manga bookshelf

Off the Shelf: Princess Knight

MICHELLE: As we occasionally do when the Manga Moveable Feast rolls around, Melinda and I have opted to dedicate this week’s Off the Shelf column to the topic at hand, which this month is the works of Osamu Tezuka. Specifically for our case, we’re going to be talking about Princess Knight, Tezuka’s shoujo manga about Sapphire, a princess who accidentally receives both a boy’s heart and a girl’s heart at the time of her birth, and who, when we pick up her story as an adolescent, has somewhat of an identity crisis while undergoing many wacky hardships/hijinks.

This is my first time reading the series. Whenever Ed Chavez from Vertical would solicit suggestions for Tezuka titles to license, I would always request Princess Knight. I wanted the series so much I even bought a few of the bilingual Kodansha editions. However, when I finally had both parts of the series in hand, I was content for a while to merely gaze upon them, content. And now that I have finally gotten around to reading it, I must say… I’m a little disappointed.

MELINDA: Well, as you may recall, I certainly had my issues with volume one, and these didn’t disappear when I read volume two. In some ways, I’d even say they became more pronounced. On the other hand, there were things I liked about it, so though I could characterize my experience as disappointing as well, I’m still glad I read it.

Should we get the least pleasant subjects out of the way straight off?

MICHELLE: Might as well. I guess my big problem with it is that it’s supposed to be so groundbreaking in terms of gender identities, but it actually does very little in this regard. When Sapphire has only a boy heart, she’s swaggering and brave. When she has only her girl heart, she’s weak and fragile. True, some of the growl-inducing comments do come from the villains or from those attempting to fool villains by approximating girlish behavior (“I suddenly want to take up cross-stitching and play the piano.”) but I do have to wonder how much of it Tezuka really believes, since he creates a swordswoman character, only to bedeck her armor with hearts and have her proudly admit that she’s entered a tournament to find a husband.

MELINDA: Yes, this was definitely the biggest hurdle for me as well. While I might have found it interesting to watch a character struggle with her gender identity in a society where clearly what you describe is set up as the standard for femininity vs. masculinity, that’s not really what Tezuka does here at all. Even when he has his chances to challenge these roles, he passes them up. For instance, the big female revolt that happens during the second volume seems to hinge mainly on the threat of the country’s men being left without anyone to clean their homes or look after their children. Even after it’s over, the only comment made by one of the defeated men is relief that his wife will come home and take care of the laundry that’s piled up.

I completely understand that both Tezuka and Princess Knight are a product of their time, but I’m genuinely confused as to why this seems to be held up as a great example of shoujo manga challenging gender roles.

MICHELLE: It seems very likely that Tezuka never intended it to be so, since so much of it takes a Loony Tunes approach to storytelling. Why, indeed, take a female revolt seriously? Instead, let’s play it for comedy by making the men out to be henpecked morons! That’s not to say there aren’t some darker aspects that I did like and wish could’ve been expounded upon. For example, while I don’t care about or believe in the “true love” that suddenly springs up between Sapphire and Prince Franz Charming, the characters set up as romantic rivals are actually interesting and meet tragic fates. It makes me wonder what kind of story Tezuka could’ve fashioned with Hecate and Captain Blood (aka Heinrich) as the leads!

MELINDA: Yes! Though I actually quite liked Sapphire, at least until she became completely consumed by her weirdly passive pursuit of Prince Franz, my favorite characters were Captain Blood and Hecate. I would have happily read entire books about them. I rather wished that Sapphire would ditch Franz and fall for Blood, but I suppose it was never meant to be.

MICHELLE: And, really, Hecate is probably the best example of a character who defies gender roles, since she’s perfectly happy defining herself for herself and has no wish to consume Sapphire’s girl heart (which her witch mother, Madame Hell, keeps trying to steal on her behalf) and take up some passive, “feminine” identity. She’s independent, level-headed, and one of the few truly good characters in the story. Plus, she can turn herself into a goat!

MELINDA: Speaking of all the heart-exchanging business, I’d say that probably the only time I actually appreciated it, was when Plastic ingests Sapphire’s boy’s heart, and suddenly becomes a decent man, instead of a selfish, sniveling boob.

MICHELLE: Oh yes, I quite agree! And he promptly begins championing women’s rights! This makes him the second character in the series (after Hecate) to go his own way and oppose the evil schemes of a parent. I wonder if this is Tezuka’s way of saying that the younger generation is going to get things right regarding equality whereas their parents are hopeless.

