Michelle Smith

This week, Sean and Michelle take a look at recent releases from Seven Seas, Yen Press, Viz Media, and Kodansha Comics

Alice in the Country of Joker: Nightmare Trilogy, Vol. 2 | By QuinRose and Job | Seven Seas – Slightly better than the first volume, this has an interesting premise in that for once Alice has a repressed memory her love doesn’t want her to see that isn’t about Lorina. The idea of her scribbling in her dictionary is somewhat childish, but that fits the plot pretty well, to be honest. Unfortunately, we keep running into two big problems. First, the art is simply not up to par, frequently looking almost doujinshi-esque, and suggests a rushed product. Secondly, Nightmare just isn’t that good of a romantic hero, not showing off enough cool to make up for his basic flaws. It’s sad that the cutest part of this volume was in a side story which is Alice/Blood. For completists only.-Sean Gaffney

Durarara!! Yellow Scarves Arc, Vol. 2 | By Ryohgo Narita, Suzuhito Yasuda, and Akiyo Satorigi | Yen Press – It’s impressive just how much the narrative is bending itself to make sure that its three leads don’t find out about each other’s secrets. Masaomi *almost* sees Anri here, but Celty manages to rescue her before the damage is done. As you can guess, most of this volume is backstory and buildup, showing why Masaomi is tormented in his relationship with Saki, as well as how Kadota’s gang ties into this (Walker blithely setting thugs on fire is in keeping with this author’s tendency to enjoy psychopathic tendencies). And then there’s Shinra’s father, who is a real loathsome piece of work on all fronts. Ah, DRRR, even your likeable heroes are broken.-Sean Gaffney

Food Wars!, Vol. 3 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | Viz Media – OK, this series has now fully won me over after its awful start. It’s got just what you want from a Jump series: ridiculous side character, rivals turned friends, ludicrous battles that are also amazing, all involving cooking, and teamwork winning out… well, at least till the end, when Megumi is expelled. I highly doubt that will last, and the cliffhanger suggests a new battle may change the outcome. But it also allows for some heartbreak. There’s a short story at the end that was Saeki’s debut work, showing a typical high school romance and also likely showing why he was paired with a writer for this new project. The main reason to get this is Food Wars, though, and I am looking forward to the next volume.-Sean Gaffney

Haganai: I Don’t Have Many Friends – Club Minutes | By Kurian and Bomi | Seven Seas – This volumes holds together a little better than the previous ‘comedy side stories’ volume, partly due to its focus on holidays, giving it more of a thematic impact. Everyone’s amusing quirks are on display here. Rika makes filthy jokes, Yukimura is deadpan (this time about the Warring States), Sena can’t win at bishoujo games, and Yozora is the most broken of them all. We actually seem to skip past the main release, timeline-wise, as we see Student Council members who are implied to be new regulars here, and seem to have wandered in from a more normal comedy Still, it wasn’t too spoilery, and those who want more Haganai will be happy with what this volume gives them.-Sean Gaffney

Honey Blood Vol. 2 | By Miko Mitsuki | Viz Media – Well, that didn’t end so much as stop. Despite the author’s best efforts to say that this was indeed the ending she had in mind, this ending comes very abruptly and made me raise an eyebrow. (There’s a ‘side’ volume in February, that seems to consist of the ‘pilot episode’ and some side stories.) It’s a surprise as we get a new antagonist vampire introduced here, who’s carried a grudge against Junya since the Edo period and is determined to break up our couple. Add this to Hinata’s worries about whether she can really be what Junya needs, and whether hteir ‘bond’ requires sex in order to work, and you have a tasty little vampire potboiler for supernatural fans. Just… be aware it stops rather than ends. -Sean Gaffney

