manga bookshelf

Bookshelf Briefs 11/19/12

This week, Sean, Melinda, & Michelle look at recent releases from VIZ Media and Yen Press.

Blue Exorcist, Vol. 8 | By Kazue Kato | VIZ Media – For the most part this is a typical Jump battle volume, meaning there’s lots of fighting and enemies vanquished, but not as much to really mention in a review. There’s enough to really enjoy, though. Shiemi showing her gumption in commanding her familiar to help her save Izumo; Renzo having to face up to the fact that doing the right thing is really annoying and hard; and all of Rin and Bon’s fight against the Impure King (who is truly disgusting adn foul, as you would expect from a giant demonic fungus). But it’s Yukio who gets the most attention here, as he’s dealing with the traitor Saburota, who knows just how to get under his skin and hit his weaknesses. Just as Rin feels his brother outshines him, Yukio feels the same. Hopefully it won’t prove to be a problem in future, but the foreshadowing isn’t looking good. -Sean Gaffney

Kamisama Kiss, Vol. 11 | By Julietta Suzuki | VIZ Media – Volumes like this remind me why I keep reading Kamisama Kiss even when it seems that the plot is content to coast along without resolving much. There’s just strong characterization, particularly of the heroine, Nanami. We already knew her father was a scumball from the opening chapter, but the flashbacks we get here show a truly tragic childhood, with the love of her mother (who dies early, in what is hinted to be part of a kamisama’s curse) being one of the few bright spots… and these days Nanami can’t even remember her face. It’s a sign of her strong will that she’s grown up to be the determined young woman she is today, and we see that determination in the second half, where she goes toe to toe with some nameless demons. Cute, intelligent, plucky heroines. What’s not to like? -Sean Gaffney

Kimi ni Todoke: From Me to You, Vol. 15 | By Karuho Shiina | VIZ Media – Although the friendship between Sawako, Chizu, and Ayane has been a central focus of the series since the beginning, at this point in the story it seems like the three of them have truly become co-leads, as they each face their own romantic problems in this volume. Sawako is troubled by a new distance in her relationship with Kazehaya; Ayane is possibly beginning to feel something for Kent, though she insists she’s not as great as he thinks she is; and Chizu is panicking because Ryu’s confession of love means the end of the sibling-like relationship they’ve shared since childhood. There’s a long and wonderful flashback to the two of them as kids, proving that she’s always been the one who understood him best, culminating in a surprising display of feeling from Ryu. Honestly, it’s giving me goosebumps just typing about it. How can I possibly wait until April for the next installment?! – Michelle Smith

March Story, Vol. 4 | By Kim Hung-Min and Yan Kyung-Il | VIZ Media – After a very exciting and beautifully-crafted third volume, volume four of March Story focuses on March’s secret gender. On the upside, this plays out much differently than in the all-too-common gender-bending comedy. On the downside, it seems to be part of some kind of grand, coordinated effort to boost the series’ volume of fanservice, which is suddenly in full bloom. The artists pull out all the usual tricks in this volume, including ill-fitting clothing that can’t quite keep from falling off and strategically timed gusts of wind. From this reader’s perspective, it reads as distracting and unnecessary pandering that is below these artists’ abilities, but perhaps it’s just a stern reminder that I’m not the series’ demographic after all. There’s enough genuine substance still in this volume to keep my attention, but I can’t deny that I found it disappointing. – Melinda Beasi

The Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi-chan, Vol. 6 | By Puyo and Nagaru Tanigawa | Yen Press – The goal of this series is to be as silly as possible. And as logn as that goal is in sight, it doesn’t matter how it achieves it. This time around, we get a discussion of fanservice, the continued humiliation of Mori-san, a far larger role for Kunikida than he ever gets in the main series (though he may not be too happy with why that is), and Ryoko and Kimidori-san teaming up to throw Yuki a school festival in the privacy of their own apartment. But the best chapters, in my opinion, are the two that mock the cliched Japanese over-dramatic plotlines, as we see Haruhi discovering she has to transfer and saying goodbye to everyone, followed by a life-or-death struggle to see who’s strongest on Children’s Day. Neither story has an ending, but endings don’t matter. Are they silly. Yes indeed. -Sean Gaffney

