One Thousand and One Nights, Volume 7

I have a mini review out at PCS today for volume seven of manhwa series One Thousand and One Nights. This is such a beautiful and well-crafted series, and I could easily have written a full-length review of this volume so I will add some things here that I did not have room to say in my mini. Bonus: I get to say them here with wholly unprofessional abandon. :)

First of all, let me address the new political turn the series has taken, because that’s probably the thing that most sets this volume apart from the others. Though politically and theologically I’m sure it would be easy to poke at some of the author’s statements made through the characters (Sehara, mainly), but to do that would be missing the point. Fiction is all about expressing ideas, which is what the author does here–and very effectively at that. His notes at the back of the book are incredibly revealing, too. “There are always greedy people who have profited from war. They create a reason for war, and the rest of us go along with it. Young and innocent lives are uselessly sacrificed,” he says, mentioning too that at the time of his writing, Korea had the third highest number of soldiers in Iraq (after the US and England).

Even if he had not written these notes, however, his point is made clearly through his storytelling, and this is one of the things I love most about fiction. The story-within-a-story in this volume speeds ahead to present day, where an American soldier is trapped in the desert with a young Iraqi boy who has been manipulated into becoming a suicide bomber by a man who promises to pay for much-needed medical treatment for the boy’s sister after he is gone. There are a few clumsy bits, mainly due to the story’s nebulous timeline, but overall the author’s ideas are introduced very well and feel very much in place with the rest of the series.

All of that aside, however, the real draw of this series is the romance. Perhaps it seems odd for me to call it that when the series hasn’t entirely acknowledged it, but man I haven’t read anything so honestly romantic in quite some time.

“A Bard from the west once told me the story of King Arthur and his knights,” says Sehara to the English king. “He also told me that you are a wise and kind king who is loved by his people. Some say you are King Arthur, returned from Avalon.” “I love the people of England,” says the king. To which Sehara replies, “And I love the Sultan of Baghdad.”

Sehara’s quiet devotion, Shahryar’s intense fire, the painfully dramatic ending of this volume which I will not give away–oh, it is almost more romance than I can bear, though I’d fight anyone who tried to take it away from me. This is the kind of story that I read for in the first place, and it is a pleasure to be reminded of it once again. I have no idea how this story is going to end, and more and more it seems nearly impossible to avoid real tragedy. For a character with as much blood on his hands as Shahyrar has, can there be a happy ending? Perhaps, but it is tough to write that ending without the happiness feeling unearned. I guess we shall see. I have a lot of faith in these storytellers, and they have yet to let me down in any significant way.

There are other series I’m reading now that I could say are better comics, and certainly some I love more if I was pressed to choose. But there is something truly special about this series–a timeless, romantic, otherworldly quality that is different than anything else I’m reading and satisfying in a way that is truly all its own. Now I endure the long wait until August when Yen Press will release volume eight.

For more of my long-winded ramblings on the topic of this series, see One Thousand and One Nights, volumes 1-6 and Ash vs. Shahryar.

One comment thread

  1. Renee
    #1

    I discovered this series through your review @ MangaRecon & love it!

    I’m also getting strong whiffs of impending tragedy, as much as I want my happy ending. All the stories Sehara tells end badly for the character who most resembles Sehara (at least through vol 3). I’m hoping it’s an unintentional coincidence or an intentional misdirect…but probably not.

    Sigh. Manhwa, why must you break our hearts?

    Reply

    Melinda Beasi Reply:

    We can keep our fingers crossed for a happy end!

    I am *so* pleased that you picked up this series based on my review! That makes me really happy!

    Reply

Leave a Reply





XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

One Trackback/Ping


Off the Shelf

 Thumbnail
Off the Shelf: ParaChara!

It's all ParaKiss all the time in this week's Off the Shelf! - Welcome to another edition of Off the Shelf with Melinda & Michelle! As always, I'm joined... 

July 28, 2010 | Continue »

MANGA REVIEWS

 Thumbnail
Antique Bakery, Vols. 1-4

As I begin this article, I find myself struck by the impossibility of saying anything about Antique Bakery that hasn't already been said. Undoubtedly... 

July 24, 2010 | Continue »

 Thumbnail
Ooku, Vols. 1-3

In this alternate history of Edo-period Japan, an incurable disease has wiped out much of the nation's male population, leaving women to take up traditional... 

July 22, 2010 | Continue »

 Thumbnail
Garden Dreams

Garden Dreams tells the story of Farhad, a young boy orphaned by the Crusades, who is rescued from the desert by Saud, one of his own people who has lost... 

July 20, 2010 | Continue »

MANHWA REVIEWS

 Thumbnail
Magical JxR, Vol. 1

Jay and Aru are young wizards, ready to graduate from wizarding school. To fulfill their final graduation test, they must make a contract to help a human... 

July 4, 2010 | Continue »

BL BOOKRACK

 Thumbnail
BL Bookrack: Yoshinaga Special

Welcome to the first edition of BL Bookrack, a new, monthly feature co-written with Soliloquy in Blue's Michelle Smith. Once a month, in place of our weekly... 

July 21, 2010 | Continue »



Archives

read manga online

Recent Comments

Affiliates & Sponsors