Knights of Sidonia, Vol. 12 | By Tsutomu Nihei | Vertical Comics – There’s some obvious emotional manipulation going on in this volume, even more so than usual, and yet I still manage to find myself feeling bad for Sho, the newly introduced Honoka clone who is introduced to die tragicaslly, in a callback to events of the first few volumes with Hoshijiro (remember her?). I was less wild about the subplot involving who’s been peeping on the female pilots when they’re changing – naturally, everyone blames Tanikaze, and just as naturally it isn’t him. But if you’re going to introduce harem manga elements in your story, I suppose you have to take the bad with the good. Still, this volume is better off when it’s trying to pull at your heartstrings rather than hit your funnybone.-Sean Gaffney

Magi, Vol. 9 | By Shinobu Ohtaka | Viz Media – A transitional volume of Magi, this serves to a) introduce a whole bunch of new powerful people who serve under Sinbad, including the cover couple, who hate each other so it must be love; b) have a wacky comedic subplot involving Sinbad being accused of raping a girl in her sleep, which I could have done without; and c) introducing a new protagonist, Hakuryu Ren, who initially seems a bit villainous but allies himself with our heroes fairly quickly. Oh yes, and there’s Morgiana, who repurposes the shackles she once wore in slavery into her new magical weapons, which almost makes up for the comedy subplot. A good volume, but I’m more looking forward to what happens next.-Sean Gaffney

Millennium Snow, Vol. 4 | By Bisco Hatori | Viz Media – It’s possibly unfortunate that this came out the same week as the last Honey Blood, as they both feature very similar plotlines, with a vampire from the past arriving to stir things up and ruin our hero’s life. Of course, Toya is far easier to manipulate than Junya, so things work out a lot better for the villain here. It’s up to Chiyuki, now dying again without Toya’s help, to try to figure out what’s really going on. The outcome is not really in doubt, nor is the epilogue,, but it’s still nice to see feelings being returned. Oh yes, there’s also the subplot with Toya’s grandfather, which has a sad and tragic air around it as it deals with senility that comes with old age. A solid, if somewhat stolid, ending for the series.-Sean Gaffney

Voice Over: Seiyu Academy, Vol. 8 | By Maki Minami | Viz Media – We’ve already seen Hime having to deal with her apathetic, neglectful mother earlier in the series. Now we get Senri’s parents, and we find out that things are even rougher here. I love the flashback to Senri’s parents, as it’s framed as a sort of shoujo manga of its own, with two eccentric people meeting cutely and falling for each other. But there’s a reason shoujo mangas often stop before the couple has children (or even a wedding), and this is why: it doesn’t always translate into good parenting. Given Sakura is also the actress who most deeply influenced Hime, and we can see a major roadblock coming up in the next volume or so – assuming Hime gets past admitting that she’s Shiro.-Sean Gaffney

Voice Over!: Seiyu Academy, Vol. 8 | By Maki Minami | Viz Media – Although the regular gang makes an appearance in the first chapter, in which Tsukino finally manages to speak up and convey her feelings, the majority of this volume is devoted to Senri’s childhood. It all starts because he realizes his friendship with Shiro (heroine Hime in disguise) is making him happy, but then he panics because he can’t tell if it’s genuine happiness or just a performance. It turns out his famous actress mother was never her genuine self around Senri, always taking on a variety of roles and not considering how this would affect her son and his ability to relate to others. I suppose this could be treading perilously close to one of those shoujo manga that becomes mostly about the lead guy’s angst, but I actually quite enjoyed it, especially the story of Senri’s first cat friend. I find I’m sad that there are only four volumes left! – Michelle Smith

Witchcraft Works, Vol. 2 | By Ryu Mizunagi | Vertical Comics – There are some interesting battles and discussion of witchcraft here in this second volume, but for the most part the emphasis remains firmly on comedy, particularly with the introduction of Honoka’s overprotective little sister Kasumi, who it turns out is also a witch. If you saw the words ‘overprotective little sister’ and groaned at the thought of what was to come, congratulations, you win the otaku cliche bingo card. She sleeps in his bed, she takes baths with him, etc. No surprise then that Honoka (also for everyone’s safety) moves into Ayaka’s high rise, though they may not live long enough to enjoy it. I’m not sure I’m going to keep up with this one, but it’s fun for fans of supernatural comedy, even if a bit predictable.-Sean Gaffney

This week, Sean and Michelle look at recent releases from Viz Media and Kodansha Comics.