MELINDA: That may be a generous assumption, but I’ll give it to him if you will. You know, I think what’s most disappointing to me about Princess Knight is that I feel like I really could have liked it. Tezuka’s artwork is so much fun here, and so full of life. And I’m really fine with the “Looney Tunes approach,” as you so brilliantly put it. I think this manga could have been a lot of fun. But the gender issues are so profound, they kinda take over the whole thing for me.

MICHELLE: I’m not sure I could’ve liked it even without the gender issues giving me fits. The plotting is just so random sometimes. Early on, there’s a scene where Sapphire is letting herself be collected by Duke Duralumin’s men as a potential consort for his then-still-feeble-minded son, Plastic. And Franz rides in from, like, the next kingdom over to rescue her, and then rides back home again a few panels later. Or then there’s my favorite spot of wtf, the scene where Blood quickly escapes slavery by coercing a nearby beetle into chewing through some ropes. Everything’s so fast, furious, and madcap that poignant things aren’t given time to sink in.

MELINDA: Hee hee, yeah, it’s like that. Is it wrong that I find that fun? Or maybe I find it fun, because the poignant stuff doesn’t sit right. I can enjoy something that’s silly and madcap for that alone, and Princess Knight works better as that for me. Overall, I’d say I liked the silly, unbelievable parts the most. Also, I love every scene that Blood is in. Heh.

MICHELLE: It’s not wrong for anyone to like what they like! :) I’m just hard to please, comedy-wise, so many of the gags just left me blinking impassively at the page. I feel bad for being so down on Princess Knight, because now that it’s over I find myself growing fond of the idea of it again. And though it may not have lived up to its reputation for me, I nonetheless wonder if it wasn’t the origin of certain shoujo tropes, like, say, all of the guys instantly falling in love with the passive heroine, or the contingent of jealous fangirls.

MELINDA: As disappointed as I might have been with it, I really am grateful to have had the opportunity to read it. It may not be my favorite of Tezuka’s works (or really even close), but I’m quite enamored of his artwork, as always, and even now as I’m just flipping through, I’m struck by the beauty and flow of what’s on the page.

MICHELLE: Oh, I am definitely exceedingly grateful to the folks at Vertical for licensing the work and producing such a beautiful edition. I’m also pleased to note that I didn’t spot a single typo in their text, and found that the translation actually included some rather sophisticated words without any hint of awkwardness.

MELINDA: So thanks, Vertical, for giving us the chance to experience Princess Knight!

For more of this week’s MMF bounty, please visit the Osamu Tezuka MMF Archive, hosted by Kate Dacey at The Manga Critic!


More full-series discussions with Melinda & Michelle:

Fullmetal Alchemist | Paradise Kiss | The “Color of…” Trilogy | One Thousand and One Nights| Please Save My Earth
Fruits Basket | Wild Adapter (with guest David Welsh)

Full-series multi-guest roundtables: Hikaru no Go | Banana Fish | Gerard & Jacques | Flower of Life

Did you enjoy this article? Consider supporting us.

Comments

  1. “I feel bad for being so down on Princess Knight, because now that it’s over I find myself growing fond of the idea of it again.”

    I feel very much the same way! I didn’t like Princess Knight nearly as much as I was hoping, although I did find parts of it a lot of fun. I somehow enjoy Princess Knight more thinking back on it than I did while I was actually reading the series.