Pandora Hearts, Vol. 12 | By Jun Mochizuki | Yen Press – Pandora Hearts doesn’t have the most coherent plotting at the best of times, but volume twelve is more disjointed than most. There’s a lot of exposition here, as the focus shifts towards finding the seals (and their keys) that bind villainous Glen Baskerville and investigating a mysterious, murderous contractor known as “the headhunter.” We go from scenes of Vincent Nightray scheming to seduce Oz’s sister, to Oz’s uncle seeking to dispel the gloomy atmosphere at Pandora by hosting an outdoor tea party, to the group doing some snooping in disguise (with Oz in drag), to everyone attending a fancy dress banquet at the home of a creepy cult leader. This makes for some nice moments—I’m especially fond of the contrast between the female-filtered view of gussied-up Gilbert and the reality—but on the whole, the volume feels rather scattered. That’s not enough to keep me from recommending it, though! – Michelle Smith

Did you enjoy this article? Consider supporting us.


  1. Definitely a great volume of Kimi ni todoke. Loved the flashback to the Ryu and Chizu story when they were kids. So touching and beautiful. I actually love the sibling-like relationship they are sharing but I can’t deny that they are a good match, so I would love to see their relationship develop. In their situation, I don’t mind either way. It would be great if they became more than just friends but I wouldn’t be disappointed if they maintained their current relationship, which I don’t think will happen.

    As for Ayane, I can see that she might be starting to notice Kento and there is a possibility that she is beginning to feel something for him. The thing is, I always wanted something different for Ayane. To me, Kento is a typical shoujo male character and I honestly feel he is a bit boring. Maybe it would have been more interesting if he was with someone else but I don’t feel he and Ayane suit each other. Well, we can only wait and see what Shiina-sensei is planning for her characters.

    • I agree regarding Ryu and Chizu—I wouldn’t be disappointed with either outcome. Also, little kid Ryu was freakin’ adorable. :)

      Honestly, I am not completely feeling the Ayane/Kento relationship much either, but if it’s someone she can be herself with and not be in an immediately physical relationship with, then I can see how it would be something she would want. Even if they’re not together long-term, to realize that she is capable of falling in love would be a big thing for her.

      • I want Ayane to be happy and true to herself, so if Kento is the one who would make her happy, I will not have any complaints. However, I will not deny that I will be a bit disappointed if Kento/Ayane is endgame. Well, I just hope Ayane falls in love and be happy whether it was Kento or someone else.

        I hope Shiina-sensei re-introduces Kurumi into the story as I think she is one of the best characters in this series.

        • If this were a typical shoujo romance, there should be some leftover guy that Kurumi can start going out with so that everyone ends up with someone. Unfortunately, I’m only coming up with the teacher. Pin? Is that his name?

          • Oh, no! Please not Pin and Kurumi. I seriously hope Shiina-sensei doesn’t go there. Some people support this idea but I would be so disappointed if this were to happen. I so want Kurumi to find happiness with someone when she is finally ready to let go of her feelings for Kazehaya but I do not think she and Pin are a good match. If Shiina-sensei is planning to pair Kurumi off with someone, I know it is not likely to happen but I was hoping Kento would fall for her. There are not many available guys left other than Pin and Mogi but I wonder if one of them will be that for Kurumi. There is also the slim chance that a new character might be introduced but I wonder if it will happen this late in the series. Either way, I would be so happy to see Kurumi with someone and finally be able to face Kazehaya and Sawako properly.

            • It could still end up Kento/Kurumi and Pin/Ayane. That would fit pretty well!

              • I would be happy with this outcome but I do not think we will see Kurumi anytime soon. Honestly, if Pin is going to end up with anyone, I want it to be with Ayane but I guess this is hoping for too much at this point. I have a feeling Ayane will be with Kento but whether it will be long-term or not is what I cannot tell. I think it is interesting that this series makes us think really hard and that it is not so easy to predict what is going to happen. This is one of the thing I love about it.

Before leaving a comment at Manga Bookshelf, please read our Comment Policy.

Speak Your Mind