Kimi Ni Todoke, Vol. 20 | By Karuho Shiina | Viz Media – This is still Sawako’s story, and her development here is great, but I do love that there’s just as much investment in having the other two heroines grow up as well – Sawako’s career choice is actually the easiest. It’s also great to see the good teacher we know Pin is, as he reminds Chizu that running a ramen joint requires more than just knowing how to cook, and tells Yano straight up that she has the talent to set her goals higher… so why isn’t she? Her mother backs this up, and now Yano is not only wondering about her life goals but about her relationship with Kento. I’d complained earlier that I felt this series might be running a bit long, but this volume showed it still has a lot more going on. – Sean Gaffney

Nura: Rise of the Yokai Clan, Vol. 24 | By Hiroshi Shiibashi | Viz Media – For the most part, this penultimate volume of Nura is a bunch of battles. I believe that the actual end in Weekly Jump is here, approximately halfway through – the rest ended up being in the extra issues like Jump Next, etc. It’s nice seeing the school classmates here, even if it fells like a goodbye – Nura quickly outgrew its “real-world” aspect, and even Kana is an afterthought now, as it’s Tsurara who spends the volume by Rikuo’s side. We see the culmination of what he’s been doing the entire series, as everyone he approached to be allies in the fight now shows up to help out, leaving him safe to fight the final boss. This was never the best shonen series, but I’ll miss it. – Sean Gaffney

Real, Vol. 13 | By Takehiko Inoue | Viz Media – The latest volume of this wheelchair basketball drama is actually all about pro wrestling, as Takahashi’s rehab companion, Shiratori, makes an inspirational return to the ring, fighting in such a way that the audience is oblivious to his disability. While it was nice to learn more about his backstory, better still is the impact his performance has on Hanasaki and Takahashi. The latter, especially, watches Shiratori fighting with everything he’s got left, pushing himself to the limit for something he loves and finally completely lets go of the aloof, unaffected persona he’d cultivated in high school and embraces his real self, who could love something passionately. To that end, the final page is him showing up to join a wheelchair basketball team. Maybe it sounds simplistic described in words, but in Inoue’s sure hands, the end result is very moving. Now to endure another year before volume fourteen! – Michelle Smith

Toriko, Vol. 25 | By Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro | Viz Media – I will admit to being a bit disappointed with this volume. I wanted more amazing cooking battles, but sadly Gourmet Corps crashes the event and starts attacking everything, so instead this turns into a melee battle. It’s not without its high points – I liked Coco explaining to Komatsu why chefs such as him are so highly prized in this world, and a battle between Sunny and Tommyrod promises to be rather epic – but for the most part this is a bunch of people showing off their fighting power, then vanishing from the narrative to make way for more people. Combine that with the already high number of new chefs introduced in the last volume, and you have a Toriko that’s less than the sum of its parts. – Sean Gaffney

xxxHOLIC Rei, Vol. 2 | By CLAMP | Kodansha Comics – Yeah, OK, I knew I wasn’t really getting a reboot. Clearly this takes place after the main series, and also clearly there is something terribly wrong, seemingly based on a decision that Watanuki made at some point, something lampshaded by his being interrupted here in this dream/whatever world before he can choose between two gifts. He has knowledge of the supernatural that could only come with experience, and is thus surprising everyone – or is he? In any event, we also still have the usual supernatural, yokai-influenced stories, which are the best part of xxxHOLIC for me. And Himawari’s here, yay! And not married to generic guy we never see and shoved offscreen! Oh xxxHOLIC, why can’t I quit you?-Sean Gaffney

This week, Sean, Michelle, & Anna look at recent releases from Viz Media, Kodansha Comics, and Yen Press.

