Manga Bookshelf

Discussion, Resources, Roundtables, & Reviews

Chainsaw Man

The Manga Review: Looking Backward

by Leave a Comment

Buckle up, dear reader; this week’s Manga Review is bursting at the seams!

The first order of business? The best (and worst) of 2022. The Comics Journal recently posted its annual list, polling thirty-three critics, artists, editors, and scholars about their favorite titles. While some of the nominations were predictable—there were a lot of folks praising Kate Beaton’s Ducks—there were also a refreshing number of contributors who discussed their manga-reading habits, among them Ritesh Babu, Helen Chazan, Austin English, Charles Hatfield, Chris Mautner, Joe McCulloch, and Katie Skelly. The Beat’s 30 Best Comics of 2022 had fewer manga entries but offered a more balanced list of mainstream and indie comics, as did The Mary Sue, which gave nods to Junji Ito and Yamada Murasaki in its list of the 30 Best Comics and Graphic Novels of 2022, and From Cover to Cover, which named Gengoroh Tagame’s Our Colors among the year’s best titles. Perhaps the most interesting list was Polygon’s 10 Best Comics of 2022, which gave shout-outs to Look Back and Yokohama Kaidashi Kikou as well as Jamilla Rowser and Robyn Smith’s Wash Day Diaries.

Readers in search of manga-only lists will find plenty to choose from, including Okazu’s Best Yuri of 2022, But Why Tho’s Top BL Manga of 2022, and Anime UK News’s favorite Manga, Manhwha, and Light Novels of 2022. Also worth a look: Asian Movie Pulse’s 10 Best Manga Releases of 2022, Beneath the Tangles’ Best Manga of 2022, Bounding Into Comics’ Top 10 New Manga Series of 2022, CBR’s Best New & Ongoing Manga of 2022, Game Rant’s 10 Best Manga of 2022, The Outerhaven’s Top 5 Manga of 2022, and Screen Rant’s 10 Best Manga of 2022. Last but not least, I posted my first Best and Worst Manga list in… (checks notes) seven years, focusing on the titles that most delighted and annoyed me in 2022.

NEWS…

Did you know the New York Times has revived its Graphic Books and Manga Bestseller List? (Me, neither.) By whatever metrics they’re using, Chainsaw Man and Shuna’s Journey are selling briskly but not as well as Dav Pilkey’s perennially popular Cat Kid and Dog Man series. [The New York Times]

To mark the twentieth anniversary of Yuricon, Erica Friedman is moving the event online and reimagining the format “as a series of presentations and panels to be held online throughout the year on Yuri Studio.” Anyone interested in organizing a panel or giving a presentation at Yuricon 2023 is encouraged to fill out an application at Okazu. [Okazu]

Publishers Weekly compiles its “top-15 most-read articles on comics” and, to no one’s surprise, “Manga Is Booming” topped the list. [PW]

Shonen Jump readers take note: the cost for US subscribers is going up a $1.00/month. Krystallina offers more context for the rate increase, and reflects on the state of the digital manga market. [The OASG]

Wondering what new series you can expect to see at your local bookstore this month? Bill Curtis has you covered with a comprehensive list of January’s manga and light novel releases. [Yatta-Tachi]

…AND VIEWS

Fatimah explains why Tenmaku no Jendoogar (A Witch’s Life in Mongol) deserves an English-language release. The title, which won a 2023 Kono Manga ga Sugoi Award, focuses on an Iranian girl “who’s a captive of the Mongol Empire and uses her education to her advantage.” Fatimah provides insight into the time period in which the story takes place, discusses one of the real-life characters who appears in the story, and praises the artwork for its graceful fusion of Japanese and Persian sensibilities. [Saffron Apple Pie Manga Recs]

In a generously illustrated essay, Leo Flemisch argues that “few cartoonists have explored what it means to exit childhood as profoundly as Japanese manga artist Taiyō Matsumoto.” [SOLRAD]

Marcel Green compares Shonen Jump‘s most recent crop of titles with older series and notices that the magazine has shifted away from stories that “center on an individual’s quest for glory or redemption” to stories that “focus on the individual’s connection with their family.” [Screen Rant]

Ana Diaz explains why fans of the Chainsaw Man anime should read the manga, too. [Polygon]

Over at Drop-In to Manga, Tony Yao uses the teacher-student dynamic in Akane-banashi as a jumping-off point for exploring mental myopia. [Drop-In to Manga]

Cy Catwell offers a thoughtful reflection on why I Am a Wall mattered to them in 2022. “Trauma is a vicious thing, and yet I Want to Be a Wall is a reminder that trauma has an opposite: healing,” they write. “This is the crux of I Want to Be a Wall’s narrative, a reminder that there are ways to be happy, ways to survive and even thrive in the world when healing is centered, when you no longer are forced to always feel strange.” [Anime Feminist]

