. Not great, not something I’d recommend. But it reads easily, the main characters are likeable (they may be the only likeable characters in this fictional world), and the fact that it’s in space helps to cover up the fact that this is basically a standard fantasy guild adventurer book, only with spaceships and lasers rather than dungeons and monsters. And then there’s the hero, who… well, despite what he says, we’ve seen his type before.

John Ouzos is a mercenary for hire, doing such jobs as security for a repair job, trying to stamp out space pirates, and occasionally getting involved in a war between rival nobles. He tends to stay out of flashy situations, do his job, and not get killed. He is a commoner, and knows that in this world that is trying to become more equal but isn’t yet, this is just the right thing for him to do. Unfortunately, not everyone agrees. Another mercenary pilot is furious that he’s hiding his true talents and being “lazy”. A sentient spaceship is determined to get him to pilot her so that she can be rid of her current immature pilot. And his old classmate is now a famous professional racer, and wants him to join her team. They all know what he won’t admit – he’s one of the very best.

Again, this hits its beats pretty well. As you can tell from the cover, it has a thing for breasts (and, as future covers will show, butts as well), but honestly I’ve seen worse. There was a very odd paragraph describing two arrogant noble siblings as “anti-men feminists” that made me growl a bit, but it went away almost as fast and the POV character was not to be trusted either. And of course, if you don’t like the sort of protagonist who will do anything to avoid being part of an exciting story, this isn’t for you by definition. But I liked how, the more you get to know the world John lives in (mostly through his endless exposition, which wasn’t too boring so I’ll let it slide), you realize that his plan to stay unnoticed is pretty smart. That said, even in his past he tended to get into death-defying situations, and that hasn’t changed. He may think he’s an NPC, and he’s certainly surrounded by evil nobles, but the hot girls around him know his true value.

Yeah, that’s right, it really is a stock light novel, but in space. I expect more harem next time. But till then, if you want to enjoy a standard LN that doesn’t require you to know how to cast from hit points, this is good.

Filed Under: dorky npc mercenary knows his place, REVIEWS

Earl and Fairy: Awaiting a Moonlit Elopement

November 4, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Mizue Tani and Asako Takaboshi. Released in Japan as “Hakushaku to Yōsei” by Shueisha Cobalt Bunko. Released in North America by J-Novel Heart. Translated by Alexandra Owen-Burns.

Sometimes I don’t read the blurbs before I start a volume, particularly if it’s a series I’ve been reading for a while. As a result, I came into this book not knowing that it was a short story volume. This is good and bad in some ways. It allows for less complicated narratives that better show off the two leads, and can also venture into other areas, such as Lydia’s pre-Edgar life. (All but the last short story were collected elsewhere, and the prologue was the first thing the author ever wrote for the series at all.) On the down side, without a big, action-packed and terrifying narrative to drive everything, we can sometimes be reminded a bit TOO much how irritatingly smug and possessive Edgar is, and how annoyingly naive and stubborn Lydia is. Fortunately, they’re only really at their worst in one of the short stories featured in this volume. So, of course, that particular story is the one that was used for the volume’s subtitle. Sigh.

There are five short stories in this book. 1) Before the events of the main series, a Lydia who’s just starting out meets a violinist plagued by a fairy, and makes a foolish decision that will need to be fixed by the man she’s trying to save. 2) We learn how Lydia first met Kelpie, as she helps to reunite Kelpie’s bookish brother with an elderly woman who romanced him in her youth; 3) Edgar takes Lydia to the opera, and they deal with a flower girl whose daisies are telling very accurate fortunes; 4) Lydia, having just read an exciting romance novel about a couple eloping, finds a young man being troubled by a lhiannan-shee, and decides to get involved despite Edgar, accurately, saying this is incredibly shady; 5) After the events of the 6th book, we see Edgar in London and Lydia in Scotland, both lonely at Christmastime.

The first three stories are all various shades of ‘pretty good’. The fourth annoyed me the most, as Lydia is even more naive than usual, which of course requires Edgar to be more possessive than usual, and they reinforce both their worst habits, especially as Lydia is still the sort of girl who will stubbornly jump off a cliff if Edgar tells her it’s a bad idea. That said, Lydia has heroine plot armor, unbeknownst to both of them, and therefore, of course, her naive ideas of romance and eloping turn out to be correct after all. The best story in the book is the final one, especially on Edgar’s side, as it shows him trying his best to try to fall for some other girl so he can let Lydia go and not involve her in his drama and failing miserably. The climax of the story, where fairy magic brings the two of them together for a brief period,. is the most romantic this series has gotten to date.