Happy Marriage?!, Vol. 9 | By Maki Enjoji | Viz Media – We’re starting to wrap everything up here, and it shows. There’s a brief ‘I must not confess my horrible secret’ plotline here, but it’s resolved without much fuss. Hokuto can still be difficult to read, and Chiwa gets emotional, but that’s them, and we’re not doubting their Happy Marriage here. That leaves us with Hokuto’s father, whose death is not a surprise but does allow for some closure. And of course the attacks on Chiwa continue. I had already guessed that Hokuto’s ex was a red herring, but the author has done a good job at concealing the real culprit – I have my suspicions, but am still unsure. In any case, a nasty cliffhanger here, but I expect everything should work out well in the end. – Sean Gaffney

Honey Blood, Vol. 2 | By Miko Mitsuki | Viz Media – I didn’t have high hopes for volume two of Honey Blood, since I’d initially found the characters generic and their romance unconvincing, but it turned out to be quite an improvement! It helps that one can just accept that teenage Hinata and immortal vampire Junya are now a couple, and go on from there. What I really liked was that a rosy future for these two seemed downright unlikely. Hinata opines frequently about their current happiness not lasting, and a character from Junya’s past instills further doubts when he reveals that Hinata is the spitting image (and probably the descendant) of Junya’s former love, whom he admits he can never forget. And the best, most bittersweet, twist comes at the very end. Mitsuki-sensei writes that she’d hoped for a longer serialization and wasn’t able to wrap everything up to her satisfaction, but ultimately, this series turned out to be much better than I’d originally thought. – Michelle Smith

Food Wars!: Shokugeki no Soma, Vol. 3 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki | Viz Media – Man, sometimes shounen manga just hits the spot! I really enjoyed this third volume of Food Wars!, in which all 980 members of Soma’s class at the Totsuki Institute go off to cooking camp, where distinguished alumni of the school set challenges in which failure means immediate expulsion. Every good shounen hero needs a worthy rival, and Soma gets his own Akira Touya in this volume in the form of Takumi Aldini, a boy his age who also grew up in a humble family restaurant and has experience cooking for actual customers. I look forward to them challenging and inspiring each other for a long time to come. Soma’s friend and class partner, Megumi, makes some welcome progress, too, and the volume ends on a cliffhanger regarding her future. Realistically, I know that she’s probably not genuinely in peril, but I still wish I had volume four here already! – Michelle Smith

My Little Monster, Vol. 5 | By Robico | Kodansha Comics – The romance and comedy in My Little Monster are both pretty good, but let’s face it: we read this series for the deeply broken characters, right? Haru’s violence continues to disturb me, and something has to give soon there – I simply don’t trust him enough. Natsume is dealing with feelings she’s not ready to handle, particularly given her past. Shizuku wonders if she’s bothering to do enough in her relationship, and Yamaken is easily the most self-aware and savvy character in the cast, but that’s not helping him at all. It all comes to a head in a disastrous ski trip, with lots of misunderstandings. This is one of the better train wrecks I’ve read, and I mean that in the best possible way. – Sean Gaffney

Phantom Thief Jeanne Vol. 5 | By Arina Tanemura | Viz Media – One of the main reasons for my enduring fondness for this series is the absolutely crazy ending, where Maron goes to heaven, explores the complexities and secrets of the tale of Genesis with a magical girl twist, and finally dukes it out with the source of all darkness in the world. Maron ends up in a much better emotional place, and is able to resolve the issues causing the theme of loss and abandonment that was explored throughout the series. There’s plenty of romance as the obstacles keeping many couples apart are finally dealt with, and the profusion of ribbons and flower petals sprinkled over all the panels will be enough to make any shoujo fan happy. There are bonus side stories in this volume as well, giving the reader the opportunity to visit with favorite characters one last time. Hands down, this is my favorite Tanemura series. Highly recommended! – Anna N