LISTENING IN

Over at Manga Machinations, Seamus, Morgana, Darfox8, and dakazu unveil the winners of their Best Manga of 2022 Awards in categories ranging from Most Enjoyable to There’s Still Hope. [Manga Machinations]

Not to be outdone, David and Jordan hand out “the most prestigious awards in canceled manga – The Shonen Flop Awards aka The Floppies,” naming their favorite—and least favorite—titles of the year. [Shonen Flop]

Also weighing in on the year’s best manga are Ray and Gee, hosts of Read Right to Left. [Read Right to Left]

Justin and Helen close out 2022 with a look at the year’s weirdest anime and manga news. [The OASG Podcast]

For their final podcast of 2022, Elliot and Andy look at two fantasy series: Reincarnated as a Sword and Colorless. [Screentone Club]

Manga Mavericks Colton and Lum weigh in on four new series available on the Shonen Jump website: The Ichinose Family’s Deadly Sins, Cipher Academy, Ichigoki’s Under Control!!, and Fabricant 100. [The Manga Mavericks]

The dynamic duo of Ed Piskor and Jim Rugg take a deep dive into GENGA: Otomo Katsuhiro Original Pictures. First published in 2012, GENGA offers readers insight into Otomo’s approach to character design and layout, as well as rare glimpses of his work as a commercial illustrator. [Cartoonist Kayfabe]

REVIEWS

Johanna Draper Carlson explains why she doesn’t make the recipes in What Did You Eat Yesterday?, while Jaime explains why she found A Tropical Fish Yearns for Snow disappointing. On the capsule review front, the staff at Beneath the Tangles offer pithy assessments of Dandadan, My Gently Raised Beast, and SHY, my Manga Bookshelf colleagues weigh in on Captain Corinth, Skip and Loafer, and Usotoki Rhetoric, and WWAC’s Carrie McClain tackles the latest crop of manga and light novels from Seven Seas.

New and Noteworthy

Complete and Ongoing Series

The Manga Review, 10/14/22

by Leave a Comment

Historically, New York Comic Con was the event for big licensing announcements, but in recent years manga publishers have focused more on promoting their best-selling series than on unveiling new acquisitions. While this year’s event yielded some licensing news–VIZ, for example, revealed that it would be publishing a new Spiderman manga–the bigger story is that many companies are casting their nets widely for new content. “One notable trend,” Deb Aoki observes, “is the growth of webtoons, including comics content originally from Korea and China, and original comics created by a wave of international creators featured on such mobile comics platforms such as Webtoon, Tapas Media, Manta, Lezhin, and Tappytoon.” Yen Press, in particular, was enthusiastically promoting its new Korean comics imprint Ize Press, which will release its first titles this fall. Will readers embrace Korean comics this time around? Hard to say, but given the current wave of teen interest in Korean music, television, and movies, it’s not a stretch to imagine that Yen Press will find a more receptive audience for manhwa than it did ten or fifteen years ago. Stay tuned…

NEWS AND VIEWS

For the second year in a row, Chainsaw Man won the Harvey Award for Best Manga, beating out Blood on the Tracks, Blue Lock, Cat + Gamer, Red Flowers, and Spy x Family. [The Beat]

Seven Seas announced three new additions to its spring 2023 schedule: Last Game, The Great Snake’s Bride, and A Story of Seven Lives. [Seven Seas]

Erica Friedman files a report from New York Comic Con. [Okazu]

Whether you’re new to manga or just want to refresh your library’s collection, Sara Smith has you covered. Join her for Manga 101 at this year’s SLJ Summit. [SLJ Summit 2022]

If you listen to only one podcast this week, make it the latest episode of Mangasplaining, which focuses on Jun Mayuzuki’s Kowloon Generic Romance. Come for the thoughtful commentary, stay for the fascinating history lesson on the neighborhood that inspired the story. [Mangasplaining]

Ashley and Asher jump in the WABAC machine for a look at Yuu Watase’s Absolute Boyfriend. [Shojo & Tell]

The latest Taiiku Podcast focuses on When a Cat Faces West and Reincarnated as a Sword. [Manga in Your Ears]

Ryosuke Arakane interviews Kazuo Umezu about his creative process as both as a painter and a manga artist. “Having a childlike spirit is a profound thing,” he notes. “It’s a great thing I picked up. My stories feature children, so there’s a connection… The difference between adults and children is that adults might think something is childish, but children might think the opposite.” [Tokion]

REVIEWS

Krystallina reviews Risky Business, a digital-only offering from Media Do. “Risky Business sounds like a gambling manga, but the only gamble is the one you take on this series,” she notes. “On one hand, the manga is very intriguing with all the manipulation and underhanded tricks going on. On the other hand, man, this manga has a high amount of unlikable characters.” Over at Okazu, Erica Friedman explains why she’s looking forward to more installments of She Loves to Eat, She Loves to Cook.