Next time we likely should get back to the main plot. Will we get Lydia firmly admitting her feelings with no backsies? That’s less likely. Will Edgar stop flirting with every single girl in London as part of his schemes? Even less likely.

Filed Under: earl and fairy, REVIEWS

How I Swapped Places with the Villainess, Beat Up Her Fiancé, and Found True Love, Vol. 1

November 3, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By BlueBlue and Meiji Anno. Released in Japan as “Danzai Sareteiru Akuyaku Reijou to Irekawatte Konyakusha-tachi wo Buttobashitara, Dekiai ga Matteimashita” by M Novels f. Released in North America by Cross Infinite World. Translated by JCT.

There are good elements to this book, which I promise I’ll get to later. But for the most part, as I was reading this I found myself thinking ‘we’ve finally hit the era of generic villainess books’. It’s boilerplate, and most things that it does do well (such as our heroine beating up her problems) are done better in other, more famous series and also ignored for the majority of the book. It features a super evil “heroine” character, which I have grown very bored with – if you’re going to be evil, you’d better at least be as interesting as Lilia. But the most annoying part of the book may be how easy it is. Everyone immediately figures out the problem and comes up with a solution. Our main character is overpowered. And mostly it’s just her friends doing a Noel Coward play while the heroine fumes. This book suffers from being smug.

You know how this begins. Truck-kun. After our main character is killed saving a mother and child from a truck at the cost of her own life, she meets a goddess who has a deal to make for her. She was killed by accident, so can’t be reincarnated in Japan. But fortunately there’s a bad situation in another world. Alexandra Vistriano is in a time loop. She has been betrayed by her friends and fiance, exiled, and brutally murdered four times now, and it’s about to be five. Her soul is so damaged by despair that she’s at risk of being lost forever. Could the main character, who grew up learning karate and is a bit of a tomboy, step into the villainess’ place? Of course! The new Alexandra has no issue beating the crap out of everyone trying to exile and betray her. That said… when she does that, time loops AGAIN, and Alexandra has to do everything for a sixth time.

I did mention the good things. There are some plot conceits I quite liked involving the time loops, which also help explain one of the book’s biggest and most ludicrous handwaves, the amulets of protection. I also really loved Alexandra finally snapping at the end of the book and screaming at Celette for everything she’d done, expressing sheer horror and disbelief that she could possibly be so cruel and uncaring. It felt earned. That said… the rest of the book feels too easy. Since Alexandra has her past life memories, AND she now has a ton more magic power thanks to the reincarnation, this particular loop mostly consists of the heroine failing over and over again and everyone sneering at her. Also, the main love interest is, well, a jealous and obsessive stalker, and YMMV with those types – I just read one two days ago in the other October CIW debut, so was less forgiving this time around.

And of course, one more common villainess book cliche – despite wrapping up all its plotlines in the first volume, there are four more. For completists only.

Filed Under: how i swapped places with the villainess, REVIEWS

A Pale Moon Reverie, Vol. 3

November 2, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Kuji Furumiya and Teruko Arai. Released in Japan as “Tsuki no Shirosa o Shirite Madoromu” by DRE Novels. Released in North America by J-Novel Club. Translated by Jason Li.

The third volume of this series, as with the previous two, is very much concerned with people who are trying to control other people vs. people who want to live their lives freely, and it’s not a surprise that we’re very much on the free side. The bulk of the first two-thirds of this volume involves fighting against a god who really wants to have Sari do what he says, and is quite content to blow everything up if he can’t do that. We also have Xixu, hemmed in by his royal blood and his diligence to duty, who needs to be almost killed and possessed himself before he and Sari finally agree to make the choice we’ve been waiting almost 1000 pages for them to make. Even the last third, an epilogue, features a bunch of slave traders kidnapping people, or blackmailing them into evil. At the end of the book, one open ending has an antagonist, no longer being blackmailed, simply leave the city, unsure how to be free. Sometimes control can feel safer.

There’s war in other countries, but it hasn’t quite hit Irede yet. Unfortunately, as a result of the fight she had in the last volume, Sari accidentally left behind a pool of blood for the enemy to find – which the enemy can now use to essentially create a number of brainwashed assassins. A much more down to earth problem is that there’s a new guy showing up to the Pale Moon every day, and he wants to go to bed with Sari, and he is not taking no for an answer. And of course there’s Vas, now possessed by a God and very interested in making Sari give up her humanity and making Xixu dead. It’s becoming increasingly apparent that most everything that’s been happening to date is the god’s doing. As a result, it’s probably a very good thing that, after a bit more pouting and self-deprecation, our couple are finally ready to BE a couple.