Soul Eater, Vol. 23 | By Atsushi Ohkubo | Yen Press – The major event in this volume is Kid’s journey to ask the witches for help, assisted by allies such as Kim as well as prisoners like Erika. As you can imagine, it doesn’t go well at first, but Kid’s willingness to put pride aside when it comes to the safety of the world is important, and a major development for him. He even stops being OCD about symmetry briefly! Meanwhile, Maka and Black*Star join the battle on the moon, and it’s noted that they’re not merely very powerful students, but “freaks”, the sort of soldiers you hold back toill the last minute. Which has now come, as Crona seems to have woken Asura, who is finalyl making his terifying appearance. Can’t wait for the next volume. – Sean Gaffney

Sword Art Online: Fairy Dance, Vol. 2 | By Reki Kawahara, abec, and Tsubasa Haduki | Yen Press – There’s a few brief moments in the real world here that are intriguing, with Kazuto finding it hard to reconnect with a non-fantasy life, and his love for Asuna being driven home to Suguha. The majority, however, takes place in Alfheim, with Kirito showing off his mad gaming skills in large battles, and Asuna attempting to escape and find out exactly why she and the others are trapped there. I knew she would end up recaptured, so wasn’t bothered by that – but framing it as slug-like tentacle things capturing her, along with the coarse breast size discussion in the author afterword, left a bad taste in my mouth. I may stick to the light novels in the future. – Sean Gaffney

This week, Sean, Anna, & Michelle look at recent releases from Kodansha Comics, Viz Media, Yen Press, and Seven Seas.

Attack on Titan Junior High, Vol. 2 | By Saki Nakagawa | Kodansha Comics – A word of warning: as with the first volume, if you think that accurate translation is the most important thing in a North American release, this volume may make you catch fire just by touching it. If, on the other hand, you’re looking for an adaptation bursting with ridiculous humor, you’ve come to the right place. Even when the manga tries briefly to run with a serious plotline, it’s not only filled with multiple gags per page, but it undercuts the serious by talking about how crappy the Naruto manga’s become as it’s ending. There’s Eren being racist, Hange being hyper, Ymir loving (and insulting) Krista, and the introduction of Erwin and Hannes to the series. This is tremendously stupid, in all the best ways. – Sean Gaffney

Black Rose Alice, Vol. 2 | By Setona Mizushiro | Viz Media – I really was not prepared for Black Rose Alice to get more awesome, but that’s exactly what it does in its second volume. The transplanted soul of 28-year-old teacher Azusa Kikukawa awakes in the 16-year-old body that once belonged to a Viennese aristocrat whom vampire Dimitri once loved and learns exactly what’s expected of her in exchange for Dimitri saving her lover’s life. What is expected is pretty dark, but Mizushiro-sensei sort of half-buries this with cuteness, resulting in a volume with a really interesting and inescapable undercurrent. Honestly, reading this manga feels somewhat like reading a novel, so sure-footed is the storytelling and characterization, but with the added benefit of some terrific non-verbal reaction shots, especially from Dimitri and Kai, one of the vampires vying for the chance to propagate with Azusa (now renamed Alice). This is fascinating stuff. Get on board! – Michelle Smith

A Bride’s Story, Vol. 6 | By Kaoru Mori | Yen Press – I think I’m finally starting to be won over in regards to Amir. I had trouble getting a handle on her in the first few volumes, finding her a bit too detached for my tastes. But we return to her after a few volumes’ absence now, and she has a lot to be emotional about – her family has now come to take her back by force, even though some of her brothers may disagree with this; said family is allying with treacherous Russian gun-runners; and Karluk is growing up, and chafing at still being considered a child. This culminates in a magnificent battle, drawn with verve and attention to detail. It looks like we’ll be following a new bride in the next volume, so I appreciate that we saw Amir and company here again – and I like her a lot more now. – Sean Gaffney

