manga bookshelf

Bookshelf Briefs 3/28/11

Welcome to the first installment of Bookshelf Briefs, a new, weekly collection of short reviews from the Manga Bookshelf crew covering both recent releases and some blasts from the past. This week, David, Kate, and Melinda look at ongoing series from Viz Media and Yen Press, while guest Michelle Smith chimes in with an oldie from Dark Horse.

Black Butler, vol. 5 | by Yana Toboso | Yen Press – The fifth volume of Black Butler pits Sebastian against a rival butler in a curry cook-off reminiscent of an Iron Chef episode. (Queen Victoria stands in for Chairman Kaga as the ultimate arbiter of whose curry reigns supreme.) As inspired a development as the curry battle may be, it reveals the biggest problem with Black Butler: the story relies so heavily on gruesome supernatural plot twists that the narrative comes to a grinding halt whenever Yana Toboso depicts more mundane situations. The supporting characters are two-dimensional at best, doomed to sound the same notes over and over, while Sebastian is so relentlessly perfect that the outcome of every conflict is never in doubt. About the best I can say for volume five is that Toboso pulls out all the stops while drawing the interior of the Crystal Palace; every steel arch and palm tree are rendered with loving precision. – Katherine Dacey

Itsuwaribito vol. 2 | by Yuuki Iinuma | Viz Media – This series has such a terrific premise – an habitual liar decides to use his inherent dishonesty to help people – that I keep hoping it will start to make the most of it. Unfortunately, Utsuho is a rather inscrutable protagonist, and there aren’t enough hints at hidden depths to give his adventures the kind of weight the premise promises. It’s pleasant and attractively drawn, but it doesn’t really go any farther than that. Iinuma could build an interesting and novel mythology with the underlying idea, which could transform the series into something quite special. I’ll probably stick with it for a bit longer to see if that happens. – David Welsh

Kimi ni Todoke, vol. 7 | by Karuho Shiina | Viz Media – Sawako’s slowly burgeoning relationship with Kazehaya leaps boldly forward in this installment, leaving Sawako finally certain of her own feelings. Unfortunately, insecurity prevents her from recognizing that those feelings are returned. Though the pace of this series remains as leisurely as the growth of its heroine’s self-confidence, its unabashed sweetness saves this from ever becoming stale. Shiina’s smart, honest writing and expressive artwork serve as a how-to manual for creating effective shoujo manga, with a touch of wry humor as a special bonus. A scene in which Chizu and Ayane give Sawako a whirlwind makeover is worth the cover price, alone. Still recommended.– Melinda Beasi

Seiho Boys’ High School!, vol. 4 | by Kaneyoshi Izumi | Viz Media -Though Seiho Boys’ High School pretends to be a soap opera about hunky, horny guys trapped at a geographically isolated boarding school, it’s actually a smart comedy about teenage dating rituals. Male and female characters alike struggle mightily to impress the opposite sex: they pretend to be easygoing, or feign indifference, or mistake friendship for romantic attraction, embarrassing themselves in the process. In keeping with the realistic spirit of the comedy, Kaneyoshi Izumi doesn’t always find a way to unite her would-be couples; their interactions are as messy and complicated as real-life relationships, even if her characters are handier with snappy one-liners than most teenagers. Only the dorm room hijinks fall flat, with predictable jokes about the slovenly habits of the adolescent male — a minor complaint about an otherwise entertaining series. Recommended. – Katherine Dacey

Seiho Boys’ High School!, vol. 5 | by Kaneyoshi Izumi | Viz Media – A series of ghost sightings at Seiho High force Maki to confront his lingering feelings for the love of his past, while his present girlfriend pushes for some understanding of where she stands. Meanwhile, Hana finds a new calling in providing photos of his classmates to a nearby girls’ school, and townie Fuyuka makes unexpected progress with her crush, Kamiki. Kaneyoshi Izumi may not be revolutionizing the genre, but she’s surely livening it up with this decidedly indelicate, humorous look at the inner lives of boys left to wallow in each others’ company. As a die-hard fan of shoujo, it’s hard not to be charmed as she alternately mocks and pacifies her readers, and her increasing focus on deeper characterization only makes the series stronger. Five volumes in, Seiho continues to be one of Shojo Beat’s most enjoyable current reads. – Melinda Beasi

Toriko, vol. 3 | by Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro | Viz Media – It’s hard to imagine a manga that both Ted Nugent and Michael Pollan could agree on, but Toriko comes pretty close: while it celebrates the manly valor of hunting game, it also focuses on the importance of eating “real” food. (Or what counts for “real” food in the fantasy-universe of the manga.) The tonal shifts can be dramatic, with characters waxing poetic about the delicate properties of puffer whale meat in one panel and engaging in brutal, hand-to-hand combat with rival gourmet hunters in the next, but the prevailing spirit is exuberant; every line of dialogue is delivered with emphatic punctuation, and every character seems thoroughly committed to the pursuit of delicacies. I’d be the first to admit that many of the game animals seem more ferocious than delicious, but Mitsutoshi Shimabukuro’s feverish energy and imagination help sell the more improbable story lines. Recommended.
– Katherine Dacey