So yes, spoiling the one question that everyone who’s read the first two volumes has, they do indeed have sex. Indeed, it’s possibly the most awkward first time ever, as due to all the machinations of the plot that have been going on, it also involves some death and resurrection. Which feels very fitting in a book with so many gods going on. Xixu remains the same awkward but heroic guy he’s always been, but it’s really striking how much Sari comes alive after she’s finally chosen Xixu as her life partner. The Epilogue section in particular shows her fully in control, kicking eight kinds of ass, and freezing bad guys in ice and then shattering them to bits. She’s gotten over her worries. I also liked the plucky young royal we saw here, introduced as a theoretical threat but in reality that’s defused almost immediately and she proves to be a savvy businesswoman with a good head on her shoulders – which is good, because she gets abducted. Abductions happen a lot in this series.

Fans of Kuji Furumiya should read this, of course, but it’s also a good read for those who are sick of isekai RPG-style fantasy and want something different. It also has a lot of cool sword fights, magic battles, and giant snakes. I loved reading it. And hey, a lot less death than I was expecting!

Filed Under: a pale moon reverie, REVIEWS

The Frugal Priestess Becomes a Saint

November 1, 2024 by Sean Gaffney

By Hanami Nishine and Suzuka Oda. Released in Japan as “Isekai kara Seijo wo Yobe to Muchaburisareta Shinkan wa, Cost Performance no Tsugou de Seijo ni Naru” by Muchu Bunko Aletta. Released in North America by Cross Infinite World. Translated by Kashi Kamitoma.

I always like it when a book hits all the things I enjoy, though sometimes I have to remind myself that it’s fine because it’s fiction. The main romance here works because a) despite even the publisher labeling the Crown Prince a yandere, he’s very careful to go so far and no farther, so he gets to be extremely possessive and give chilly looks to everyone else, but around the girl he loves he’s a total soppy sweetheart. b) Fiona, our heroine, is as oblivious as a bag of things that don’t know they’re hammers, but because she’s so serious and dedicated, it’s refreshing. She lacks the ditzy quality we frequently see from this type, and it’s also very clear why she’s like this – she’s been carefully kept in a gilded cage for the last ten years. The reason for that, frankly, is not a mystery to the reader, but it is to her.

Fiona Everett is a talented priestess and aide to the pontiff. Unfortunately, the King has demanded that they summon a saint, mostly as the country next door has summoned one and he really wants to keep up with the Joneses. They already tried to summon a saint ten years ago, but it failed, and summoning one again will cost a great deal of time, manpower, and MONEY. So Fiona has an idea. Since saints traditionally have black hair, a rarity in this kingdom, and Fiona also has black hair, why doesn’t she says the spirit of the saint possessed her and she can act as a fake saint? The crown prince and the pontiff seem to go along with this pretty easily. Honestly, a bit too easily. And because Fiona is an overly serious, bookish sort, she’s decided she is the Saint of Cost Performance, balancing the books so that we see a lot more fixed bridges and a lot fewer replacement wigs.

So yeah, not to spoil too much, but Fiona actually has no memories from before she was ten years old, where she was taken in by the pontiff and also when the crown prince started doting on her. It does not take a brain surgeon to figure out the big secret everyone is covering up. The best part of the book is how the writing keeps Fiona both likeable and powerful without having to back off on her not understanding why Linus is kissing her hair, going with her wherever she goes, and having her sleep in his lap when she’s exhausted. This is played for humor, mostly in the coments from everyone around them who cannot believe she doesn’t get it, and it really is funny. Everyone calls Linus a sexual harrasser, which is true in terms of the letter of the law, I suppose, but it’s not as if Fiona ever tells him to stop either. Basically, she’s unconsciously in love with him the entire book. We also do meet another saint from a different country, who manages to be an absolute terror and makes me very happy Fiona decidedly does NOT regain her memories at the end of the book.

It’s also only one volume long, so even the series is cost-effective! If you can put up with clueless but studious heroines and handsy, possessive (but not sadistic) princes, this is a must read. Also, it has Fiona solve a problem by slapping someone in the face over and over and over again, which was glorious and I now want that in every book I read.

Filed Under: frugal priestess becomes a saint, REVIEWS

  • « Go to Previous Page
  • Page 1
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 34
  • Page 35
  • Page 36
  • Page 37
  • Page 38
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 541
  • Go to Next Page »
 | Log in
Copyright © 2010 Manga Bookshelf | Powered by WordPress & the Genesis Framework