Food Wars, Vol. 3 | By Yuto Tsukuda and Shun Saeki – This series is slowly winning me over. I enjoyed the third volume of Food Wars much more than previous volumes. The elite cooking academy goes to a resort, not for a relaxing vacation but for grueling tests with the harshest taskmasters possible – successful graduates of their school. Soma finally meets a rival worthy of his attention when the half-Japanese half-Italian Takumi Aldini shows up and promptly challenges him. Takumi has a tendency to make aggressive pronouncements that then turn out to be very anti-climatic, but his approach to food is similar to Soma’s. Seeing the students of cuisine being pitted against the quirky graduates of their program was amusing, and I’m looking forward to the next volume. – Anna N

Gangsta, Vol. 4 | By Kohske | Viz Media – Between Gangsta and Dorohedoro, it may be that the most violent titles on the manga market at the moment are both being drawn by women, which is awesome. There’s also more of the complex plot, as we find one of the new villains is an old childhood friend of Worick and Nicholas, and that there’s a group – supported it seems by the general populace – who simply want all Twilights wiped out entirely. There’s also Alex, who not only can’t escape her past – she’s still being told prostitute is her best and possibly only option – but also recalls she is searching for her brother, whose appearance at the end of this volume is one of the least shocking plot twists ever. Complex, but also fun to read. – Sean Gaffney

Kokoro Connect, Vol. 2 | By Sadanatsu Anda and CUTEG | Seven Seas – After a first volume establishing the mind-swapping premise, things settle down here into more prosaic matters – a love triangle and teenage angst. In fact, the teenage angst is a particularly good spotlight. as Inaba stresses herself into being sick over worries that, once revealed, turn out to be fairly ordinary. This manga seems to be about secrets that can’t help but be revealed, so it’s nice to see that some of what folks think is a huge secret turns out to be no big deal. (Also, it’s refreshing to see a female character admit they masturbate in a non-porn title.) I suspect Iori’s worries are more complicated and harder to magically fix, and also that Taichi is not the best one to do it. We’ll see what happens. – Sean Gaffney

Phantom Thief Jeanne, Vol. 5 | By Arina Tanemura | Viz Media – Phantom Thief Jeanne comes to an end with this volume, wrapping up in a thoroughly shoujotastic yet satisfying fashion. After resolving the cliffhanger from the end of the last volume, things begin moving quickly. Maron ends up meeting God (depicted as a glowing ball of light), who drafts her to participate in one final fight against the Demon Lord. I wondered how this would work, since Jeanne basically has no powers aside from sealing demons located in paintings, but I should’ve known it would play out in the most magical girl way possible. So, maybe the resolution was a little too easy, but I really can’t argue about any aspect of it. I particularly enjoyed seeing the eventual fate of a couple of supporting characters who are finally able to find happiness together. Definitely recommended. – Michelle Smith

This week, Sean and Michelle look at recent releases from Viz Media and Kodansha Comics.

Blue Exorcist, Vol. 12 | By Kazue Kato | Viz Media – This volume essentially has two functions, both of which it performs very well. It gives some backstory and depth to Izumo, who has had a lot to do but whose past has been unclear to us. We get a big flashback here, and no surprises: her past was horrible. Now she’s been captured by the latest big villains, which include a surprising member. This betrayal comes as something of a surprise, and there’s no real sense yet that it’s for show and said person will really turn good later, so you can sympathize with everyone’s frustration. We also briefly see Lucifer, who makes a big impression by being able to terrify even Mephisto. Blue Exorcist continues to be one of the jewels in Viz’s shonen crown.-Sean Gaffney

Cage of Eden, Vol. 16 | By Yoshinobu Yamada | Kodansha Comics – I’ve always sort of sighed and shook my head at this series’ fanservice, but the cover of this volume actually caused me to let out an annoyed grunt. Women tied up and in peril while our heroes stand shocked and the villain sneers. Must we? Luckily, the content continues to be better once you get past this, as we continue to fight the evil doctor and discover more about the island – it’s seemingly near Japan, and the prehistoric animals we’ve seen (remember them?) all may have actually been part of a giant experiment. That said, we haven’t had a main cast death in a while, and it’s worrying. Is Kurusu-sensei the next one to go? Or will they be able to defeat their tormentor once more? Soap opera fun with much service.-Sean Gaffney