From the Archives

Metropolis | by Osamu Tezuka | Dark Horse – According to the back cover, the 1949 Tezuka work Metropolis inspired an “astonishing” animated film. Alas, it didn’t inspire me much. For the most part, the narrative consists of a band of vertically challenged middle-aged sleuths pursuing an over-the-top villain who is himself pursuing Michi, an artificial being who is neither male nor female. Later, the villain’s robot slaves, led by Michi, stage a revolt. True, one could talk about the themes present in the work, most notably that life is sacred, no matter if it’s biological or artificial, but the story zooms by too quickly for anything to make much of an impact. I’m left wondering what Naoki Urasawa could make of this one. – Michelle Smith

Did you enjoy this article? Consider supporting us.


  1. I didn’t like Seiho Boys’ High School much. Well, maybe it is because I didn’t give it a chance by reading beyond volume 1. From this list, the only one I really love and enjoy is Karuho Shiina’s Kimi ni Todoke. I just love how slow the relationship develops between Kazehaya and Sawako. The thing I like about this series the most is that it is not your typical, predictable shoujo where you know who is going to end up with who. Honestly, I am getting tired of those typical love stories. Back to Kimi ni Todoke, it has a great cast of characters. I actually am more interested in the other characters such as Chizu, Ayane and Pin. Don’t get me wrong. I love both Kazehaya and Sawako but I am finding myself more curious about the others especially Ayane. It sure will be interesting to see who she is going to end up with. I have a faint idea about Chizu but Ayane is a different matter. Even Kurumi is an interesting one. One of the rivals that I never hated.

    Can’t wait for volume 8 to come out. Truly one of the best shoujo series and I definitely hope it won’t end anytime soon.

    • Obviously I can’t know if you’d like Seiho, but it does shift pretty dramatically in volume two. here is my review of the first two volumes if that gives you an idea of whether you’d like to try more. I was grateful that I read the first two volumes together, because that was key in forming a positive opinion about the series from the get-go.

    • Katherine Dacey says:

      Hi, Noura! I didn’t like the first volume of Seiho either, but it started to grow on me with subsequent volumes. I won’t claim it’s brilliant, but it definitely gets better (and much less predictable) as it goes along. Once the artist gets all the “boys are messy!” and “boys have secret porn stashes!” scenes out of the way, the stories have more interesting places to go, if that makes sense.

  2. Hee, for a few minutes I thought Seiho Boys’ High School was the the book Kate was panning not too long ago about the girl getting sent to the boys’ school to ‘straighten her out.’ I was seriously confused how that could possibly turn out well enough that you’d eventually recommend it.

    • Katherine Dacey says:

      I can’t imagine how the creator of The Beautiful Skies of Houhou High could possibly right that ship, though it’s entertaining to speculate on what she could do to redeem its awful premise.

  3. The sad thing is, that story arc of Black Butler is really the one I enjoyed, because I’m just a fan of the Iron Chef style of dramatics. I was all, CHOCOLATES? HAND GROUND SPICE? BRING IT ON! Then I remembered that Black Butler was actually about demons and black magic handwaving and questionable master-servant relationships and got bored again.

    • Katherine Dacey says:

      I was intrigued by the idea of adding chocolate to curry, too, though the characters spent so much time talking that I quickly got tired of the cook-off. It’s never a good sign when you find yourself thinking, “Aren’t we overdue for another serial murderer?”

      • Just Someguy says:

        Chocolate and spice actually go rather well together. Cinnamon’s a classic, but curry powder works as well


  1. […] Smith, David Welsh, and I will be teaming up to produce capsule reviews of new and upcoming manga. For our inaugural column, we’ve chosen a mixture of VIZ and Yen Press titles that includes volume five of Black […]

  2. […] current Pick of the Week, so go take a look. While you’re there, take a look at our new feature, Bookshelf Briefs, capsule reviews of current volumes with some wild cards thrown in from time to time. Now, on to […]

  3. […] David, Kate, and Melinda launch a new column of short reviews, Bookshelf Briefs, at Manga Bookshelf. Carlo Santos takes us through a stack of recent releases in his latest Right […]

  4. […] In other, non-Cross Game and, for that reason, lesser Viz news, there’s the second volume of Yuuki Iinuma’s Itsuwaribito, which seems like a series that could go somewhere interesting, though this volume didn’t particularly impress me. […]

Before leaving a comment at Manga Bookshelf, please read our Comment Policy.

Speak Your Mind