New and Noteworthy

Ongoing and Complete Series

The Manga Review, 10/7/22

by Leave a Comment

Bust out that Sailor Moon costume–New York Comic Con is in full swing! If you’re looking for a good manga panel, I highly recommend This Manga Is Awesome! Manga Must-Reads and Underrated Gems, which is happening today at 3:30 pm. Deb Aoki leads an all-star crew of librarians, industry professionals, podcasters, and critics in a lively discussion about their favorite series. Also of note is Comics in the Post Pandemic World, which is scheduled for Saturday at 12:30 pm. Publishers Weekly is the sponsor; the conversation will focus on the explosive growth of the comics industry during lockdown, and will consider some of the challenges facing publishers as supply chain issues increase and inflation rises.

NEWS AND VIEWS

Jamila Rowser, founder of Black Josei Press, posted an update on the forthcoming Gladiolus Magazine, which “will feature comics, essays, short stories, and more created by people of color from marginalized genders and sexualities.” Rowser shared a list of contributors whose work will appear in the inaugural issue, as well as the magazine’s expected publication date: spring 2023. [Black Josei Press]

Bill Curtis compiles a list of October’s new manga and light novel releases. [Yatta-Tachi]

To kick off LGBTQ History Month, the librarians at No Flying No Tights recommend nine queer-friendly comics for teen readers, including The Bride Was a Boy and Be Gay, Do Comics. [No Flying No Tights]

Yuu Watase is resuming work on Fushigi Yugi Byakko Senki. [Otaku USA]

It’s a hit: Chainsaw Man now has 16 million volumes in print. [Otaku USA]

Dog lovers rejoice: Seven Seas has licensed Shibanban: Super Cute Doggies which is pretty much what it sounds like: a parade of adorable Shiba Inus doing adorable things. Volume one is slated for a May 2023 release. [Seven Seas]

If you’ve been on the fence about Taiyo Matsumoto‘s work, let Jocelyne Allen’s generously illustrated review of Tokyo Higoro persuade you to give him a second chance. “Pretty much every page is filled with such thoughtful detail to make even minor characters seem fully fleshed out,” she notes. “It’s one of those books that I kept flipping back and forth in, just to drink in the details, the art, and the many, many perfect pages.” [Brain vs. Book]

VIDEO OF THE WEEK

I’m not a big MangaTuber, but I make an exception for BakaBoysClub, a new-ish YouTube channel featuring lively, thoughtful reviews of manga, old and new. In particular, I thought that host GrunWho did an exceptional job of explaining why The Girl from the Other Side: Siúl, A Rún is such an engrossing story, making great use of the video format to highlight Nagabe’s beautiful artwork:

Check out the BakaBoys’ other videos here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCnmtMpN3E2LGnz_Mef4zCCw.

REVIEWS

Thinking about starting your own manga blog or podcast? One great way to build an audience for your work is to contribute to an established site like The Fandom Post, which is currently looking for reviewers. Site founder Chris Beveridge notes that “we get a good range of books from publishers and have a bit of a backlog we’re looking to clear out… There’s a good mix of one-offs and ongoing series that we’re looking for people to take on and new series starting up all the time.” For information on how to apply, click here.

New and Noteworthy

Complete and Ongoing Series

Chainsaw Man, Vol 1

by

Chainsaw Man Volume 1 by Tatsuki Fujimoto

Monster or demon hunting manga is a fairly common shonen manga scenario, but Chainsaw Man keeps it fresh, thanks to the introduction of chainsaws!? Actually Denji starts out in such a difficult situation, it is hard not to sympathize with him. He’s sold off some of his organs like his eye and he struggles every day to piece together a meager living from monster hunting, helped out by his pet demon dog Pochita who manages to look adorable despite having a chainsaw for a nose. Denji dreams of the day that he’ll have enough money to actually put jam on the slice of bread that makes up most of his meals, but it wouldn’t be the first volume of a shonen manga if there weren’t some powered up surprises in store for the hero.