Nisekoi: False Love, Vol. 6 | By Naoshi Komi | Viz Media – Harem manga that are as balanced as this one are something of a rarity. While you get the vague sense that Chitoge will wind up the winner simply due to narrative structure and Japan’s love of tsunderes, it’s not obvious every single chapter like it is in many other series such as Love Hina. Chitoge may get to play Juliet in the end, but it’s Onodera who gets the bit rooftop romantic scene at the end. Speaking of Chitoge, her realization that she loves Raku leads to their biggest fight, as he hasn’t realized much of anything, so can’t understand why his words are hurting her. There’s nothing new and unique here, but it’s well-written and makes you like everyone, which is always nice to see in a romantic comedy like this. – Sean Gaffney

Oresama Teacher, Vol. 17 | By Izumi Tsubaki | Viz Media – The last few volumes of Oresama Teacher have been consistently good—maybe it’s time to officially come down in favor of the series. In volume seventeen, Yui has been blackmailing members of the Public Morals Club in order to get them to quit, and eventually realizes he’s been using Miyabi’s orders as an excuse not to have to think for himself. Honestly, it was predictable that Yui would repent and seek to rejoin his friends in the club, but that didn’t make it any less satisfying. Plus, there was pigeon symbolism! Too, I like that Miyabi seems to actively be trying to help the members of the student council change. Could he actually be a decent person? His cryptic warning about Hayasaka is pretty durn intriguing, too. Translation: bring on volume eighteen! – Michelle Smith

Rin-Ne, Vol. 16 | By Rumiko Takahashi | Viz Media – As Rin-Ne heads towards its anime, which is finally happening sometime next year, the plot seems to be moving slower than ever. Is there even a plot? Most of the volumes have included something that advances plot and characterization even if it’s only in a token way, but this one consists entirely of unconnected one-shots. They’re well-written – Takahashi may be trying to be a hack here, but she can’t quite pull it off – and I enjoyed the humor, but it’s telling that this review sounds exactly the same as the last 10 reviews of Rin-Ne I’ve written. At least the anime won’t have to worry too much about ending differently than the canon – judging by this volume, any resolution is a long way away. – Sean Gaffney

Spell of Desire, Vol. 2 | By Tomu Ohmi | Viz Media – I ended up liking the first volume of Spell of Desire more than I expected, and it’s probably because of that that I ended up being disappointed by volume two. There’s just not a lot of plot here, until the very end when Kaoruko and Kaname are summoned before the black witches coven. Before that, it’s pages upon pages of Kaoruko reflecting rhapsodically—usually with teary, heavy-lidded eyes—upon Kaname’s kisses and trying to convince herself that what she feels for him is due to the magic power compelling her to reciprocate. When she finally admits to herself that she loves him, it’s a relief rather than any sort of revelation. I suppose something more interesting could happen in the next volume, but now I really wouldn’t bet on it. At least this series is only five volumes long. – Michelle Smith

UQ Holder, Vol. 3 | By Ken Akamatsu | Kodansha Comics -Akamatsu may begun this sequel to Negima by telling fans most of the girls they loved were dead, but that doesn’t mean he’s totally moving on. His grandson here shows off his new use of Magia Erebea, Negi’s signature powers, and though he has no idea what they are he can use them instinctively. Meanwhile, one of the villains turns out to be a frustrated idealist who found he couldn’t compete with the ungodly powers of Negi’s generation – watch for silhouettes, fans of Zazie, Mana and Chachamaru. That said, this is still Tota’s story, and he gets to show off, while Kuromaru continues to wrestle with gender issues and Karin faces a villain who can be very clever about getting rid of her. Good action shonen. – Sean Gaffney