  2. I recently got this in and read it myself. There were definitely parts I quite liked, I’d been curious where Hecate came from ever since I played Astro Boy: Omega Factor (it only says that she’s “The daughter of the devil” but not what series she was from) and she was easily my favorite character (turning into a cat was another big plus as I’m a total cat person). I feel like she was certainly the character most comfortable in her own skin and she was a joy to watch, every Hecate scene made me quite happy! Except, y’know, that one towards the end. And yeah, the action was fast paced, but I enjoyed it too, it was a fun adventure style thing, even if I thought the ending was incredibly rushed on it. I enjoyed that it wasn’t just a romance, it had action too.
    But yeah, when Sapphire loses her boy-heart mid-battle and suddenly can’t fight, my reaction was “Really, Tezuka? Really? You’re going with this?” and a lot of the character changes that occurred due to having a heart added or removed was kinda “Really?” But then I noticed later that Sapphire with only a girl heart seemed to be able to fight perfectly well which rather confused me, internal consistency please?
    But I also did like the swordswoman and her brother/king (who played the moron pretty well, but unlike pre-boy heart Prince Plastic, was actually smart and interesting). sure, the girl immediately goes “I’m doing this to find a man”, but seriously, Belle falls in love with her captor, and that movie was made in the 90s! Every Disney princess’ goal seems to be “to get a man”, I can’t say the trope has at all disappeared. It’s not like that trope has disappeared and this was one of the less offensive “I just need a man” examples I’ve seen. Besides, she doesn’t fall in love with the first guy to make eye contact, that’s definitely a step above Sapphire in that department. But then the king also says at the end that his sister isn’t a rare special flower who can go into danger and fight, there’s plenty out there, that endeared me to the two of them pretty well.

    And once again, I’m curious what the Shojo Club edition was like! Tezuka re-doing stuff was common, it always makes me wonder what the original was like. I’m sure they were both products of their time, makes me wonder what the earlier version was like. Most of his stuff has a “product of its time” feel, I can let some stuff slide, some stuff is a bit tougher to let slide, this was one manga where it was harder to let stuff slide. But if you’ve ever seen episodes of Wife Swap where one house has the woman believing all women should be stay at home slaves (because they read some book written in the 60s), yeah, this feminism isn’t at all bad.

    • Oh yeah, I’d meant to comment about Sapphire being able to fight perfectly well as a girl in that tournament. Maybe because she didn’t remember that the boy heart was removed, she didn’t believe she was now weak, and therefore wasn’t? That could’ve been made more clear.

      I also like Fiebe (sp?) and her brother, Oolong. I especially like when he jokes about marrying Sapphire, since several others have already wanted to do that in the course of the series. :)

      • I also meant to mention that I liked Fiebe (yeah, I’m not sure of the spelling either)! And also Sapphire’s fighting with her girl heart. At the time, I thought maybe the series would actually turn down the road you mention here, Michelle, where Sapphire ends up becoming the strong girl she’s meant to me, because she forgets to conform to what she’s learned about being a girl or boy. But this was completely dropped later on, to my disappointment.

        • That would’ve redeemed the series greatly, had Tezuka gone that route. That would’ve put all of the gender-conforming dialogue we heard earlier into perspective, because it is true that her early caregivers very clearly delineated “things a prince likes/does” from “things a princess likes/does” from the start.

  3. Hee~ so I wasn’t the only one to wish for Hecate and Blood to get together and kick some a$$. Imagine my disappointment when my favorite character got killed off as some convenient plot moving device for Charming and Saphire to get their acts together.
    I am also interested to know what the original edition was like. Because I thought this longer version was too long. Throw obstacles after obstacles, but nothing really gets accomplished once she clears her hurdle. I actually already own the bilingual edition when Vertical announced their release. I bought the new edition because folks at ANN said it’d be the Shojo Club version. Turns out not. >_<



Trackbacks

  1. [...] Beasi and Michelle Smith discuss Princess Knight in their latest Off the Shelf column at Manga [...]

  2. [...] Blog Log) Anna on vol. 1 of Princess Knight (Manga Report) Melinda Beasi and Michelle Smith on vols. 1 and 2 of Princess Knight (Manga Bookshelf) Lori Henderson on vols. 1 and 2 of Princess Knight (Manga Xanadu) David Gromer on [...]

  3. [...] Beasi and Michelle Smith discuss Osamu Tezuka’s Princess Knight in their Off the Shelf column at Manga [...]

  4. [...] | The “Color of…” Trilogy | One Thousand and One Nights| Please Save My Earth Princess Knight | Fruits Basket | Wild Adapter (with guest David [...]

  5. [...] The “Color of…” Trilogy | One Thousand and One Nights | Please Save My Earth Princess Knight | Fruits Basket | Wild Adapter (with guest David [...]

  6. [...] After experiencing some disappointment with the story of Princess Knight, another historically significant work whose English release I [...]

  7. […] Princess Knight at Manga Bookshelf: Manga Artifacts: Princess Knight (Katherine Dacey) | Off the Shelf: Princess Knight (Melinda Beasi & Michelle […]



Before leaving a comment at Manga Bookshelf, please read our Comment Policy.

Speak Your Mind

*