There’s a level of off-kilter humor in Chainsaw Man that I find endearing. I found Denji heading into the woods to cut trees with his dog’s chainsaw nose extremely amusing. When Denji tells Pochita that if anything happens to him, the demon is free to take over his body and live his best life, his dog unexpectedly answers saying “I’ll give you my heart, in exchange show me your dreams.” Denji wakes up with his wounds from a recent attack healed, and a chainsaw pull sticking out of his chest. In some illustrated action sequences that show an impressive command of body horror, Denji cuts his way out of a pile of demons do to his sudden ability to manifest chainsaws on the top of his head and one of his arms. An attractive girl accompanied by additional agents suddenly appears and gives him a hug and introduces herself as a devil hunter for public safety. Makita offers him the choice to be slain as a demon or live as her pet, and she’s willing to provide incredibly yummy breakfasts.

Denji has difficulty integrating into his new Public Safety Demon Hunter squad, with some altercations with a new rival, and some funny slice of live scenes that showcase his unending devotion to jam at breakfast. There’s also plenty of juvenile humor as once Denji has the basics of food and shelter secured he promptly decides that his next mission in life is to touch some boobs. Overall, I found the monster fighting, buckets of gore, and humor in Chainsaw Man plenty amusing. Denji is an incredibly damaged but potentially powerful hero, so I’m definitely intrigued by seeing him chainsaw his way through further adventures.

Chainsaw Man

by

There comes a moment in every manga reader’s journey when they’re no longer dazzled by the sheer variety of genres, styles, or outrageous storylines that an issue of Weekly Shonen Jump or Big Comic Spirits offers—the moment when a manga about killer goldfish or a warrior with lethal nose hair sounds more exhausting than awesome. I reached that milestone around the time I read The Qwaser of Stigmata, a manga so lewdly preposterous I felt uncomfortable even summarizing the plot in my review. So when I heard about Chainsaw Man, a series whose premise is pretty much summed up in the title, I was pretty sure I wasn’t interested in reading it. Then I saw this image:

My first thought was whoa. And then: cool. And so began my Chainsaw Man read-a-thon, an attempt to understand the appeal of this blood-and-testosterone-soaked battle manga.

The character atop the shark is Denji, who begins the story as an ordinary young man struggling to pay off his father’s gambling debts. His only friend is the sweet-faced Pochita, a dog demon with a chainsaw blade where his snout should be. After local mobsters brutally attack Denji, Pochita transfers his demonic powers to Denji, thus enabling Denji to transform from scrawny teen to chainsaw-wielding menace with the pull of a cord. His remarkable abilities attract the interest of Makima, a professional Devil Hunter who recognizes Denji’s potential value as a weapon. Through a mixture of flirtation, cajoling, and threats, Makima recruits Denji for the Public Safety Council, dispatching him to kill monsters.

Going into Chainsaw Man, I was fully prepared for carnage and mayhem and three-eyed sharks. What I didn’t expect were moments of genuine pathos. The interactions between Denji and Pochita, however, are sniffle-inducing, underscoring the poignancy of Pochita’s decision to sacrifice himself for Denji. Later chapters set up an interesting parallel between Denji’s relationship with Pochita and his relationship with Makima, who refers to him as her “dog.” When Denji chafes against the conditions Makima has imposed on their partnership, it spurs a moment of self-reflection about his own treatment of Pochita, making him realize just how much he took Pochita’s companionship for granted.

Of course, no one is reading Chainsaw Man for these kind of emotional beats; they’re hoping for outrageous displays of gore and violence, and on that front, Tatsuki Fujimoto does his utmost to push the boundaries of good taste. Every time Denji reverts to his demonic form, chainsaw blades burst through his chest and head with great clouds of arterial spray, a preview of the even bloodier manner in which he kills his enemies. Though some of the demons are uninspired—how’s a giant bat grab you?—Fujimoto’s most memorable creations are clearly designed to elicit an appreciative “ewww”; the first monster Denji kills, for example, is an enormous tomato devil who looks like something that’s been moldering in the crisper drawer for weeks.

Between the action scenes, Fujimoto peppers the script with crude jokes to remind us that Denji is a teenage boy whose primary motivation for fighting demons is to impress Makima and earn enough money to eat junk food. In that respect, Denji is a more honest shonen hero than the typical Jump lead; he thinks and acts like a real teenage boy, right down to his self-absorption and total objectification of women. (There’s even a chapter called “A Way to Touch Some Boobs.” Yes, really.) I can’t say I ever warmed to Denji as a lead character, but I finished my read-a-thon with a grudging respect for Fujimoto’s excessive, ridiculous creation, which entertained and repelled me in equal measure. Your mileage will vary.

Chapters 1-53 of Chainsaw Man are available at the VIZ website. 

CHAINSAW MAN • STORY AND ART BY TATSUKI FUJIMOTO • VIZ MEDIA